MVP
|
2014 CABA Hall of Fame (Part 2)
David Davila – Shortstop – Honduras Horsemen – 76.1% First Ballot
David Davila was a 6’0’’, 195 pound right-handed shortstop from San Nicolas, a municipality of nearly 15,000 in western Honduras. Davila was a well-rounded hitter with good contact skills as well as a solid knack for drawing walks and avoiding strikeouts. He had a reliable pop in his bat with 33 doubles and 21 home runs per his 162 game average. Davila’s speed was below average, but he was still a crafty baserunner that could pick his spots.
Finding reliable bats that could play shortstop wasn’t the easiest. Davila played almost exclusively at short and graded as reliably average on the whole. He was above average to good in his earlier years with some struggles at the end. Davila was a hard worker and had respectable durability at a demanding position, leading to a 19-year career. He was never considered the best at any one thing, but being above average to good across the board made him an invaluable piece for Honduras for nearly two decades.
Davila’s entire pro career came with his home country team, taken by Honduras seventh overall in the 1989 CABA Draft. He was a full-time starter immediately, but did miss part of his rookie year to injury. Davila quickly became one of the most popular figures in Tegucigalpa and the entire country.
In addition to his run with the Horsemen, Davila played from 1990-2008 reliably in the World Baseball Championship for Honduras’ national team with 161 games and 151 starts. He posted 118 hits, 65 runs, 31 doubles, 21 home runs, 53 RBI, a .226/.327/.413 slash, 117 wRC+, and 3.3 WAR in his WBC career.
The Horsemen would be a playoff regular during Davila’s tenure, making the postseason 16 times with ten Continental Division titles, 11 appearances in the Caribbean League Championship Series, four pennants, and two CABA titles. Honduras won the CLCS in Davila’s second season of 1991, falling in the CABA finale to Monterrey’s dynasty. Their only losing season from 1990-2007 would come in 1992, Davila’s third year.
Although he missed some time to injury, 1993 saw Davila’s career best in home runs (28, and was his first of nine seasons worth 5+ WAR. He won his first Silver Slugger and got his first CABA title with Honduras getting revenge on Monterrey. The Horsemen remained a playoff regular, but would go the next nine seasons without a pennant due to eventual dynasty runs by both Salvador (1996-99) and Haiti (2000-02).
Davila kept on chugging along, leading in doubles in 1994 with 41 for his second Silver Slugger. He signed a two-year, $4,960,000 extension in April 1994, then a five-year, $16,600,000 add-on in May 1996. 1998 would see a career best in WAR (8.9), triple slash (.340/.411/.569), OPS (.980), runs (100), and RBI (93).
Davila would never be an MVP finalist in his career, but did win 11 Silver Sluggers (1993, 94, 96, 97, 98, 99, 2000, 02, 04, 05, 06). As of 2037, he’s one of only three in CABA history with 11+ Sluggers specifically at shortstop. While Honduras had early playoff exits though, Davila’s numbers were relatively underwhelming with only 0.1 WAR over 35 starts from 1994-2002.
Still, Davila was popular and reliable and few pointed the finger at him for the disappointments. After the 2000 campaign, the now 33-year old Davila signed another five years for $19,000,000. 2002 would be one of his finest seasons with a career high 42 doubles along with a .905 OPS and 7.8 WAR.
In 2003, Honduras took the top seed at 110-52 and finally slayed their divisional foe Salvador on the way to a CABA Championship win over Ecatepec. Davila stepped up and earned finals MVP, posting 13 hits, 3 runs, 3 doubles, 2 homers, and 3 RBI over 12 playoff starts. The Horsemen won the Caribbean crown again in 2004, but lost in a CABA finals rematch with the Explosion.
Honduras would lose in the first round in 2005, then had CLCS defeats in 2006 and 2007 to wrap up a ten-year playoff stretch. For his playoff career, Davila had 111 starts, 112 hits, 42 runs, 21 doubles, 14 home runs, 49 RBI, a .286/.334/.457 slash, 115 wRC+, and 2.1 WAR. His reliable presence in the lineup was greatly appreciated by Honduras and their fans, leading to his #29 uniform’s retirement at the end of his career.
Davila signed a three-year, $18,400,000 extension after the 2005 season. He won his final Silver Slugger in 2006, then was shuffled to a platoon role in 2007. Davila was notably stronger in his career against lefties (.953 OPS, 153 wRC+) compared to righties (.815 OPS, 122 wRC+). Age caught up and he was largely a bench piece with middling results in 2008. He also no longer had the athleticism needed to play shortstop defensively. Davila would retire from the game after the 2008 campaign at age 40.
The final stats saw 2737 hits, 1325 runs, 517 doubles, 331 home runs, 1246 RBI, 747 walks, 116 stolen bases, a .306/.365/.486 slash, 130 wRC+, and 89.3 WAR. Despite almost never leading the league in stats, as of 2037 Davila ranks 32nd in hits, 12th in doubles, and 54th in WAR among position players.
Specifically playing shortstop, Davila has the third-most WAR of any CABA player. There were still a few voters that thought he merely sustained above averageness, but you really couldn’t find a better shortstop in CABA in the 1990s or early 2000s than Davila. He was a big piece to Honduras’ consistent contention and earned the first ballot induction into the Hall of Fame in 2014. While the 76.1% may not be the biggest number, it secured Davila’s spot with the greats.
Alfred “Horseface” Wooster – Outfield/First Base – Torreon Tomahawks – 70.7% First Ballot
Alfred Wooster was a 6’2’’, 205 pound switch-hitting outfielder and first baseman from Road Town, the capital and largest city of the British Virgin Islands. With only around 30,000 for the entire island group, Wooster is unsurprisingly the only Hall of Famer from the British Virgin Islands and one of a small few to play pro baseball from there. He was once insulted by a fan as “horseface,” despite being a fairly average looking guy. The absurdity of the insult was hilarious for his teammates and stuck as Wooster’s career moniker.
On the whole, Wooster graded as a pretty good contact hitter with a respectable eye and average strikeout rate. He had great power, topping 30+ home runs in 11 seasons and 40+ in five seasons. Wooster could find the gap decently with a 162 game average of 24 doubles and 9 triples. He had good quickness and was considered a very crafty baserunner. Wooster was much stronger against right-handed pitching (.974 OPS, 167 wRC+) compared to lefties (.775 OPS, 120 wRC+).
Wooster’s great baserunning speed didn’t translate to great defensive range. He played right field the most with around 2/5s of his starts, while also seeing time at first base, left field, and designated hitter. Wooster graded as a mediocre defender in the outfield, but had good stats at first. He had respectable durability and didn’t miss too many starts over an 18-year career.
He thrived in the very limited amateur scene in the British Virgin Islands, eventually playing elsewhere in the Caribbean in college. Wooster’s induction is believed to make BVI the smallest country by population with an inductee in any league. Wooster got attention ahead of the 1990 CABA Draft and ended up in the Dominican Republic, picked 14th overall by Santiago.
Wooster was mostly a pinch hitter as a rookie and struggled initially. He became a full-time starter with decent results in year two, then figured it out in his third season. A fractured finger cost him a month of 1993, but Wooster still posted a career best 6.6 WAR and led the Caribbean League with a .406 OBP. This would be his only season as a league leader, although he would top 6+ WAR in six different seasons.
Santiago was terrible in the 1980s and into the early 1990s. The Sailfish went 68-94 in 1994, but stunned everyone with a 98-64 mark in 1995. Santiago won the Caribbean League title, falling to Monterrey in the CABA Championship. Wooster had 15 hits, 11 runs, 2 homers, 3 triples, and 8 RBI over the 17 playoff starts.
The Sailfish regressed back to 85-77 in 1996 and a now 28-year old Wooster was headed towards free agency. He couldn’t come to terms with Santiago, who ended up back at the bottom of the standings shortly after. In total for his original squad, Wooster had 884 hits, 442 runs, 112 doubles, 57 triples, 165 home runs, 501 RBI, 212 stolen bases, a .299/.363/.543 slash, 141 wRC+, and 23.5 WAR.
Wooster ended up in Mexico, signing a seven-year, $16,760,000 deal with Torreon. This would become his signature run, becoming very popular with Tomahawks fans and eventually seeing his #35 uniform retired. It wasn’t an immediate success as he only hit 24 home runs in his debut 1997 season. Wooster then missed all of 1998 to a torn ACL suffered in spring training, which made his future prospects murky.
He bounced back impressively and hit 40+ homers and 100+ RBI each year from 1999-2002. 2003 was well on pace for it with 37 homers and a career best 196 wRC+ in 123 games, but shoulder bursitis cost him a month. Torreon would become a contender to start the new Millennium, winning North Division titles in 2001, 2003, and 2004. Each year, they won 100+ games, but each time they lost to Ecatepec in the Mexican League Championship Series.
Wooster held up his end in the postseason for Torreon. In 27 playoff starts, he had 36 hits, 20 runs, 3 doubles, 6 triples, 5 home runs, 17 RBI, 12 walks, a .364/.429/.667 slash, 218 wRC+, and 2.0 WAR. 2003 would be his lone Silver Slugger season in a contract year. The Tomahawks would re-sign a 35-year old Wooster on a three-year, $13,520,000 deal.
In his 30s, Wooster also put up stellar numbers in the World Baseball Championship. With the British Virgin Islands as a territory of the United Kingdom, Wooster was eligible and accepted a spot with England’s team from 2000-2005. Over 60 starts, Wooster had 67 hits, 44 runs, 12 doubles, 20 home runs, 55 RBI, 27 walks, 27 stolen bases, a .338/.450/.722 slash, 235 wRC+, and 5.1 WAR.
A fractured wrist cost Wooster a month in 2004, then a concussion knocked him out most of 2005. When he returned in 2006, Wooster moved him primarily to a platoon starter. He was back in the full-time role in 2007 with solid results at age 38. Torreon would lose in the first round of the 2005 playoffs as a wild card, then just miss the field in 2006 and 2007.
Wooster signed a one-year, $3,920,000 deal for 2007, but Torreon didn’t bring him back after that. Over 11 years, Wooster had 1398 hits, 844 runs, 207 doubles, 62 triples, 329 home runs, 884 RBI, 336 stolen bases, a .299/.357/.581 slash, 164 wRC+, and 47.0 WAR. He stayed a popular figure for Tomahawks fans for years to come, regularly appearing at events for the franchise.
For 2008, Wooster signed a one-year, $4,600,000 deal with Ecatepec, where he became the 40th member of the 500 home run club. He had a solid 3.0 WAR and .863 OPS over 116 starts and 148 games for the Explosion. Wooster also had 15 hits, 8 runs, and 5 extra base hits with 1.0 WAR and 241 wRC+ in only 9 playoff starts as Ecatepec lost to Hermosillo in the MLCS. Wooster was a free agent again for 2009 and surprisingly was unsigned despite still looking solid in 2008. He retired in the winter of 2009 at age 41.
Wooster finished with 2411 hits, 1355 runs, 346 doubles, 124 triples, 519 home runs, 1457 RBI, 678 walks, 571 stolen bases, a .298/.358/.563 slash, 154 wRC+, and 73.5 WAR. As of 2037, he’s 62nd in home runs, 54th in RBI, 57th in runs scored, 100th in WAR among position players, and 85th in hits.
He was steady, but never particularly dominant. Wooster lacked black ink or big awards, which made his resume a bit borderline. He was popular though and had just enough accumulations to win over 70.7% of the voters. Wooster earned the first ballot nod to cap off CABA’s 2014 Hall of Fame class.
|