WW CXXIV: When Worlds Collide - Game Over!

[mckerney]

Hulk strong.

[JAG]

Sigh.

[Autumn]

Why does that make you think that Thursday is a wolf?

[Autumn]

What we have lost to the Hulk? Three characters now? This is ridiculous. I think someone said Hulk could regenerate well too, which sucks.

[Barkeep49]

We knew Thursday had an ability to be removed from the game for 2 cycles.

[mauchow]

i see.

[dubb93]

I hope hulk is a wolf bc he has killed about as much people as the freaking wolves at this point.

[dubb93]

Originally Posted by Autumn

Why does that make you think that Thursday is a wolf?

Thursday clearly said he was going to die andwas going to take Jackal with him. For that to not happen makes he know he is a wolf. A villager wouldn't have allowed us to waste our votes on him and then make us remove them form the other major suspect of the day. NtN is clearly a wolf.

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by dubb93

Thursday clearly said he was going to die andwas going to take Jackal with him. For that to not happen makes he know he is a wolf. A villager wouldn't have allowed us to waste our votes on him and then make us remove them form the other major suspect of the day. NtN is clearly a wolf.

I agree with this. This sucks that after everything from yesterday we lost mckerney to a random Hulk attack. I, of course, did not win my interaction

The day's actions moved some people around on my top suspects list as well.

[JAG]

So Thursday Next and Keyser Soze as presumably the last two wolves, unless there's a 5th.

[dubb93]

Originally Posted by JAG

So Thursday Next and Keyser Soze as presumably the last two wolves, unless there's a 5th.

So the question is do we take a day and kill the Hulk to avoid him killing us each day?

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by JAG

So Thursday Next and Keyser Soze as presumably the last two wolves, unless there's a 5th.

I'm with you on NTN, but how does anything that happened yesterday support what seems to be a gut call on me being a wolf? You're barking up the wrong tree

[The Jackal]

Originally Posted by dubb93

So the question is do we take a day and kill the Hulk to avoid him killing us each day?

It's poor luck that he's been offing villagers, but the odds are still in that favor for pretty much the rest of the game. Hopefully since he's wounded he wouldn't need much more damage dealt.

[JAG]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

I'm with you on NTN, but how does anything that happened yesterday support what seems to be a gut call on me being a wolf? You're barking up the wrong tree

Other than you going after two villagers in me and mckerney you mean? And probably a third assuming the Hulk is 'good'? But I do admit it's mostly vibe.

[EagleFan]

Updated with mckerney's green. Will try to get the other days done before Monday (I have a feeling that my days are numbered).


Day One>>
(257) – Hulk Hogan (dubb93) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(279) – Animal (Autumn) attacks dubb (invalid)
(279) – Gonzo (Autumn) attacks BK (invalid)
(281) – Tyrith attacks mckerney (invalid)
(282) – Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Lathum(invalid)
(282) – Beaker (Autumn) attacks Lathum(invalid)
(285) – Animal (Autumn) attacks Hulk Hogan (dubb93)
(285) – Gonzo (Autumn) attacks Athena (BK)
(285) – Honeydew (Autumn) attacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(285) – Beaker (Autumn) attacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(286) – Duke (EF) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(287) – Hulk Hogan (dubb) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(289) – Macho Man (dubb) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(290) – Jack Bauer (PF) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(294) – Athena (BK) attacks Beaker (Autumn)
(296) – Goo (cougar) attacksHarry Potter (Lathum)
(307) – Macho Man (dubb) unattacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(315) – Tyrith attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(319) – The Jackal attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(321) – ntn attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(342) – Dwight (Zinto) attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(343) – Cookie Monster (Chubby) attacks Chloe (who the f***is Chloe?)
(343) – Super Grover (Chubby) attacks Had Hatter (Crimson)
(343) – Oscar the Grouch (Chubby) attacks Miss Piggy(Autumn)
(345) – Lathum attacksBeaker (Autumn)
(357) – Zoe (mau) attacks Doormouse(Crimson)
(357) – Jayne (mau) attacks Doormouse(Crimson)
(357) – Malcolm (mau) attacks Doormouse(Crimson)
(358) – Macho Man (dubb) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(358) – Hulk Hogan (dubb) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(358) – Miss Elizabeth (dubb) attacks TMIMITW (J23)
(361) – Heavy (mckerney) attacks Keyser (Jackal)
(370) – Mel (JAG) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(373) – Miss Piggy (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(373) – Kermit (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(373) – Chef (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(375) – Honeydew (Autumn) unattacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(375) – Beaker (Autumn) unattacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(375) – Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Goo(cougar)
(375) – Beaker (Autumn) attacks Goo(cougar)
(385) – Gonzo (Autumn) unattacks Athena (BK)
(385) – Gonzo (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(386) – Keyser (Jackal) unattacks Doubtfire(DT)
(386) – Keyser (Jackal) attacks Goo(cougar)
(389) – Keyser (Jackal) unattacks Goo(cougar)
(389) – Keyser (Jackal) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(391) – Zoe (mau) unattacks dormouse(Crimson)
(391) – Jayne (mau) unattacks dormouse(Crimson)
(391) – Malcolm (mau) unattacks dormouse(Crimson)
(391) – Jayne (mau) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(391) – Zoe (mau) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(391) – Malcolm (mau) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(399) – Cthulu (DV) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty) – viamessage from Danny
(409) – Animal (Autumn) unattacks Hulk Hogan (dubb)
(409) – Animal (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(411) – Zinto unattacks Heavy (mckerney)
(411) – Zinto attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(412) – DT attacks TheHulk (Schmidty)
(419) – hoops votes TheHulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Piggy (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Kermit (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Animal (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Chef (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Piggy (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(430) – Kermit (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(430) – Animal (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(430) – Chef (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(432) – Mad Hatter (Crimson)attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(435) – March Hare (Crimson)attacks TMIMITW (J23)
(437) – Dormouse (Crimson)attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(442) – Deadline
No submitted attacks: The Hulk (Schmidty) and TMIMITW (J23)>>

>>

Day Two>>
(503) Duke (EF) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(518) Jayne, Zoe and Mal (mau) attacks cookie monster(Chubby)
(528) Hulk Hogan, Miss Elizabeth and Macho Man (dubb) attacks Nelson (Tyrith)
(530) Jack Bauer (PF) attacksTMIMITW (J23)
(542) Dwight (Zinto) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(558) BK attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(559) Dwight (Zinto) unattacks TMIMITW(J23)
(561) March Hare (Crimson)attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(572) Mal, Jayne and Zoe (mau) unattacks Cookie Monster(Chubby)
(578) Dwight (Zinto) attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(585) Darth attacks Sauron (hoops)
(586) ntn attacks TMIMITW (J23)
(587) Super Grover and Cookie Monster (Chubby) attacks Goo 1 (cougar)
(587) Oscar (Chubby) attacks Goo2 (cougar)
(591) Heavy (mckerney) attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(609) Kermit and Animal (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire (DT)
(609) Chef (Autumn) attacks Goo1 (cougar)
(609) Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Goo2 (cougar)
(623) Goo 1 and Goo 2 (cougar) attacksTMIMITW (J23)
(629) Tyrith attacks Goo 2 (cougar)
(636) hoops attacks Doubtfire (DT)
(638) Duke (EF) unattacks TMIMITW(J23)
(643) The Jackal attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(644) Lathum attacks Goo 1 (cougar)
(645) Mal, Zoe, Jayne (mau) attacks Melisandra (JAG)
(646) Zoe (mau) unattacks Melisandra (JAG)
(646) Zoe (mau) attacks Goo 2(cougar)
(648) Mal (mau) unattacks Mellisandra (JAG)
(648) Mal (mau) attacks Goo 2(cougar)
(651) TMIMITW (J23)attacks Macho Man (dubb)
(652) EF attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(659) Chef (Autumn) unattacks Goo1 (cougar)
(659) Honeydew (Autumn) unattacks Goo2 (cougar)
(659) Chef (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire(DT)>>
(659) Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(665) Zinto unattacks Heavy (mckerney)
(665) Zinto attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(670) Mad Hatter (Crimson)attacks Doubtfire (DT)
(674) Melisandra (JAG) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(683) Deadline
No Submitted Attacks – Hulk (Schmidty)

[EagleFan]

Pardon the formatting of these. The >> came over from the copy/paste out of Word and it seems the green from Word is different from what the forum gives me (hence the different shades of color). Green means known good and red means known wolf. The shades mean nothing.

[mauchow]

I did not win an interaction.

[mauchow]

Or a kill for that matter.

[Barkeep49]

I won Harry Potter. I had to make a choice about what spell to get. I am not sure if I think get to direct that spell as well against a certain person or if it will be randomly directed.

[dubb93]

Originally Posted by Barkeep49

I won Harry Potter. I had to make a choice about what spell to get. I am not sure if I think get to direct that spell as well against a certain person or if it will be randomly directed.

Any particular reason you broke with the plan? Was there a reason you didn't want Autumn or I to win Harry as was the plan? This is just really odd to me since you were one of the few to publically agree with an support the plan.

[Barkeep49]

Originally Posted by dubb93

Any particular reason you broke with the plan? Was there a reason you didn't want Autumn or I to win Harry as was the plan? This is just really odd to me since you were one of the few to publically agree with an support the plan.

I thought my part of the plan was to do Harry?

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by dubb93

Assuming no one cares I would like to see the following done today:

Sauron -- Attack=McKerney // Interact=Barkeep
Harry Potter -- Attack=Dubb // Interact=Autumn
Jack Bauer -- Attack=EF // Interact=Chubby

The rest of you, if you have a better idea tell me. If you are a villager and you suspect one of the above is a wolf then by all means submit the same action as that person has been asked to submit.

nope

[Schmidty]

To everyone I've pissed off in the past day or two (Autumn, etc.), I apologize. I had my first seizure in over a month, and was sleeping most of the day, and all of today up until now. I think it's from switching meds (gradually) in the past week, and even before yesterday, I haven't been feeling like myself. Looking at a computer screen is kind of hard right now, so I'm going to ask to be replaced because I don't think I can do what needs to be done this game, which Danny has put a lot of thought into. If he can't find anyone else, I hope I'm feeling better by Monday.

Sorry.

[mauchow]

Sorry Schmidty. I was pissed at Hulk, not you.

Get better!

[Autumn]

Same here, that sucks Schmidty. Get better. Just pick a wimpier character next time ;-)

[EagleFan]

Feel better Schmidty.

[dubb93]

<~~~~Was pissed at The Hulk. Hope you get to feeling better. Pick Grandpa Simpson next time

[Zinto]

No worries Schmidty. Hope you are feeling better soon.

[JAG]

Dittos to the above well-wishes.

[JAG]

As we're post-night deadline, I'll reveal I won Jack Bauer. He allowed me to use a bomb on another player for five damage, which I used on Thursday Next (originally was going to use it on Keyser, but in case he was being truthful about his ability and used it, I didn't want the attack to go off randomly).

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by mauboy1

Sorry Schmidty. I was pissed at Hulk, not you.

Get better!

+1

[PackerFanatic]

Originally Posted by JAG

As we're post-night deadline, I'll reveal I won Jack Bauer. He allowed me to use a bomb on another player for five damage, which I used on Thursday Next (originally was going to use it on Keyser, but in case he was being truthful about his ability and used it, I didn't want the attack to go off randomly).

Nobody "wins" me!!

[Danny]

Processing night actions now

[Danny]

Dubb has been killed. He was a villager.

In addition, Jack Bauer attempts to attack Thursday Next, but his attack fails as Thursday is hiding in a book.

[Danny]

Health updates going out now.

[Danny]

Health updates sent out, Hulk is wounded

[Danny]

Today's characters

James Bond
King Arthur
Aragorn
Dr. Mccoy

[Chubby]

uggh again

obviously thursday next should be out prime target IMO but we need to decide what to do about The Hulk as well. There's a couple of others high on my list of suspects but I can't see myself putting them over thursday next (i could see putting them over the Hulk tho)

[JAG]

Oh well, I figured 'today' meant 'day', not 'night' also. Assuming Jackal used his ability yesterday, there wasn't anything to be done about it.

I recommend we pile on one today and one the next day unless we think we have enough attack power to take one down without a full pile-up. If we only hurt both of them and don't fully wipe them out, they'll regen an extra health each plus be able to use whatever night attack abilities they have, plus we'll be down an extra player after night actions tonight presumably.

Melisandre attacks Keyser Soze

[JAG]

Barring any specials, there's a reasonable chance they can try to take down Hulk or Autumn with last second switches, so that's another thing to worry about...we might get in a situation where we don't have enough raw firepower to take them down even though we're confident they're the remaining wolves.

[The Jackal]

Don't have time today to convince you guys that JAG is wrong about me, doing some traveling. May be able to input tonight but probably just tomorrow. If I was a wolf I would've killed you by now JAG, youre the only person that has been outspoken against me.

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by JAG

Oh well, I figured 'today' meant 'day', not 'night' also. Assuming Jackal used his ability yesterday, there wasn't anything to be done about it.

I recommend we pile on one today and one the next day unless we think we have enough attack power to take one down without a full pile-up. If we only hurt both of them and don't fully wipe them out, they'll regen an extra health each plus be able to use whatever night attack abilities they have, plus we'll be down an extra player after night actions tonight presumably.

Melisandre attacks Keyser Soze

Why Keyser Soze and not Thursday Next today?

[Chubby]

I find it strange that JAG uses Bauer against Thursday Next last night but then won't vote him today when it didn't work. The clear choice today is:

Super Grover 2.0 attacks Thursday Next
Oscar the Grouch attacks Thursday Next

With the Hulk below 25% health, what do we do with him? (we have until monday night to decide as the day doesn't end til then, correct?)

[Barkeep49]

Athean attacks Thursday Next

[JAG]

Originally Posted by Chubby

I find it strange that JAG uses Bauer against Thursday Next last night but then won't vote him today when it didn't work. The clear choice today is:

Super Grover 2.0 attacks Thursday Next
Oscar the Grouch attacks Thursday Next

With the Hulk below 25% health, what do we do with him? (we have until monday night to decide as the day doesn't end til then, correct?)

If he really has a brutal ability, as I pointed out above, we might not have enough attack power to knock off the last wolf with an extra villager kill.

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by JAG

If he really has a brutal ability, as I pointed out above, we might not have enough attack power to knock off the last wolf with an extra villager kill.

but if you had killed him last night, wouldn't the brutal have kicked in then too?

if the bomb wasn't powerful enough to kill him last night and it worked, wouldn't we kill him today?

maybe I'm missing something (totally possible) but your strategy is confusing me.

[EagleFan]

Updated

Day One>>
(257) – Hulk Hogan (dubb93) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(279) – Animal (Autumn) attacks dubb (invalid)
(279) – Gonzo (Autumn) attacks BK (invalid)
(281) – Tyrith attacks mckerney (invalid)
(282) – Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Lathum(invalid)
(282) – Beaker (Autumn) attacks Lathum(invalid)
(285) – Animal (Autumn) attacks Hulk Hogan (dubb93)
(285) – Gonzo (Autumn) attacks Athena (BK)
(285) – Honeydew (Autumn) attacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(285) – Beaker (Autumn) attacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(286) – Duke (EF) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(287) – Hulk Hogan (dubb) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(289) – Macho Man (dubb) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(290) – Jack Bauer (PF) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(294) – Athena (BK) attacks Beaker (Autumn)
(296) – Goo (cougar) attacksHarry Potter (Lathum)
(307) – Macho Man (dubb) unattacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(315) – Tyrith attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(319) – The Jackal attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(321) – ntn attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(342) – Dwight (Zinto) attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(343) – Cookie Monster (Chubby) attacks Chloe (who the f***is Chloe?)
(343) – Super Grover (Chubby) attacks Had Hatter (Crimson)
(343) – Oscar the Grouch (Chubby) attacks Miss Piggy(Autumn)
(345) – Lathum attacksBeaker (Autumn)
(357) – Zoe (mau) attacks Doormouse(Crimson)
(357) – Jayne (mau) attacks Doormouse(Crimson)
(357) – Malcolm (mau) attacks Doormouse(Crimson)
(358) – Macho Man (dubb) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(358) – Hulk Hogan (dubb) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(358) – Miss Elizabeth (dubb) attacks TMIMITW (J23)
(361) – Heavy (mckerney) attacks Keyser (Jackal)
(370) – Mel (JAG) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(373) – Miss Piggy (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(373) – Kermit (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(373) – Chef (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(375) – Honeydew (Autumn) unattacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(375) – Beaker (Autumn) unattacks HarryPotter (Lathum)
(375) – Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Goo(cougar)
(375) – Beaker (Autumn) attacks Goo(cougar)
(385) – Gonzo (Autumn) unattacks Athena (BK)
(385) – Gonzo (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(386) – Keyser (Jackal) unattacks Doubtfire(DT)
(386) – Keyser (Jackal) attacks Goo(cougar)
(389) – Keyser (Jackal) unattacks Goo(cougar)
(389) – Keyser (Jackal) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(391) – Zoe (mau) unattacks dormouse(Crimson)
(391) – Jayne (mau) unattacks dormouse(Crimson)
(391) – Malcolm (mau) unattacks dormouse(Crimson)
(391) – Jayne (mau) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(391) – Zoe (mau) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(391) – Malcolm (mau) attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(399) – Cthulu (DV) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty) – viamessage from Danny
(409) – Animal (Autumn) unattacks Hulk Hogan (dubb)
(409) – Animal (Autumn) attacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(411) – Zinto unattacks Heavy (mckerney)
(411) – Zinto attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(412) – DT attacks TheHulk (Schmidty)
(419) – hoops votes TheHulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Piggy (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Kermit (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Animal (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Chef (Autumn) unattacks The Hulk (Schmidty)
(430) – Piggy (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(430) – Kermit (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(430) – Animal (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(430) – Chef (Autumn) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(432) – Mad Hatter (Crimson)attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(435) – March Hare (Crimson)attacks TMIMITW (J23)
(437) – Dormouse (Crimson)attacks Gonzo (Autumn)
(442) – Deadline

No submitted attacks: The Hulk (Schmidty) and TMIMITW (J23)>>

>>

Day Two>>
(503) Duke (EF) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(518) Jayne, Zoe and Mal (mau) attacks cookie monster(Chubby)
(528) Hulk Hogan, Miss Elizabeth and Macho Man (dubb) attacks Nelson (Tyrith)
(530) Jack Bauer (PF) attacksTMIMITW (J23)
(542) Dwight (Zinto) attacks TMIMITW(J23)
(558) BK attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(559) Dwight (Zinto) unattacks TMIMITW(J23)
(561) March Hare (Crimson)attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(572) Mal, Jayne and Zoe (mau) unattacks Cookie Monster(Chubby)
(578) Dwight (Zinto) attacks Heavy (mckerney)
(585) Darth attacks Sauron (hoops)
(586) ntn attacks TMIMITW (J23)
(587) Super Grover and Cookie Monster (Chubby) attacks Goo 1 (cougar)
(587) Oscar (Chubby) attacks Goo2 (cougar)
(591) Heavy (mckerney) attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(609) Kermit and Animal (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire (DT)
(609) Chef (Autumn) attacks Goo1 (cougar)
(609) Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Goo2 (cougar)
(623) Goo 1 and Goo 2 (cougar) attacksTMIMITW (J23)
(629) Tyrith attacks Goo 2 (cougar)
(636) hoops attacks Doubtfire (DT)
(638) Duke (EF) unattacks TMIMITW(J23)
(643) The Jackal attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(644) Lathum attacks Goo 1 (cougar)
(645) Mal, Zoe, Jayne (mau) attacks Melisandra (JAG)
(646) Zoe (mau) unattacks Melisandra (JAG)
(646) Zoe (mau) attacks Goo 2(cougar)
(648) Mal (mau) unattacks Mellisandra (JAG)
(648) Mal (mau) attacks Goo 2(cougar)
(651) TMIMITW (J23)attacks Macho Man (dubb)
(652) EF attacks Cookie Monster (Chubby)
(659) Chef (Autumn) unattacks Goo1 (cougar)
(659) Honeydew (Autumn) unattacks Goo2 (cougar)
(659) Chef (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire(DT)>>
(659) Honeydew (Autumn) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(665) Zinto unattacks Heavy (mckerney)
(665) Zinto attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(670) Mad Hatter (Crimson)attacks Doubtfire (DT)
(674) Melisandra (JAG) attacks Doubtfire(DT)
(683) Deadline

No Submitted Attacks – Hulk (Schmidty)

[JAG]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

Don't have time today to convince you guys that JAG is wrong about me, doing some traveling. May be able to input tonight but probably just tomorrow. If I was a wolf I would've killed you by now JAG, youre the only person that has been outspoken against me.

In case others might not cone up with the reasons:

1. Would've killed me by now? I disagree. I'm not in the top tier of trusted people and I only started going after you yesterday.

2. You might've considered dubb to be more dangerous from an attacking perspective. He also seemed to agree with me about you with his last post.

3. Killing me would've really pointed the finger at you as a wolf. If you were a villager, I think I might've been an interesting NK choice to try to frame you as being a wolf.

[JAG]

Originally Posted by Chubby

but if you had killed him last night, wouldn't the brutal have kicked in then too?

if the bomb wasn't powerful enough to kill him last night and it worked, wouldn't we kill him today?

maybe I'm missing something (totally possible) but your strategy is confusing me.

I think you're missing that the bomb only did five points of damage. He took no damage yesterday and I don't think he's accumulated any damage to this point, so he's probably got 8-11ish hps, so I wasn't worried about him being killed from it. If Jackal hadn't revealed his ability (assuming it's true), I would've used it on him, but I didn't want to risk the bomb hitting someone else.

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by JAG

I think you're missing that the bomb only did five points of damage. He took no damage yesterday and I don't think he's accumulated any damage to this point, so he's probably got 8-11ish hps, so I wasn't worried about him being killed from it. If Jackal hadn't revealed his ability (assuming it's true), I would've used it on him, but I didn't want to risk the bomb hitting someone else.

but what was the point of using it on him if you weren't going to follow it up with an attack today?

I understand why you didn't use it on Jackal, I guess I'm confused as to why you didn't use it on the Hulk then if you didn't expect to kill thursday next and weren't going to follow it up with an attack in the next day cycle? I still don't want the Hulk randomly killing more villagers...

I think where you are going is that you want thursday next to be the last wolf killed off to avoid the brutal, am I correct? Using the bmb on thursday next then waiting to kill him will only allow him to heal, no?