Beware the Fat Man in Red (Game Over: Village Wins!)

[mauchow]

Super Man!

[britrock88]

for page 8 reference:

1 mauboy - CF (211)
6 britrock - DT (185), Autumn (267), Abe (283), CR (293), JAG (322), mau (340)
1 Abe - Zinto (299)
2 CF - britrock (341), GE (347)

[Abe Sargent]

Well hello, basically, everyone

[britrock88]

Hello to 5 of the 6 of you with votes on me.

[britrock88]

I am the duke.

[GoldenEagle]

I am just trying to get some movement. I think everyone piling on BR is a bad thing. It allowed the wolves to hide votes.

[mauchow]

If Brit is who he says he is then we should keep it on him and let him join the COT tomorrow, right? Or am I wrong?

[britrock88]

We best figure out someone else quickly, or else I'm taking a shot in the dark.

[JAG]

Mmkay.

Unvote Britrock88
Vote CrimsonFox

[DaddyTorgo]

Originally Posted by mauboy1

If Brit is who he says he is then we should keep it on him and let him join the COT tomorrow, right? Or am I wrong?

Yes

[Abe Sargent]

Originally Posted by mauboy1

If Brit is who he says he is then we should keep it on him and let him join the COT tomorrow, right? Or am I wrong?

I actually agree.

BR, let us know before you take a shot in the dark who you have as your top target, juts in case....

[JAG]

Don't feel great about a CF vote. Obviously if Brit is lying, the real duke should duke to him.

[DaddyTorgo]

Put in a duke order to somebody else brit

my preference would be someone on the list of names i put out there earlier obviously, as i think that really would help narrow stuff down

[britrock88]

1 mauboy - CF (211)
5 britrock - DT (185), Autumn (267), Abe (283), CR (293), mau (340)
1 Abe - Zinto (299)
3 CF - britrock (341), GE (347), JAG (359)

[britrock88]

Thinking on the order...

[JAG]

Originally Posted by JAG

So here is where everyone's initial votes were yesterday (pre-reveal and DT vote swap to Simbo), assuming GE isn't lying for purposes of below colors for both he and Zinto:


2 Autumn - Abe Sargent (47), Zinto (78)
3 DaddyTorgo - Autumn (49), Chief Rum (84), GoldenEagle (122)
3 GoldenEagle - JAG (50), Simbo Klice (81), britrock88 (98)
2 Simbo Klice - CrimsonFox (71), DaddyTorgo (102),

For reference, again the green for GE + Zinto are assumptions, not true greens like Simbo. I also put Brit in green since a duke would be a horrible fake reveal.

[mauchow]

Originally Posted by JAG

For reference, again the green for GE + Zinto are assumptions, not true greens like Simbo. I also put Brit in green since a duke would be a horrible fake reveal.

Yeah, a wolf would gain nothing by fake revealing as a duke. For that reason alone do we make a last minute switch?

[Abe Sargent]

Originally Posted by JAG

Don't feel great about a CF vote. Obviously if Brit is lying, the real duke should duke to him.

What a bad call. Jus keep the vote on him. OIf hes the duke, he dukes iut. If he is lying, then the duke doesn;t have to waste the duke, so no they shouldn;t

[Autumn]

I agree, no reason to switch off Britrock. He dukes it, proves he's who he says, and no harm no foul.

[DaddyTorgo]

Originally Posted by mauboy1

Yeah, a wolf would gain nothing by fake revealing as a duke. For that reason alone do we make a last minute switch?

Absolutely not. We let him use his duke powers and join the COT.

[JAG]

Unvote CF
Vote Britrock

[DaddyTorgo]

DEADLINE

[britrock88]

Okay, I put in for CF. JAG following me along and arguing against a CF vote pinged me.

[mauchow]

Got it. I just wanted to make sure as the deadline approached is all.

My refresh button got good work though.. missed these moments of WW history!

[DaddyTorgo]

Originally Posted by britrock88

Okay, I put in for CF. JAG following me along and arguing against a CF vote pinged me.

Cool. Hopefully we get some good info out of all this. IMO we're narrowing it down pretty well I think.

[Autumn]

Yes, it's not Werewolf until you're refreshing like crazy.

We're good at voting for roled players at least!

[JAG]

Disagree with what you guys are saying, no way any respecting wolf comes out with a fake duke reveal there, but whatever.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by DaddyTorgo

Cool. Hopefully we get some good info out of all this. IMO we're narrowing it down pretty well I think.

I hope so, too... I went against my gut choice, which was you...

[Abe Sargent]

CF is not a bad shot,he's one of DT's five but i wish you had given people a chance, i don't want to Duke off the bodyguard ,you know?

[Chief Rum]

Our ability to root out roled villagers is extremely impressive.

[Abe Sargent]

Well nm, it doesn;t even look like he's ehere

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Abe Sargent

CF is not a bad shot,he's one of DT's five but i wish you had given people a chance, i don't want to Duke off the bodyguard ,you know?

That's why I started asking for ideas 30-45 minutes ago...

[DaddyTorgo]

Originally Posted by britrock88

I hope so, too... I went against my gut choice, which was you...

i'm vanilla villager, so all that would have done is shut up someone who is (hopefully) getting on the wolves' nerves

[DaddyTorgo]

Originally Posted by britrock88

That's why I started asking for ideas 30-45 minutes ago...

yep

[Abe Sargent]

Originally Posted by britrock88

That's why I started asking for ideas 30-45 minutes ago...

Good point, it becomes clear in hindsight.

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by JAG

Disagree with what you guys are saying, no way any respecting wolf comes out with a fake duke reveal there, but whatever.

Well, sometimes wolves try to get too clever, or can't think fast on their feet. It's also possible he's the sorceror and just trying to confuse the issue. A duke who has used his powers though is fully cleared, and also no longer dangerous ;-) Dukings almost never go well.

[JAG]

Originally Posted by britrock88

Okay, I put in for CF. JAG following me along and arguing against a CF vote pinged me.

True, that is a classic wolf move.

[Abe Sargent]

Well JAG, suppose he didn;t duke, now you are forcing teh BG to choose who to block, a revelaed seer or a revealed duke instead of himself and the revealed seer.

[Abe Sargent]

Originally Posted by Autumn

Well, sometimes wolves try to get too clever, or can't think fast on their feet. It's also possible he's the sorceror and just trying to confuse the issue. A duke who has used his powers though is fully cleared, and also no longer dangerous ;-) Dukings almost never go well.

Precisely

[Abe Sargent]

Originally Posted by Autumn

Well, sometimes wolves try to get too clever, or can't think fast on their feet. It's also possible he's the sorceror and just trying to confuse the issue. A duke who has used his powers though is fully cleared, and also no longer dangerous ;-) Dukings almost never go well.

Clearly we thinkt he same on teh duke issue, and you won;t be isolated on that.

[Abe Sargent]

Did EF say he was going to be late tonight? I want to go back and play some more King's Bounty

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Abe Sargent

Well JAG, suppose he didn;t duke, now you are forcing teh BG to choose who to block, a revelaed seer or a revealed duke instead of himself and the revealed seer.

There's no good reason to protect me at this point other than belonging to the COT. I don't have a renewable power like the other roled players.

Originally Posted by Autumn

Well, sometimes wolves try to get too clever, or can't think fast on their feet. It's also possible he's the sorceror and just trying to confuse the issue. A duke who has used his powers though is fully cleared, and also no longer dangerous ;-) Dukings almost never go well.

Originally Posted by Abe Sargent

Clearly we thinkt he same on teh duke issue, and you won;t be isolated on that.

Heh. I invite you two to be assigned the Duke and face a Day 2 lynch to see if you would act differently.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by Abe Sargent

Did EF say he was going to be late tonight? I want to go back and play some more King's Bounty

He did, yeah.

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by Chief Rum

Our ability to root out roled villagers is extremely impressive.

Presuming you're referring to EF, he said after the Day One deadline that he might not be here at deadline tonight, but would run the deadline as soon as he could.

[Autumn]

A mad rush off of Britrock is going to be just as random and possibly dangerous as Britrock duking, so I think it's fine. Or as fine as we can get.

[Abe Sargent]

Originally Posted by britrock88

There's no good reason to protect me at this point other than belonging to the COT. I don't have a renewable power like the other roled players.





Heh. I invite you two to be assigned the Duke and face a Day 2 lynch to see if you would act differently.

Right, i meant if we moved off of you post reveal, and then you said well, no need to Duke then, and didn;t use your power, then the BG has a difficult choice and the wolves have a tempting target.

[Chief Rum]

That was supposed to refer to Abe's looking for EF. And you guys figured it out anyway.

[Autumn]

I wasn't saying you should have acted differently, Britrock. I was responding to the comment about a wolf not claiming Duke.

[britrock88]

Originally Posted by JAG

True, that is a classic wolf move.

Then again, I am terrible at voting and vote analysis...

[britrock88]

Eh, okay, understood now. Sorry to indict you two.