Mafia Town - GAME OVER (Town Wins)

[cheekimonk]

Woah! What a bloodbath! Is there a mortician role in this game?

[Danny]

Well I screwed the pooch here, am I still alive?

[Danny]

I work at a high school and this was first week of school, it was crazy busy and i forgot about this game.

[Danny]

Will try and figure out what's going on

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Danny

Well I screwed the pooch here, am I still alive?

You're here. The lynch vote failed.

[EagleFan]

He should have been lynched for the bestiality alone...

[Danny]

So after reading the rules I can safely proclaim that I am good guy

[dubb93]

Originally Posted by Danny

So after reading the rules I can safely proclaim that I am good guy

Good thing it took reading the rules, rather than your starting PM, to come to that conclusion.

[EagleFan]

No votes yet.

[britrock88]

Time to kickstart some discussion with a reads list!

1) Zinto - reads as a possible/probable Neutral. Used "nonevil" in a way CF caught onto and has mostly talked about nomination/lynch mechanics (to be fair, he was nomination leader on Thursday). Would guess Survivor, Jester, or Amnesiac.
3) britrock88 - good
7) cheekimonk - Shoveler escorted him N1, so not the Arsonist, per Shoveler's will. Was part of the Zinto push with independent reasoning. Neutral to good read.
8) Autumn - is good
9) Danny - largely absent, which leans good
10) The Jackal - is good
12) dubb93 - active; knows ToS roleset; thinks Danny could be third mafia in hiding -- good read
14) lighthousekeeper - moderately active, mostly role-related questions, which would be a ping, but threw a little shade on timmae, so he may be trying to hunt?

Eight players left... knowing we have at least 2 more neutrals out there is interesting. Things could be as tight as 4-2-2 for the Town.

...Where's our Arsonist?

[britrock88]

nominate lighthousekeeper

To kick things off.

[dubb93]

nominate danny

[EagleFan]

Nomination Vote

5 needed to nominate

As of post 412:

lighthousekeeper 1 - britrock88 (411)
Danny 1 - dubb93 (412)

[britrock88]

Too quiet.

[cheekimonk]

I don't agree that "mostly absent" = "leans good" in this case. It generally does, but with so many roles in this game it's too easy for a creep - neutral or evil - to keep his/her head down while the board debates all the roles and who belongs to them. I nominated based on Zinto being quiet, and I nominated this person earlier, so I'll go with:

nominate Danny

[cheekimonk]

Originally Posted by britrock88

Too quiet.

Agree. We need to have a lynch because, looking at the remaining roles, we're going to have another (smaller) massacre tonight in any case. We need to control the one death we can.

[EagleFan]

Nomination Vote

5 needed to nominate

As of post 415:

Danny 2 - dubb93 (412), cheekimonk (415)
lighthousekeeper 1 - britrock88 (411)

[The Jackal]

nominate lighthousekeeper

[EagleFan]

Nomination Vote

5 needed to nominate

As of post 418:

Danny 2 - dubb93 (412), cheekimonk (415)
lighthousekeeper 2 - britrock88 (411), The Jackal (418)

[EagleFan]

A little over a half hour until the deadline.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by cheekimonk

I don't agree that "mostly absent" = "leans good" in this case. It generally does, but with so many roles in this game it's too easy for a creep - neutral or evil - to keep his/her head down while the board debates all the roles and who belongs to them. I nominated based on Zinto being quiet, and I nominated this person earlier, so I'll go with:

nominate Danny

Re-reading several of you, I realized that I'm now in the minority with this opinion. Hoping to generate any kind of momentum, so I'll switch.

nominate Danny

[EagleFan]

Nomination Vote

5 needed to nominate

As of post 418:

Danny 3 - dubb93 (412), cheekimonk (415), britrock88 (421)
lighthousekeeper 1 - The Jackal (418)

[EagleFan]

Two minute warning.

[lighthousekeeper]

why bother nominating anyone? let the jailer find out.

[Zinto]

Nominate Danny

[EagleFan]

Deadline

[EagleFan]

The nomination fell one vote short. That includes Zinto's vote which made it 4; needed 5.

[EagleFan]

The next deadline is 9 PM for the jailer and for everyone to get a jailer note in (whatever you want to tell the jailer to keep him from executing you).

[Zinto]

I am not sure it is an awful thing that we didn't nominate anyone. But it is for activity and discussion. Did anyone have anymore useful information?

[Danny]

So we nominate people to put up for lunch? And then vote to lunch them or not? What do we do now that no one is nominated?

[lighthousekeeper]

Originally Posted by Danny

So we nominate people to put up for lunch? And then vote to lunch them or not? What do we do now that no one is nominated?

get doused in flames

[lighthousekeeper]

but really, the jailer will get to work tonight to root out the remaining baddies. i think there's only 1 killer left (arsonist), so he's fairly outnumbered. i don't know what the 1 (maybe 2) remaining mafia support can accomplish, now that his bosses are dead.

[dubb93]

Originally Posted by lighthousekeeper

but really, the jailer will get to work tonight to root out the remaining baddies. i think there's only 1 killer left (arsonist), so he's fairly outnumbered. i don't know what the 1 (maybe 2) remaining mafia support can accomplish, now that his bosses are dead.

The support will morph into a killing role. As long as there is mafia they can kill.

[dubb93]

I seriously hope we didn't decide to not nominate today under the impression that mafia wouldn't be able to kill. Spend five minutes playing a game of town of Salem. It is free to play for crying out loud.

[Autumn]

Damn, busy day again and too late to nominate. Danny and Lighthouse are both question marks in my book, so I would have been happy with either of those. I was really hoping we'd be getting some info this morning from people. Did no one go to jail?

[Danny]

I would not have nominated myself.

[EagleFan]

Deadline

Sending out jail notice shortly. Night deadline at 10.

[EagleFan]

Jail Notifications Sent.

[EagleFan]

Night deadline coming up. Sorting through the PM's. You have just over 4 minutes left to get any actions to me if you haven't yet.

[EagleFan]

Deadline

Processing.

[EagleFan]

Night 5 Results

You find britrock88 dead on the ground.

You do not find a will by the body.

You find a death note by the body:
"Voters won't protect you, it was an offer you couldn't refuse. Now we do this the hard way, fool!"

britrock88 was a Town Sheriff.

[EagleFan]

Day 6 has begun. I have doctor appointments in Philly tomorrow so we will extend the deadlines a bit.

The deadline for nomination will be 5 PM EST. 4 votes are required for nomination.

We will keep the 9 and 10 PM deadlines.

[Danny]

That sucks

[dubb93]

I guess we are the same place we were yesterday.

Nominate Danny

[cheekimonk]

Originally Posted by Danny

That sucks

Verily. We have to have a lynch today or we're wasting the vote we control.

[cheekimonk]

Did anyone get doused last night? It would be extremely helpful to know as they're good as dead at this point and we can take them out of the pool of lynch candidates.

[cheekimonk]

I've got meetings today so I might as well leave my vote where it was yesterday in case I get tied up. We have to have enough votes to at least nominate today.

nominate Danny

[Autumn]

I think that whoever is our investigator should come out today. My numbers suggest there are 3 good guys left, 1 mafia, 2 neutrals (one of whom is the arsonist) and the Any, which I believe is a Witch. That means we're outnumbered, but we can't afford to have a mislynch of one of those three, and scans are not going to be of much use at all from now on. This will also allow our Jailer to make a good choice, as anyone outside of us three goods are fair game.

[EagleFan]

Phone post.

2 votes for Danny

Traffic will determine when we can post the deadline. If anyone reaches 4 votes the Lynch vote can begin before I post.

Waiting on the doc now. Looking like I will be stuck in rush hour on the way home.

[Zinto]

Vote Danny