WW LXXXI Highlander game thread ( D5 deadline 8:00 PM EST)

[claphamsa]

I was just rereading this... but it doesn't say you aren't a highlander. and that you cant duel.....

[jeheinz72]

Hogwash. You're making that up.

My guess is if it gets down to Brenda and any highlander, Brenda wins by default.

[jeheinz72]

Originally Posted by claphamsa

I was just rereading this... but it doesn't say you aren't a highlander. and that you cant duel.....

? It clearly states that Brenda is a non-highlander. Thoguh you're right about the dueling.

[saldana]

so with the reminder that Brenda cannot be the "only one" that takes away any of Heinz's logic about questioning the reveal...and also should make it clear to anyone else that may actually be Brenda (if Mustang is not) that you need to step up soon.

[jeheinz72]

Wait, why can't Brenda be the only one? Mustang is making that up, I think even he posed it as speculation

The more you defend him sal, the more I think my initial assessment was correct in who Mustang is paired with here.

[jeheinz72]

So are you and Mustang proposing that Lathum actually devised a game in which one player had a 0% chance of winning. Does that make sense whatsoever?

[PackerFanatic]

Yeah it only says she isn't a highlander. Nothing about not being able to duel or win.

[path12]

Originally Posted by jeheinz72

So are you and Mustang proposing that Lathum actually devised a game in which one player had a 0% chance of winning. Does that make sense whatsoever?

I'd say to some extent that any game in which one is the seer they have a 0% of usually surviving the game. The key to a role like that is to help the team, even in a game like this where it's going to come down to one person.

[saldana]

Originally Posted by jeheinz72

Wait, why can't Brenda be the only one? Mustang is making that up, I think even he posed it as speculation

The more you defend him sal, the more I think my initial assessment was correct in who Mustang is paired with here.

Originally Posted by the rules, post 3

Brenda Wyatt- The only non highlander in the game. You have excellent investigative skills and each night can scan one player to test their allegiance

how can a non highlander (read as: non immortal) win a contest that involves being immortal.

[jeheinz72]

I don't know, I'm not Brenda, but I have a hard time buying the fact that Lathum included a role that has a 0% chance of winning (or is useless as a role)

[claphamsa]

this is how it comes otu for me... Sal is right. it doesn't matter. either heinze or mustang is a wolf. so who cares

[Grammaticus]

If this holds true to the Highlander storyline, Brenda cannot be the "one" because she is not an immortal. Typically the Seers win with the village (highlanders in this case). Maybe there is another win condition for her. I can think of one, where she would not want to reveal it.

[jeheinz72]

I mean let's just lay our cards on the table here folks. I don't even think the majority of you even care if Mustang is telling the truth or not. You just know that the next 2 lynches aren't going to be you and that's all that matters.

Only reason I don't really care is I"m destined to lose anyhow since I only have friggin 12 power points anyhow, I'm a ghost next time I have to duel so why bother. I just want someone to admit that his reveal has more holes in it than Swiss Cheese

- Said I was in a city I couldn't have been in (vegas, where a duel took place)

- Was somehow able to both scan saldana and overhear my convo the same night (do you think that would be allowed by Lathum!?!?)

- My solid voting record

- The possibility that there are more wolves than most of us presumed from the get go


I'm outta here in a few hours anyhow and like I said, I'm resigned to not winning this game win or lose on this lynch, but surely you all are smarter than believing this line of crap.

[Mustang]

Vote nightfall

I've pretty much stated what I'm going to state today and there is 0% chance that I'll switch votes.

[Mustang]

Originally Posted by jeheinz72

I- Was somehow able to both scan saldana and overhear my convo the same night (do you think that would be allowed by Lathum!?!?)

You were scanned on night 3. Saldana was night 2.

[jeheinz72]

Originally Posted by Mustang

You were scanned on night 3. Saldana was night 2.

Yes but you said you scanned me *after* overhearing my conversation, so you must've overheard me on Night 2

[saldana]

perhaps brenda gets a special bonus if she is still alive when the last highlander is left...if we go back to the movie, it translates to Mustang getting "pierced" by the winners immortal, uh...."sword"

[PackerFanatic]

Originally Posted by saldana

perhaps brenda gets a special bonus if she is still alive when the last highlander is left...if we go back to the movie, it translates to Mustang getting "pierced" by the winners immortal, uh...."sword"

Post of the day.

[jeheinz72]

haha

[Mustang]

Originally Posted by saldana

perhaps brenda gets a special bonus if she is still alive when the last highlander is left...if we go back to the movie, it translates to Mustang getting "pierced" by the winners immortal, uh...."sword"

If that is my 'prize', kill me now.

[Mustang]

Originally Posted by jeheinz72

Yes but you said you scanned me *after* overhearing my conversation, so you must've overheard me on Night 2

Your conversation was on night 3 in response to hearing about the kill.

(This didn't happen in public and was fictional fluff to show how I found out you were a wolf)

[jeheinz72]

So the kill was Night 2, then you just randomly heard about my call? Or you followed me night 3 and overheard a conversation about something that in this timeframe happened a week before?

This makey no sensey.

[jeheinz72]

I don't see why you guys want to take your chance lynching the guy who is as good as dead anyhow.

[path12]

Originally Posted by saldana

perhaps brenda gets a special bonus if she is still alive when the last highlander is left...if we go back to the movie, it translates to Mustang getting "pierced" by the winners immortal, uh...."sword"

I had my physical this morning, so double

[path12]

Originally Posted by jeheinz72

I don't see why you guys want to take your chance lynching the guy who is as good as dead anyhow.

If it makes you feel any better, I think there's a weak spot or two in the reveal, but there's enough there to make me think he's on the up and up.

[Alan T]

Originally Posted by path12

I had my physical this morning, so double

Ugh... That is the one thing I'm not looking forward to as I get closer to 40... those type of exams.

[jeheinz72]

Yeah, eh well. At least I was entertaining this game (Or at least I entertained myself).

Sigh.

Oh, and all you assholes are dying spontaneous deaths in my next game.

[jeheinz72]

But I might as well give it up, since I got my one person to agree with me that his reveal has holes. I gave it a good fight but no one has any motivation to change their vote, much less actually engage with me so I could eventually convince them to do my bidding.

GO WOLVES!!!!!

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[jeheinz72]

So who is up for some ketchup porn?

[jeheinz72]

[PackerFanatic]

Now this is the way to end a Friday.

*standing O for Heinz*

[jeheinz72]

Everyone loves the ketchup porn.

[jeheinz72]

It's a time honored tradition really.

[Grammaticus]

So Heinz, who is left in your pack?

[jeheinz72]

DT and Narc are both wolves who'll be coming back from the dead on Day 5 and a quarter.

[claphamsa]

damit, and i missed al the fun!

[path12]

Me too. But at least we got another wolf!

[The Jackal]

Mm, catsup.

[jeheinz72]

The lack of prevailing ketchup porn is what has resulted in a decrease in werewolf play around here. I have a pie chart that proves it.

[path12]

Will we ever get mustard porn? Us mustard lovers demand equal porn time, dammit!

[Lathum]

deadline

[Lathum]

after one startling reveal and some banter that convinced no one, Heinze was dragged outside and beheaded.

As with Mrs. Schmidty just as he is about to die he turns furry and almost breaks lose.

Heinze was a wolf.

N4 has begun, deadline 11:00 AM EST Monday

[claphamsa]

way tokill the drama heinzey!

[Grammaticus]

I have not played in a while, when do we typically pick things back up over the weekend?

[Alan T]

Originally Posted by Grammaticus

I have not played in a while, when do we typically pick things back up over the weekend?

Usually it is one extended long day over the weekend ending with the normal Monday night deadline. ie: people can still play over the weekend, but many people might not be around to respond until Monday.

[saldana]

Originally Posted by Grammaticus

I have not played in a while, when do we typically pick things back up over the weekend?

people normally start talking again late tonight, which i expect to be true again, since we have a night phase running right now, and have to put orders in for the morning deadline.

[The Jackal]

This is definitely a different game dynamic as well, especially since we've already nailed two wolves.. because of the fact that we've got the major victory in the back of our heads.

[saldana]

so moving into the night, here is what we know:

2. Path12
3. NTNDeacon
6. Packerfanatic - cleared by seer
7. Jackal - connor
8. Saldana - cleared by seer
9. Clap - kurgan (not confirmed)
13. Grammaticus
15. Mustang - seer
16. Barkeep

to be honest, I am worried about Barkeep...i have never seen him so UTR before...I have forgotten he is even playing on more than one occasion

also, I have been burned by path hiding in the shadows before, so he is still pinging my radar. I will likely go down one of these two routes on Monday.

for now, I am off to celebrate my Niners winning today.

[Grammaticus]

What is the word on why Barkeep was MIA?

[claphamsa]

Originally Posted by saldana

for now, I am off to celebrate my Niners winning today.

yeah, screw them!

RUN GORE

and what the hell happend to Davis???????????????????????