Simple Game Day 4 (Deadline Thursday 10 PM EDT)

[Axxon]

Well, if clap is the sorcerer he played it all wrong.

[claphamsa]

vote nightfall

[Axxon]

Oh, I don't think so.

[DaddyTorgo]

[claphamsa]

just thoght i would toss that tout there......

[PurdueBrad]

I'm out until deadline.

[claphamsa]

without changing his vote....

[Axxon]

Just to be very clear, the only way I'm not the wolf is if I'm the sorcerer ( if I was the sorcerer then I'd go ahead and vote nightfall though ). As a villager, it'd make no sense to do what I did.

Maybe I'd quickly get a vote out there to get tiebreaker but I'd only have a 1/3 chance of getting the wolf. I'd have to be certain of that vote or I'm horribly misplaying the odds and risk getting myself voted which is what is happening. I'm not that player.

The right move at that point would be to watch things develop to see if anyone outed themselves not to call myself the wolf hoping to confuse the sorcerer and risking confusing the villager.

Reality is that I played the odds. I had a 2/3 chance of winning simply by quick voting. That's all I had to do and it's what I did. Once clap voted on me and convinced me he wasn't the sorcerer I revealed and the only way I could lose is if I misread clap which I still don't believe I did or if the sorcerer actually thought I'd play the lousy 1/3 odds and doom my team.

Right now that's to PB but just in case Danny is being clever like he was yesterday playing jumping bean...

[claphamsa]

yeah, wierd move by PB...

[Axxon]

Well, if he misses the deadline then you win clap. Since that could happen and since he left the vote unbalanced then who knows.

It looks like someone, whoever the sorcerer is, is going to throw the game the wrong way.

SORCERER, you do realize you can only win if the wolf wins right?? If you have doubts about me, don't wait around and just ask. I'm not moving my vote and I doubt clap will either.

[claphamsa]

nein! ich benne lynchit.

[Axxon]

Well, deadline is here and no one has changed their vote.

I'll admit this is the absolute worst way to lose a game I can imagine.

Good win villagers. Enjoy it. I imagine you won't get too many where the sorcerer seals it for you.

[Axxon]

OK, it's past 10. Will the moron, I mean sorcerer, please stand up?

[Racer]

Originally Posted by claphamsa

vote nightfall

That is awesome that you tried that.

[Axxon]

It doesn't matter. There's no logical reason anyone will ever convince me that the sorcerer voted the way he did.

[claphamsa]

im a big nightfall fan

[hoopsguy]

Originally Posted by Axxon

OK, it's past 10. Will the moron, I mean sorcerer, please stand up?

Hmm, am I ready to change out my signature? I'm picturing Axxon right now living this ...

[claphamsa]

maybe there was no sorcerer....

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by hoopsguy

Hmm, am I ready to change out my signature? I'm picturing Axxon right now living this ...

WTF??? I'm supposed to be happy with his choice or are you saying he made the right one? I am new to the game but honestly, I can't imagine the sorcerer thinking I wasn't the wolf. I really can't.

[claphamsa]

im a pretty convincing wolf....

[Racer]

Originally Posted by Axxon

WTF??? I'm supposed to be happy with his choice or are you saying he made the right one? I am new to the game but honestly, I can't imagine the sorcerer thinking I wasn't the wolf. I really can't.

You did what you should have done in my opinion. You just caught a really bad break in that Danny went a-wall and forgot to post.

[hoopsguy]

Axxon, I'm agreeing with your frustration/dismay on this one. You should have been winning this game. Someone dropped the ball.

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by hoopsguy

Axxon, I'm agreeing with your frustration/dismay on this one. You should have been winning this game. Someone dropped the ball.

Ok, I got you. I'm thinking it's PB and I think your evaluation in the other thread is pretty correct. I am about to post that in fact over there.

[Barkeep49]

"MWUHAHAHA," shots Axxon "this village is ours. With the help of my ally, the sorcerer, we will take slaughter the villagers." And then a pause. No one steps forward. A longer pause. Still no one. "Umm sorcerer?" And that is when you set in on Axxon pelting him and shooting him with arrows. Even Purdue Brad, the sorcerer joins in. And with that the villagers win and there werewolf problem in this village has been eradicated.

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by Racer

You did what you should have done in my opinion. You just caught a really bad break in that Danny went a-wall and forgot to post.

Danny was here. PB switched his vote to give you the win then told us he was leaving and would miss the deadline.

[Racer]

Was the final vote 2-1?

[Alan T]

lol.. what a tragic ending...

[Barkeep49]

I messed up the balance as really 11 would have been the right amount in this game, because of the lack of a bodyguard to ever prevent a kill. I think DT and Axxon, and also Racer, all did a great job with their roles and played the game well.

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by Racer

Was the final vote 2-1?

3-1. Sorcerer was a triple agent.

Or a moron....

Discuss.

[claphamsa]

so you dont think i confused PB? no love for me

[Axxon]

Yeah, DT was a great partner and I've already given racer his props.

Villagers got lucky too. Racer was about to die on day 2 but we wolves had a communication problem on that one.

[KWhit]

Wow. What's up with that!?

[Racer]

I wonder if PurdueBrad got really wrapped into the other game starting today. Because he was being pretty gun-ho in the other thread.

[Racer]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I messed up the balance as really 11 would have been the right amount in this game, because of the lack of a bodyguard to ever prevent a kill. I think DT and Axxon, and also Racer, all did a great job with their roles and played the game well.

I think it may have been unbalanced largely due to the fact that the hunter got killed and the sorcerer didn't. If that hadn't happened, I think it would have been a fairly balanced game.

[Barkeep49]

I wonder if he didn't realize he was the sorcerer? Here was his original PM

You’re the sorcerer. You’ve always hated the pedantic life of your stupid village. Now, FINALLY, something interesting has happened. Granted it happens to be a werewolf attack. But beggars can’t be choosers. You are determined to see to it that every lousy person in this town gets what’s coming to them and that the wolves succeed in eating everyone.

[claphamsa]

kinda hard to msis that one!

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by claphamsa

so you dont think i confused PB? no love for me

No offense clap but the logic was clear. If you confused him you did it earlier and he didn't try to think it through when new evidence came out.

That's why I say hoopsguy's accessment was spot on.

[Barkeep49]

Originally Posted by Racer

I think it may have been unbalanced largely due to the fact that the hunter got killed and the sorcerer didn't. If that hadn't happened, I think it would have been a fairly balanced game.

I think the villagers shouldn't been in a second consecutive "must gain the tiebreaker" after killing the first wolf. The game relied on the tiebreaker more than I'd have liked.

[The Jackal]

Well the hunter wasn't really that an important a role, to be honest. I mean if I'd survived to the end of the game (which I have had a habit of doing), sure, but not like I could do anything at night.

[Barkeep49]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I wonder if he didn't realize he was the sorcerer? Here was his original PM

This post was not meant sarcastically. I thought it was clear, but perhaps he skimmed and didn't realize?

[KWhit]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I wonder if he didn't realize he was the sorcerer? Here was his original PM

I'm guessing this gave it away:

You’re the sorcerer.

[The Jackal]

I really hope PB gets back and drunkenly rants.

[claphamsa]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I think the villagers shouldn't been in a second consecutive "must gain the tiebreaker" after killing the first wolf. The game relied on the tiebreaker more than I'd have liked.

it would have been fine if we hadnt known waht the tie breaker was.... i mean i was sure we had no chance...

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I wonder if he didn't realize he was the sorcerer? Here was his original PM

Maybe but he isn't a new player like the rest of us and that'd be a real reach. Plus, he'd pretty much acted like the sorcerer earlier.

[Barkeep49]

Originally Posted by claphamsa

it would have been fine if we hadnt known waht the tie breaker was.... i mean i was sure we had no chance...

I agree, though that wasn't in the spirit of a simple game. I think this simple set showed that you don't need tons of bells and whistles to have a good game. I mean I think yesterday's seer/counter seer reveal is what WW is all about.

[claphamsa]

tru tru.... I agree. just bitching

[Axxon]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I think the villagers shouldn't been in a second consecutive "must gain the tiebreaker" after killing the first wolf. The game relied on the tiebreaker more than I'd have liked.

Yes, but if you decide to keep the tiebreaker next time please have a bit of thought about time zones. When you changed the rule on the last night so we had to wait until the next day it meant I either had to stay up all night or get up before 6 am.

That got me too, racer pointed this out and PB still missed it.

Racer, I was pretty ticked when you did that at first but I thought it clearly outed me so was a good thing.

[DaddyTorgo]

wow

I am SO ripshit right now I can't even post because i'm just absolutely going to go OFF on PB. honestly...this is fucking the shittiest, most idiotic end to a WW game i've ever seen

[The Jackal]

Exactly. When WW boils down to its simplest he said/she said, it's lovely.

[The Jackal]

Hmm. DT isn't pleased.