LMAO at the fact that you made Ryan Leaf. I am old enough to remember watching that draft where there was so much debate about who was going to make the better pro, Ryan or Peyton. Wow. And they pay these pundits.
At any rate, I love Drayton. He's quick and fast and catches very well in space. He can also make some athletic catches. He's just not the guy you want to throw to in a crowd because he will drop some balls if he gets hit immediately. He's a real threat in the seam, though, vs. cover 2.
I tried Ware, and if you have an OL that has the attribute that makes your QB feel calm under pressure, you can actually get some production out of him. I also like to combo him with a quick back I can run draws with. If you don't have an OL with that attribute, though, and you try to throw under pressure or without your feet set, you're cruising for a bruising.
I might try Brister. I love to switch it up to keep things interesting--I wish more people would do that.
You know who else I really like at QB is Jim Hart. Nobody ever uses him, but I put him on a team where the offense was all bronze and the defense all silver and gold and it was my most dominant team. I got into the 40s in rankings with that squad. He can play.
I wish they had Jim Everett in the game, happy feet and all. I'd love to put him and Ellard and Warner or Dickerson out there and rock some old school Rams. Perhaps in 2020 when this game comes out again.