1UP REVIEW. GRRR.

[Vast]

http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3161361

This guy is a joke. who cares if barry never celebrated! dork. lol

[JayBee74]

How many seconds do these guys actually play the game? Steve's take on 2K8 is about 100 times more comprehensive.

[Furq]

eh he posted both what he thought were positives and negatives

if the game is about the legends and bringing them back I can see why someone would expect a certain level of detail to make them seem "authentic"

im having fun with the game though

[Killa_Khaos7]

They've been praising Madden and NCAA, and raining on APF since the beginning anyway. Who didn't see this coming?

[Full_Collapse]

I don't know how you run down defense (in video game form or reality) when that's half the battle.

[bugblast]

It got a good review, unless you think 8.5 is bad?

[mike01]

he actually seemed like he liked the game, and then gives it a badscore because of lack of features basically

he had a lot of good things to say, though he is wrong about the right stick offensive moves, you can do more than just wiggle if you use it right

[Vast]

Quote: Originally Posted by Furq

eh he posted both what he thought were positives and negatives if the game is about the legends and bringing them back I can see why someone would expect a certain level of detail to make them seem "authentic" im having fun with the game though

yeah but how authentic is madden making the NFL players? Is he taking points off because Brandon Jacobs doesn't celebrate the way he does in real life? or how do you explain his gripe with having to select the d-line plays? thats one thing i love about the 2k series, its just more control.

Football is more like chess than any other sport out there, 1 play can cost you the game, and this guys complaining about having more options on defense??