Werewolf XXXVIII: Jack The Ripper (GAME OVER! GOOD WINS ON DAY SEVEN)

[SnDvls]

vote bullet

random day one vote

OOC:I have an ASU basketball game tonight so I won't be on much more tonight

[st.cronin]

Originally Posted by Alan T

I really wish you wouldn't take what I say and then say I'm doing something else.

There are plenty of vocal people out there, and I'm not after any of them. Some of the most vocal people have made my somewhat trusted early list. Others have fallen onto the not early trusted list. The others are in the unknown list.

Who am I voting for? Someone super active? No someone who has been quiet after saying he would be around some during the day. The reason you are suspicious is because the way you felt and made it fairly obvious to me that you dont have the "normal" role that I have. Whether that role you have is good or bad, I'm not sure but it feels very obvious to me that you don't have a generic role at least.

I was willing to leave our discussion as it was with my giving my thoughts on why I felt you were suspicious so far today, and you giving a rebuttle.. but don't come and mischaracterize my suspicion on you. Its absolutely crazy to think I would be after lynching active players on day 1. To even suggest that just feels really off to me. If anyone, I should be known for day 1 going after the Under the radar folks, the newer players, the ones I know the least about. Now you are just making up things.

No, I'm not making things up, but I don't want to have this fight again, honey.

You characterized me as being at least somewhat suspicious. I said "huh?" You pointed to an instance of me thinking out loud, trying to generate some conversation. You know, the stuff I do every game, and end up on the hot seat every game.

For what it's worth, I don't think you, or any of the other active players like Barkeep, hoops, etc., are particularly suspicious yet. And I'm going to move out of my defensive mode now. I'm also going to keep my thoughts to myself for a while now.

[Fouts]

Interesting bandwagon voting there. I consider all 4 of you suspicious.

[st.cronin]

Originally Posted by path12

That bolded part is what I have problems with. It's not just certain roles that can get information, it's most every role as far as I can tell (at least for good).

If you believe that EVERY GOOD ROLE gets information on night 0, then you should vote for me. Your assumption will be proven wrong.

[Blade6119]

Originally Posted by Fouts

Interesting bandwagon voting there. I consider all 4 of you suspicious.

I hope you find me the most so, im still trying to figure out who will be my fight this game

[Alan T]

Originally Posted by Blade6119

I hope you find me the most so, im still trying to figure out who will be my fight this game

I call day 3!

[Fouts]

I have information about Izulde telling me he is not who we want to lynch.

The 4 votes on Izulde have been notified. Do what you will.

[st.cronin]

Originally Posted by Fouts

Interesting bandwagon voting there. I consider all 4 of you suspicious.

Oh, if only the four of us could be wolves together. That would be fun. Based on your other post:

unvote Izulde
vote ntndeacon

[st.cronin]

dola correction

unvote Izulde
vote ntndeacon

[Fouts]

Originally Posted by st.cronin

Oh, if only the four of us could be wolves together. That would be fun. Based on your other post:

unvote Izulde
vote ntndeacon

I'm not saying all 4 are wolves, but good chance 1 of you are.

[path12]

Originally Posted by st.cronin

It gets tiring being seen as suspicious for the same reasons game after game, is all. Making my thought process public is just something I'm going to have to learn not to do.

cronin, I didn't find you suspicious for making your thought process public, I found you suspicious because I saw some discrepancies with what I know to be true. I did say that it was just slightly better than a random reason, but I'm not on any big push to get you lynched. I just needed you to clarify your thoughts.

That said, I'm not going to switch just for the sake of switching. I don't really have a better reason to go on right now, but I would most likely switch if there was a swing your way that looked like it would get to 1/3.

[Blade6119]

UNVOTE IZULDE

VOTE BARKEEP

Back to where i was

[Alan T]

Originally Posted by Fouts

I have information about Izulde telling me he is not who we want to lynch.

The 4 votes on Izulde have been notified. Do what you will.

Fair enough. Like I said, I'm playing hunches and trying to minimalize damage of being wrong on day 1.

Unvote Izulde
Vote Jonathan E.

I'll go option #2 for me then. He and Schmidty both have been as quiet as Izulde, and JE is newer.

JE has made 2 posts this game: "In" and "Checking In."

He was a bit more involved in the discussion last game and impressed me a good bit as a new player last game.

[st.cronin]

I'll hitch my horse to the Alan T train, for good or ill -

unvote ntndeacon
vote Jonathan Ezrarik

[Mr. Wednesday]

Originally Posted by Fouts

Because I think there are multiple prostitutes, and multiple people who visit prostitutes. I am certain there are 2-5 people just like me in this game.

If you put our exchange in context, you were objecting to someone saying that night 0 gave certain roles a jump on everyone else. My observation is that there's no reason "average joe" (or, in this case, "average John" ) shouldn't be one of those "certain roles" that gets a jump.

[bulletsponge]

my head hurts so many changes. i for one did nothing last night and have no information to add to this witch hunt

[Blade6119]

We need 1/3, so im prob. going to follow Alan onto JE, though JE is here now

[Jonathan Ezarik]

Originally Posted by Alan T

Fair enough. Like I said, I'm playing hunches and trying to minimalize damage of being wrong on day 1.

Unvote Izulde
Vote Jonathan E.

I'll go option #2 for me then. He and Schmidty both have been as quiet as Izulde, and JE is newer.

JE has made 2 posts this game: "In" and "Checking In."

He was a bit more involved in the discussion last game and impressed me a good bit as a new player last game.

I haven't been around all afternoon, true. I had some work I had to get done before I could get back online. In the last game I had some idea who was good (you) so it was a bit easier to get into the flow of things. This game I have no idea. I know I'm good, but that's it.

I'm still trying to figure out who to lynch tonight, but I think we have to lynch someone. My original instinct was to go after Barkeep, but I would like to keep him around. Part of me wants to go after ntndeacon because of last game ( ) and part of me wants to lynch st.cronin because he keeps jumping all over the place. I'm going to wait and think this over dinner before I vote.

[st.cronin]

Following players have not voted yet, afaict:

DaddyTorgo
Schmidty
saldana
Lathum
Jonathon
BrianD
LoneStarGirl
RaidersArmy
Izulde

[Fouts]

Deadline in 50 minutes. Bunch of people need to get a vote in.

[Tyrith]

Yeah, Fouts, okay, we'll see how it goes. I'll vote for another quiet person that's taking some votes.

UNVOTE IZULDE
VOTE NTN

[bulletsponge]

unvote Fouts

vote BrianD

i will vote for someone whom hasnt posted yet. its as good as any

[path12]

Originally Posted by bulletsponge

unvote Fouts

vote BrianD

i will vote for someone whom hasnt posted yet. its as good as any

For the record, Brian was here earlier today.

[saldana]

two things:

i am relatively certain hoopsguy is a townsperson

i have nothing definitive as far as information, but i am very suspicious of alan t

vote alan t

[st.cronin]

I believe the votes are:

Jonathan	2	st.cronin, AlanT
Barkeep		2	Blade, Mr. W
Fouts		2	bulletsponge, Swaggs
hoops		1	Barkeep
ntn		1	Tyrith
st.cronin		1	path12
bulletsponge	1	SnDvls
saldana		1	dubb
Swaggs		1	hoops
path12		1	Dodgerchick
dubb		1	ntndeacon

3 way tie right now. How many are needed for lynch? 8?

[st.cronin]

Jonathan	2	st.cronin, AlanT
Barkeep		2	Blade, Mr. W
Fouts		1	 Swaggs
BrianD		1	bulletsponge
hoops		1	Barkeep
ntn		1	Tyrith
st.cronin		1	path12
bulletsponge	1	SnDvls
saldana		1	dubb
Swaggs		1	hoops
path12		1	Dodgerchick
dubb		1	ntndeacon
AlanT		1	saldana

[path12]

Gonna be tough to get 8 tonight with that spread.

[Raiders Army]

Well, that was a long read...At this point I don't know who to suspect. I was leaning towards Barkeep initially, but I like to keep games separate in my mind and it's pretty easy since I haven't played a game in a while.

Now, I would normally vote for a quiet person but there are two problems with that:

1. I would be a hypocrite (although I did say I would be out most of the day and I got caught in some bad traffic when I gave one of my contractors a ride home ).
2. It wouldn't make a difference in the lynch vote.

Because of reason #2, I'm going to cast a vote for Barkeep. This is primarily because of the suspicion previously and because (more so) I feel bad about going after Blade in a previous game.

VOTE BARKEEP

[Schmidty]

I'll be bold and break the 3 way tie:

Vote Jonathan Ezrarik


If anyone can give me a good reason to not vote for him, I'll change my vote.

As far as people sighting me as being inactive today, I'll respond by saying - When am I not inactive in the first few days?

[Jonathan Ezarik]

Have to vote for someone.


Vote ntndeacon

[Schmidty]

Oops.

Vote Jonathan Ezrarik

[Jonathan Ezarik]

Hey, if you're going to vote for me, at least spell my name right.

[Lathum]

vote barkeep

seems hoops may be onto something. if nothing else it will give us some info down the road

[Barkeep49]

Yes 8.

[Barkeep49]

Umm when you say hoops is on to something what do you mean Lathum? Hoops voted for Swaggs even after I voted for him.

[Jonathan Ezarik]

Schmidty,

I wish I could give you a good reason not to vote for me. Unfortunately, I don't have anything information to save myself. You'll just have to take my word that I'm good. Or as good as can be in this world. I know my word isn't worth anything, but that's all I've got.

[Raiders Army]

A lot of action in the past few minutes...after thinking about it for a sec, I'm changing my vote to see what happens now:

UNVOTE BARKEEP
VOTE JONATHAN EZARIK

[path12]

I certainly do not understand in the least why we would vote off a player of Barkeep's ability day 1 without any real reason besides the typical day 1 hunch. We wouldn't do that to hoops or Blade. Well, OK, maybe Blade.... ;-)

He will not be getting my vote.

[st.cronin]

looks like it'll be a wild finish

Barkeep		3	Blade, Mr. W, Raiders
Jonathan	3	st.cronin, AlanT, Schmidty
ntn		2	Tyrith, Jonathan
Fouts		1	 Swaggs
BrianD		1	bulletsponge
hoops		1	Barkeep
st.cronin	1	path12
bulletsponge	1	SnDvls
saldana		1	dubb
Swaggs		1	hoops
path12		1	Dodgerchick
dubb		1	ntndeacon
AlanT		1	saldana

[Lorena]

So 20 minutes til deadline and it seems we're headed towards a no-lynch. I hate that.

unvote path12

Vote Jonathan E.

[Lorena]

BrianD, DaddyTorgo, Izulde, and LSG haven't voted.

For the record, DaddyTorgo had some work stuff and LSG said she didn't have internet access at home.

[Blade6119]

well, we need 1/3 so...

UNVOTE BARKEEP

VOTE JONATHAN E.

By the way, thanks raiders

And boooo path

Both of your comments garnered comments back lol

[Blade6119]

Originally Posted by Dodgerchick

So 20 minutes til deadline and it seems we're headed towards a no-lynch. I hate that.

We have 6 on JE, need 2 more

[Jonathan Ezarik]

Originally Posted by Dodgerchick

BrianD, DaddyTorgo, Izulde, and LSG haven't voted.

And yet people gladly took their votes off Izulde just because Fouts said so. Interesting.

It looks like I'm the one to go, and that's cool. I'm all for a lynch tonight, and while I hoped it wouldn't be me, so be it. I hope you guys learn something from this because you're about to lose one good guy.

[Raiders Army]

At this point, let's get it on. I'm sorry if JE's a good guy but sometimes you have to break some eggs to make an omlette.

[Blade6119]

Originally Posted by Jonathan Ezarik

And yet people gladly took their votes off Izulde just because Fouts said so. Interesting.

It looks like I'm the one to go, and that's cool. I'm all for a lynch tonight, and while I hoped it wouldn't be me, so be it. I hope you guys learn something from this because you're about to lose one good guy.

Are you a special role? It sure doesnt sound like it, but now would be a good time to speak up. If your not, dont lie..it will only hurt the team in the long run

[saldana]

well, we all know what i think of 'no lynch situations'

unvote alan
vote Jonathan E


note: i still dont like alan, but i like days with no lynches even less

[Raiders Army]

Izulde was last on at 1:26, so I'm not sure if that means anything.

[Jonathan Ezarik]

I understand, RA. I just find it odd that people are so quick to believe Fouts for no reason.

On that note:

UNVOTE ntndeacon

VOTE Izulde

[Raiders Army]

Ummmm...3:26 PM EST, 1:26 my time.