Breakout Kings: Werewolf Style (Game over - village wins)

[bhlloy]

Unvote Chubby
Vote Julio

Don't see any particular reason to vote Chubby and I'm starting to feel a little worse about Julio

[GoldenEagle]

I think a vote on bhlloy gets us more information on whether or not Julio is a potential convert. If bholly is a wolf, then we can lynch Julio as it makes to do so then.

UNVOTE CHUBBY
VOTE BHLLOY

[GoldenEagle]

And by the way, I might take some heat for unvoting Chubby, but I never intended to leave my vote there anyway. I am guessing he will drop out of the lynch running for now. I simply wanted to see how the votes broke down. I didn't expect it to be this active around here.

[britrock88]

bhlloy 4 - Danny (341), Narcizo (353), Zinto (448), GE (502)
GoldenEagle 3 - Autumn (408), CrimsonFox (409), The Jackal (411)
Julio Riddols 2 - LoneStarGirl (464), bhlloy (501)
Chubby 1 - Julio Riddols (444)
Chief 1 - Passacaglia (404)
CrimsonFox 1 - God (375)

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by Chubby

sheesh, i voted day 1. i didn't post a ton of stuff because, it IS day 1

WEll to be fair, I believe until you showed up this afternoon you had one post in the game. It would be very, very difficult to be more inactive than that. I don't think > 1 posts = too talkative.

[Autumn]

I'm all for moving off of Chubby if he's going to be here. But I think it's important to demonstrate that if players disappear (i.e. don't post) they'll get voted out. We have to do that early in the game.

[Chubby]

So

[Chubby]

if

[LoneStarGirl]

Originally Posted by britrock88

bhlloy 4 - Danny (341), Narcizo (353), Zinto (448), GE (502)
GoldenEagle 3 - Autumn (408), CrimsonFox (409), The Jackal (411)
Julio Riddols 2 - LoneStarGirl (464), bhlloy (501)
Chubby 1 - Julio Riddols (444)
Chief 1 - Passacaglia (404)
CrimsonFox 1 - God (375)

I'm tempted to put my vote on GE just to see where Julio puts his vote.

[Chubby]

I

[Chubby]

had

[Chubby]

done

[Chubby]

this

[Chubby]

yesterday

[Chubby]

i'd

[Chubby]

be

[Chubby]

active???

[GoldenEagle]

Originally Posted by Autumn

I'm all for moving off of Chubby if he's going to be here. But I think it's important to demonstrate that if players disappear (i.e. don't post) they'll get voted out. We have to do that early in the game.

I agree with that. The more active players the more fun the game is.

[Chubby]

because the substance of my posts would have been the same yesterday, nada. i don't get the argument people need to be active day 1

[GoldenEagle]

Somehow, I think Chubby is taking a shot at CF here.

[Chubby]

wait not talkative yesterday = wolf... crap...

too talkative today = wolf... crap...


/shrug

[bhlloy]

I wonder why pass is getting such a pass to this point as well?

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by GoldenEagle

Somehow, I think Chubby is taking a shot at CF here.

not really, i just am against the belief that everybody needs to be talkative on day 1. does one need to vote? sure. IMO what difference does it make how many posts a person has on day 1?

now day 2 or 3 and you only have posts with a vote in it then fine, i agree with that sentiment but I think it probably scares off new people when anyone is expected to come in and have deep philosophical WW discussions on day 1

[Chief Rum]

There is a wide berth between a single vote post and War and Peace page by page. It seems a little disingeneous to deny that one vote post on Day One is evidence of inactivity. It very clearly is. Now, as you say, there might be nothing to say on Day One, yes, but inactivity is still inactivity.

Keep in mind, I was about as active as you were on Day One.

[The Jackal]

See this is what werewolf is about. Who's getting defensive because they have the added pressure of being a wolf? Who's getting defensive because they feel they are being unfairly singled out? Is it a mix, is it only the latter?

I don't have a definitive read at this point, but I still feel fairly comfortable with my vote where it is. I'd probably vote bhlloy before Chubby though.

[The Jackal]

I need to read more into why people are looking at Julio, will try to do that when I get home unless someone wants to sum it up, Inigo Montoya style.

[bhlloy]

Originally Posted by The Jackal

See this is what werewolf is about. Who's getting defensive because they have the added pressure of being a wolf? Who's getting defensive because they feel they are being unfairly singled out? Is it a mix, is it only the latter?

I don't have a definitive read at this point, but I still feel fairly comfortable with my vote where it is. I'd probably vote bhlloy before Chubby though.

There is a very important third category you are missing here Jackal

[Chief Rum]

Originally Posted by bhlloy

There is a very important third category you are missing here Jackal

Who is a Kings fan?

[bhlloy]

exactly

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by Chubby

not really, i just am against the belief that everybody needs to be talkative on day 1. does one need to vote? sure. IMO what difference does it make how many posts a person has on day 1?

now day 2 or 3 and you only have posts with a vote in it then fine, i agree with that sentiment but I think it probably scares off new people when anyone is expected to come in and have deep philosophical WW discussions on day 1

I'm sorry but, yes, everyone needs to be talkative, even on Day 1. Not everyone needs to post CrimsonFox levels. But the whole game is based on analyzing what people have said. Nobody every has anything to base a vote on Day 1. Would the game work if nobody posted anything but a vote? No. A lot of nonsense posts doesn't help the game, but neither does saying "I don't nkow anything, nothing to say." No one knows anything, yet we still have to keep posting so that we can learn something. What would you do today if you came in and nobyd had posted all day?

[CrimsonFox]

You're mad at us for not posting?

[Autumn]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

You're mad at us for not posting?

CF, if the term "not posting" was used in a post you can be assured it was not directed at you.

[Autumn]

And my comment isn't really directed at Chubby, so much as that argument, which we hear almost every game, that it's not worth saying anything on day one.

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by Autumn

I'm sorry but, yes, everyone needs to be talkative, even on Day 1. Not everyone needs to post CrimsonFox levels. But the whole game is based on analyzing what people have said. Nobody every has anything to base a vote on Day 1. Would the game work if nobody posted anything but a vote? No. A lot of nonsense posts doesn't help the game, but neither does saying "I don't nkow anything, nothing to say." No one knows anything, yet we still have to keep posting so that we can learn something. What would you do today if you came in and nobyd had posted all day?

i'd vote

[LoneStarGirl]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

You're mad at us for not posting?

I laughed at this.

Who'd get mad about WW?

And who'd accuse YOU or not posting?

[Chubby]

i must increase my post count so people can read something into this very informative post

[CrimsonFox]

I will rephrase without the pronoun trouble.

Chubby is mad at US because he doesn't post and we want him to? That's the argument?

Well Chubby, in black and white, if you don't post you are either considered a hiding wolf or an unhelpful villager and experience has shown that people that say nothing on day 1 and then day 2 continue their silence throughout the game.

[Chubby]

by drawing this much attention to myself i must not be a wolf

[Chubby]

of course, claiming to do something to make yourself not a wolf is very WOLFY

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by Chubby

i must increase my post count so people can read something into this very informative post

This post is a winner. It's very important! Write it down!

[CrimsonFox]

I'm surprised so much momentum has slid off of CHief. And now we're back on julio and bhlloy are we.
huh

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

I will rephrase without the pronoun trouble.

Chubby is mad at US because he doesn't post and we want him to? That's the argument?

Well Chubby, in black and white, if you don't post you are either considered a hiding wolf or an unhelpful villager and experience has shown that people that say nothing on day 1 and then day 2 continue their silence throughout the game.

I'm not mad at anything, i'm pointing out the hypocrity of deriding someone for not posting day 1 (again, as I stated earlier, there's a difference between not posting day 1 and say not posting thru 2 or 3 days) because you don't have anything to read into

who says i want you to read into anything? maybe i'm a wolf trying to hide, maybe i'm roled trying to hide, maybe i'm really just a vanilla villager with nothing to add on the 1st day and can't post from work so I need to wait until i get home?

surely that narrowed it down for autumn

[Chubby]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

This post is a winner. It's very important! Write it down!

i hope everyone can see the hidden message, there is no hidden message.



or is there?

DUH DUH DUHHHHHHH /ominous music

[LoneStarGirl]

Originally Posted by CrimsonFox

I'm surprised so much momentum has slid off of CHief. And now we're back on julio and bhlloy are we.
huh

What do you have against Julio and bhlloy being lynched?

[Chubby]

hmmm CF is trying to buddy up to me HE MUST BE A WOLF

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by LoneStarGirl

What do you have against Julio and bhlloy being lynched?

They saved my life in the war. I owe them for it.

[Chubby]

ok enough screwing around, i think everyone gets the point i'm trying to make.

i have a vote in mind but would like to see some more movement and actual discussion before voting

[CrimsonFox]

Originally Posted by Chubby

ok enough screwing around, i think everyone gets the point i'm trying to make.

i have a vote in mind but would like to see some more movement and actual discussion before voting

I guess. You don't want to post on day 1 and don't see a point to it. I think that's the point. Our point is this is a forum game and it's more fun when everyone posts and plays. I mean that's why we're here right? TO have fun? If not then why are you (the royal you not you specifically) here
This game is more than about votes.

[CrimsonFox]

Hmmmm that was an odd argument and it really doesn't get Chubby off the hook in my book. Chief's gone back to being quiet. I think Julio has it right here.

[Chief Rum]

Chubby's point: Like CF said, doesn't see the point in posting hardly at all on Day One.

The point of the rest of us: That's fine and dandy, but if you choose to post, you must accept the consequences that we who believe this is inactivity will call you inactive and perhaps vote you off for it. Your choice.