Werewolf CXL - The Dark Knight Returns - GAME OVER

[MrBug708]

Back in the thread. Wasn't CF handpicked by Abe to come back and win the game for himself?

[The Jackal]

We've still a few hours left, let's spark some movement.

VOTE CF

[MrBug708]

Originally Posted by MrBug708

Back in the thread. Wasn't CF handpicked by Abe to come back and win the game for himself?

By win the game, I meant the superhero game with Chubby...lol

[CrimsonFox]

Am back. Reading reading reading,....

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by Danny

This thread is BORING so far!!!

i agree *yawn*

[The Jackal]

We'll see how boring it is when you get to this page!

[Zinto]

It is still going to be pretty boring!

[Zinto]

I feel like half the people playing haven't posted at all, and I would assume that is what people usually feel like when I am playing and not posting at all.

[CrimsonFox]

gee...votes for ainto and votes for me on day one....yes jackal i'd say that defines boring

unvote cr
vote hoops

although i think abe is guilty too

[CrimsonFox]

zinto

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

zinto

truly a post full of intrigue and substance

[Zinto]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

gee...votes for ainto and votes for me on day one....yes jackal i'd say that defines boring

unvote cr
vote hoops

although i think abe is guilty too

Voting for both of us is definitely a wolf move especially if it happens in one day

[Zinto]

The voting is way to spread out at this point. We need to consolidate the voting to threeish candidates or this is going to be a pain to look at down the line with so many throw away votes.

[The Jackal]

Today is a tough vote, for sure. We're all absently hoping we hit on two-face, so we're watching to see what happens with late movement, but there shouldn't really be any late movement unless two-face is involved, unless people think they've hit on some disturbed citizens..

oh wait, was i supposed to talk about the game or alternative music?

[The Jackal]

Has anyone seen the pre-previews animated chipotle commercial at a movie recently? I thought of it because it has the scientist playing in the background. And people in the theatre I was in literally clapped after it. For a chipotle animated commercial.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by Zinto

The voting is way to spread out at this point. We need to consolidate the voting to threeish candidates or this is going to be a pain to look at down the line with so many throw away votes.

Agreed. Speaking of which, who hasn't been around much today?

[Zinto]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

=

oh wait, was i supposed to talk about the game or alternative music?

This game is Werewolf CXL: The Sound of Music

[CrimsonFox]

I was correcting my spelling.

[The Jackal]

Total posts:

SnD : 3
J23 : 3
Daddy : 2
Tyrith : 1

[CrimsonFox]

zinto that is an excellent idea!

[The Jackal]

There's four people with 4 or 5 posts too (dz, sal, mau, CR), but yeah, it's been a quiet, unproductive day I guess.

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

I was correcting my spelling.

Are you a disturbed, dyslexic citizen?!

[The Jackal]

Not that posting for the sake of posting is helpful. Gosh Danny, CF, and Jackal.

[Zinto]

Yeah I am surprised by how little werewolf talk has gone on but it is day one and the rules where laid out before us so it is not like there is much to discuss.

[Zinto]

Mauboy1 - PackerFanatic, ntndeacon
CrimsonFox – AbeSargent, The Jackal
Narcizo - J23, Saldana
Abe Sargent - Narcizo
Zinto - dzilla77, Hoopsguy, Lathum
Hoopsguy – Zinto, Crimson

[The Jackal]

Just the fact that no one can communicate. The only thing anyone knows about anyone is that 4 people (aside from two-face himself) know who two-face is. So that's all we have to harp on, but we've been saying that all day, so unless we actually have him on the block right now, it's going to be pretty useless.

[Zinto]

We are missing nine votes right now which is kind of crazy with only two and a half hours until the deadline.

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by Abe Sargent

I think you might be trying a bit too hard there buddy

Vote CrimsonFox

Trying too hard? Whatever for? If you are suggesting that I AM A CORRUPT VILLAGER and that I WANT TWO FACE TO CONVERT ME, then I am afraid, my friend, you must rethink that postulate. I WOULD never WANT THAT. WHAT person would? That is the least THING on my mind. What _I_ truly WANT IS to rally together, TO encourage discussion, and to BE absolutely clear that A main goal of mine is to catch that SUPERVILLAIN.

[saldana]

if you are gonna count posts, can we exclude all abe's about his ipod and soda?

im sure he still has more than me, but i would like to last more than 1 day this game.

[CrimsonFox]

Jackal

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by hoopsguy

This has to be on the "You know you are a wolf when you do this" list, right?

I'm actually surprised how few revenge votes there are on Day 1 overall in FOFC games.

For reasoning from me, This response didn't sit well with me.

Originally Posted by hoopsguy

Yeesh.

VOTE ZINTO

And I think we are at a point where you're voting Zinto on day one, you are hiding your vote. It's like every game he's on the block day 1, including when he got barrelrolled early last game.

[mauchow]

Hi

[mauchow]

That post had more meaning than half the shit that's been thrown out there today.

[hoopsguy]

Really? Can I get a list of people that I can't vote for on Day 1 so I know that I'm not hiding a vote?

I actually realized hours later that I had voted for the person who voted me, but it seriously was a knee-jerk reaction to the Coldplay thing at the time. You'll never get that random a WW vote on Day 2 and beyond, but on Day 1 I'm more or less looking for any excuse to put a vote down if I'm around early in the day. I just want to get votes moving and see if we can create some kind of movement to look at later in the game.

[CrimsonFox]

well ntn is on it for sure. Zinto has been another favorite to vote for. DV always is kinda popular too.

[CrimsonFox]

But thank you for your response

(oh and me you absolutely are not allowed to vote for me )

[CrimsonFox]

j23's name comes up an awful lot on day 1 too, but he IS the enigma.

[CrimsonFox]

so much for discussion. STill people that haven't really said anything (<5 posts)

[The Jackal]

unvote CF
vote abe

[mauchow]

vote hoopsguy

[Autumn]

If anyone has a list of those who haven't checked in, I will PM them again. I'd love to avoid the "oops, did we start" scenario.

[CrimsonFox]

Hoops 3 - Zinto (197) CrimsonFox (359) mauboy (390)
Zinto 3 - dzilla (217) hoops (274) Lathum (304)
mauboy1 2 - PackerFanatic (230) ntndeacon (334)
CrimsonFox 1 - Abe Sargent (248)
Narcizo 2 - J23 (260) saldana (349)
Abe Sargent 2 - Narcizo (269) Jackal (389)
Daddy Targo 1 - mckerney (350)

[CrimsonFox]

yeah email these:

dzilla 4 (but voted)
mckerney 3 (voted)
SnDvls (no vote not sure if he's checked in)
J23 (voted)
Daddy Targo (no vote, no checkin?)
Tyrith (no vote, no check in?)

[dzilla77]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

For reasoning from me, This response didn't sit well with me.



And I think we are at a point where you're voting Zinto on day one, you are hiding your vote. It's like every game he's on the block day 1, including when he got barrelrolled early last game.

We barrelrolled ntn last game. Zinto made to day 4. That means this game he's obviously a wolf (or a disturbed citizen, or at least a vanilla villager).

[CrimsonFox]

I sincerely apologize for that last post :P I hate these things.

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by dzilla77

We barrelrolled ntn last game. Zinto made to day 4. That means this game he's obviously a wolf (or a disturbed citizen, or at least a vanilla villager).

oh really? Who's obviously a wolf? The ONLY people that could say that are corrupt villagers because they know someone is twoface.

[Autumn]

If they've voted I'm not going to bug them, but if they perhaps don't even realize game is on I will.

[The Jackal]

Sarcasm, CF, sarcasm.

[Zinto]

Originally Posted by dzilla77

We barrelrolled ntn last game. Zinto made to day 4. That means this game he's obviously a wolf (or a disturbed citizen, or at least a vanilla villager).

I only made it till day three and it was because I was inactive day one.

[Tyrith]

Well, when I saw there were five more pages of post since last night I was concerned it was going to take a while to catch up. It appears those fears were unfounded :P

This ruleset is far enough removed from a normal game that I'm not sure the usual MO applies here - I think a reasonable case could be made for no lynch here. We have two seers, in a sense, and two bodyguards - it might be in the best interest of the village to play for time.

The flip side of this is that it's going to be very hard for the wolves to form a defense, in the event that we do stumble upon someone early. By the same token, though, it's going to be hard to use vote records for a while, since the disturbed citizens can't come to each other's defense. We can still mine the data looking for Two-Face though...and I suppose we have no choice but to lynch people and try. It just feels like this game is a lot higher variance than normal.

In terms of the D1 vote, for meta reasons I'm disinclined to vote for Zinto - I feel like he's part of a subsection of WW players that tends to take a lot of D1 heat, in my experience. But I'm also loathe to vote for hoops just for the sake of not voting for Zinto, because I feel like he'll be extremely useful at putting forth ideas on how to deal with this funky ruleset. Even if he's a wolf he'll have to give us something, and it can at least be a starting point for speculation.

At the same time, dumping a vote on someone with two votes (as I started writing this the thread was through #392) is just going to make me look like a wolf. Blah.