MVP
|
2020 MLB Hall of Fame
Major League Baseball’s 2020 Hall of Fame class saw two first ballot inductees, although neither breached 80%. OF Lukas Warrell led the way at 76.8% with 2B Cole Becenti close behind at 73.8%. SS Robert Hightower barely missed the 66% requirement with 64.8% for his seventh ballot. This was the closest Hightower has gotten and his third time above 50%.
Five other players were above 50%, led by RF Renaldo Anastasio debuting at 59.6%. C Sebastian Van Velzen got 59.2% for his fourth ballot. 3B Jeanpaul Vick debuted with 57.3%. SP Bob Gallagher earned 56.2% in his tenth and final try, while SP Victor Burke picked up 50.6% for his second chance.
For Gallagher, he peaked at 61.1% in 2018 and had a low of 43.6% in 2017. He spent most of his 15-year MLB run with Cleveland and posted a 226-181 record, 3.22 ERA, 3934.1 innings, 3394 strikeouts, 892 walks, 160 complete games, 111 ERA+, and 79.0 WAR. However, Gallagher lacked black ink and awards and was dismissed as an above average compiler. He also played his final three years in EBF and those extra accumulations might have just gotten him in. But instead, Gallagher fell to the Hall of Pretty Good.
Catcher Jacob Gibson was dropped after ten failed ballots as well, peaking at 46.3% in 2012 and ending at only 10.1%. He had a 21-year career with Edmonton and posted one Gold Glove and one Silver Slugger, 2182 hits, 1142 runs, 393 doubles, 247 home runs, 1081 RBI, 1143 walks, a .254/.345/.391 slash, 107 wRC+, and 66.6 WAR. Among catchers, he ranks 16th in WAR. Gibson had impressive longevity, but he was generally not considered elite. With the trouble even top-tier catchers can have getting inducted, longevity was never going to be enough for Gibson.
Also dropped was reliever Christian Yates, who got as high as 38.4% in 2012 but ended at only 3.7%. He had a 13-year career with 303 saves, 2.30 ERA, 820.1 innings, 885 strikeouts, 252 walks, 159 ERA+, and 29.5 WAR. Yates never won Reliever of the Year and was far less dominant than what was needed for a closer to earn the nod. Still, Yates deserves credit for lasting ten years on the ballot.
Lukas Warrell – Left/Right Field – Albuquerque Isotopes – 76.8% First Ballot
Lukas Warrell was a 6’0’’, 200 pound outfielder from Tucson, Arizona; the state’s second-largest city with just over one million in the metropolitan area. Warrell had an unusual hitting profile as he was incredible at drawing walks, yet terrible at avoiding strikeouts. Against right-handed pitching, he had strong power with above average contact skills, posting a career 145 wRC+ and .914 OPS. Warrell struggled against lefties often with a career 92 wRC+ and .691 OPS.
Warrell’s power was reliable in the middle of the lineup, getting 32 home runs, 22 doubles, and 7 triples per his 162 game average. He had solid speed along with outstanding baserunning and stealing instincts. Warrell was a corner outfielder with about half of his career starts in left field, 1/3 in right field, and the rest as a designated hitter. He graded as a strong RF and above average LF. Warrell’s work ethic and loyalty made him a popular and well respected player. He also showed solid durability over a 22-year career.
From 1990-92, Warrell played college baseball at Clemson, winning an NCAA Gold Glove in 1991 and both a Gold Glove and Silver Slugger in 1992. For his college career, Warrell had 148 games, 124 hits, 99 runs, 20 doubles, 45 home runs, 94 RBI, 111 walks, 121 strikeouts, a .256/.402/.593 slash, 176 wRC+, and 8.0 WAR. In the 1992 MLB Draft, Warrell was picked 24th overall by Albuquerque, making his return to the southwest.
Warrell was a part-time starter with 4.8 WAR in his debut season in 98 starts and 120 games, finishing third in Rookie of the Year voting. He then started all 162 games as a DH in 1994 and won a Silver Slugger, scoring an incredible 150 runs. This not only set a new MLB single-season record, but it was a world record at the time. Warrell’s mark remained the MLB record until 2036 and ranks as the 13th-best season in world history as of 2037. He also led the American Association in walks (102) and had his first of three 40+ home runs seasons. Warrell also posted his first of eight seasons worth 5+ WAR.
Albuquerque ended a six-year playoff drought and got the #2 seed in 1994, but lost in the second round to Atlanta. The Isotopes would be stuck mostly below average in the next six seasons, averaging 76.8 wins. Warrell played well, but was outside of awards conversations or league leading stats. 1998 had a big setback as a severely strained hip muscle knocked him out five months. However, Albuquerque still gave Warrell an eight-year, $40,800,000 extension in the winter.
In 2001, Warrell led the AA in runs (120), walks (102), and WAR (8.9), while getting 41 home runs and 101 RBI, winning a Silver Slugger in LF and taking second in MVP voting. This started a six-year playoff streak for Albuquerque, although they again went one-and-done despite having the first round bye. Warrell did even better in 2002, winning his lone MVP and third Silver Slugger. He led in runs (124), walks (109), OPS (1.044), and WAR (9.6). Warrell’s WAR and OPS were career highs as was were his 46 home runs and 125 RBI.
Albuquerque was a wild card in 2002, but went on a playoff tear for their first American Association pennant since 1975. Warrell was AACS MVP as they ousted Nashville, but the Isotopes did lose to Milwaukee in the World Series. In the playoff run, Warrell had 19 starts, 18 runs, 28 hits, 5 doubles, 2 triples, 4 home runs, 14 RBI, 13 walks, and a 1.133 OPS. The Isotopes had first round losses in 2003, 2004, and 2006. They got back to the AACS in 2005, but fell to top seed Seattle.
Warrell was also a regular during his peak in the World Baseball Championship for the United States, starting 223 games from 1994-2004. He posted 169 hits, 164 runs, 32 doubles, 11 triples, 55 home runs, 55 home runs, 144 RBI, 185 walks, 326 strikeouts, 117 stolen bases, a .220/.382/.506 slash, 157 wRC+, and 11.2 WAR. As of 2037, Warrell has the third most walks and strikeouts in WBC history. He also ranks 15th in runs scored.
In 1996, Warrell was WBC MVP, leading all players in homers (12), RBI (27), walks (17), total bases (70), and WAR (2.2). He led in walks drawn five times, runs twice, strikeouts thrice, and steals twice. Warrell was third in WBC MVP voting in both 1994 and 2002. He was a key part of six world champion American teams (1996, 97, 98, 2000, 01, 03).
After his 2002 MVP season for Albuquerque, Warrell was never quite as dominant again. He was still good enough and well liked to stick around. Warrell declined his contract option after the 2005 season, but inked a new three-year, $30 million deal with the Isotopes. 2006 would be a disaster though with a ruptured Achilles tendon in late June, knocking him out 14 months. Warrell did come back for two more solid seasons to conclude a 16-year run in New Mexico.
The Isotopes got the #1 seed in 2008 at 104-58, but again went one-and-done despite the bye. Warrell’s playoff stats overall weren’t bad over 44 starts, 45 hits, 29 runs, 7 doubles, 4 triples, 8 homers, 26 RBI, 29 walks, 15 steals, a .281/.387/.525 slash, and 142 wRC+. While some critics noted that Albuquerque underperformed in this era, Warrell still helped them to their first pennant in 25 years.
With Albuquerque, Warrell had 2007 hits, 1453 runs, 320 doubles, 107 triples, 447 home runs, 1284 RBI, 1265 walks, 1754 strikeouts, 500 stolen bases, a .266/.376/.515 slash, 139 wRC+, and 84.3 WAR. The Isotopes would eventually retire Warrell’s #14 uniform. He was a free agent for the first time at age 37 and signed a three-year, $35,400,000 deal with Charlotte.
Warrell had a career best 114 walks in his Charlotte debut and got 112 walks two years later. In total, he had 353 hits, 232 runs, 52 doubles, 11 triples, 74 home runs, 219 RBI, 295 walks, .230/.359/.423 slash, 116 wRC+, and 9.7 WAR. The Canaries took the #2 seed in 2011, but went one-and-done. While in Charlotte, Warrell reached the 1500 runs scored and 1500 walks drawn milestones.
Now 40-years old, Warrell signed a three-year, $39,100,000 deal with Calgary. He was merely okay starting in 2012, but trouble struck in August with a broken kneecap. A setback required surgery, putting him out almost all of 2013. Warrell returned as a part-time starter in 2014, but stunk with -0.8 WAR over 86 games. In total for the Cheetahs, he played 212 games for 1.7 WAR, a .697 OPS, and 96 wRC+. Warrell retired after the 2014 season just after his 43rd birthday.
Warrell finished with 2824 games, 2517 hits, 1815 runs, 389 doubles, 123 triples, 557 home runs, 1586 RBI, 1656 walks, 2330 strikeouts, 597 stolen bases, a .256/.368/.491 slash, 132 wRC+, and 95.6 WAR. As of 2037, Warrell ranks 24th in runs, 85th in home runs, 99th in RBI, 6th in walks, 15th in strikeouts, and 70th in WAR among position players. In all of pro baseball history, Warrell sits 14th in walks drawn.
He had a unique skillset with impressive longevity. Warrell’s outstanding 150 run effort in 1994 earned him a significant place in MLB history. He didn’t have the raw dominance of some other Hall of Fame hopefuls, but Warrell hit enough milestones to secure the first ballot nod. He wasn’t an inner-circle guy at 76.8%, but this got him in to lead the two-player 2020 class.
Cole “Buddha” Becenti – Second Base – Orlando Orcas – 73.8% First Ballot
Cole Becenti was a 6’2’’, 200 pound right-handed second baseman from Louisville, Kentucky. He would become the first Kentuckian to earn induction and the first player representing the Orlando Orcas. At his peak, Becenti was a well-rounded hitter that was good to occasionally great in terms of both contact and power. His eye for walks and avoiding strikeouts were both average to slightly below average. Becenti was notably better against left-handed pitching (152 wRC+, .915 OPS) but wasn’t bad against righties (135 wRC+, .843 OPS).
Becenti’s reliable power set him apart from many batters, getting 39 home runs and 30 doubles per his 162 game average. His baserunning skills were alright, but his speed was lousy. Despite that, Becenti’s range was respectable and he graded as reliably average defensively at second base. He started about ¾ of his games at 2B with the rest either at first base or as a designated hitter. Becenti ran into some knee troubles, but still held up for an 18-year pro career. He emerged as the first star player with Orlando, who joined MLB in the 1982 expansion.
It was a rough start for the Orcas, who were the last of those expansion teams to earn a playoff spot. Becenti caught their eye as he put up big numbers at Vanderbilt, winning a Silver Slugger his freshman year in 1996. He took second in NCAA MVP voting that year and third in 1997. As a Commodore, Becenti played 149 games with 174 hits, 110 runs, 33 doubles, 54 home runs, 110 RBI, 79 walks, .316/.406/.670 slash, 215 wRC+, and 11.2 WAR. In the 1998 MLB Draft, Orlando picked him with the #3 overall pick.
Becenti started most of his rookie year with okay results with 2.5 WAR in 131 games, taking third in Rookie of the Year voting. He broke out in his sophomore campaign, leading the American Association in both home runs (48) and WAR (9.9). Becenti won his first Silver Slugger and took second in MVP voting. He posted 6+ WAR each year from 2000-2005 and topped 9+ WAR in 2000, 2003, 2004, and 2005. Becenti won Silver Sluggers in 2002-05 at second base, then again in 2007 as a DH for the Orcas.
In 2003, Becenti won MVP, which was a rare feat for a second baseman. He led again in WAR (9.7) and home runs (50), getting career bests in homers, RBI (124), and hits (203). Orlando earned their first-ever playoff berth and division title, but went one-and-done. Despite Becenti’s best efforts, the Orcas would stay stuck at or below .500 for the rest of his run. Orlando wouldn’t make the playoffs again until 2024.
Becenti led in wRC+ (184) in 2004, although he wasn’t a league leader after that. He would smack 49 home runs in 2007 and breach 35+ dingers in four other seasons. Becenti finished third in 2004 and 2005’s MVP voting. Orlando gave him an eight-year, $61,340,000 extension after the 2002 season. 2006 would be his first major injury setback, missing most of the season to a torn meniscus in his right knee.
He would post three more solid years with the Orcas after that. Becenti also played 71 games from 2001-07 in the World Baseball Championship for the United States with 52 hits, 33 runs, 7 doubles, 17 home runs, 44 RBI, a .843 OPS, 145 wRC+, and 1.9 WAR. Becenti was part of world champion American teams in 2001, 2003, 2005, and 2007.
In total for Orlando, Becenti had 1778 hits, 923 runs, 295 doubles, 399 home runs, 1049 RBI, a .297/.345/.558 slash, 150 wRC+, and 74.0 WAR. His #2 uniform would later be the first number retired by the Orcas. Becenti’s run in central Florida ended after the 2009 season as he declined his contract option, becoming a free agent at age 32. He earned a big paycheck with San Francisco worth $72 million over five years.
Becenti’s Gold Rush debut was his best year, winning his seventh Silver Slugger. However, he tore his right knee meniscus again in 2011, missing most of the year. Becenti would struggle in the next two years in the Bay with only 1.8 WAR over 258 starts. San Francisco wouldn’t make the playoffs during his four year tenure, which saw 447 games, 447 hits, 202 runs, 59 doubles, 91 home runs, 252 RBI, a .262/.306/.461 slash, 116 wRC+, and 9.2 WAR. SF bought out the final year of Becenti’s contract, making him a free agent for 2014 at age 36.
He signed a one-year deal with Omaha and showed some of his old ability, posting 4.5 WAR, a 142 wRC+, .779 OPS, and 30 home runs with the Hawks. However, this was Becenti’s final MLB season. After struggling to find a suitor stateside, he opened up his search worldwide. Becenti ended up in West African Baseball and Burkina Faso on a three-year, $24,000,000 deal with Ouagadougou.
Becenti couldn’t carry over his 2014 momentum to WAB. He was average-at-best over 105 games in 2016 and below average in 2016, missing part of the year to elbow tendinitis. In 217 games for the Osprey, Becenti had 2.9 WAR and 100 wRC+. He didn’t meet the criteria for his deal, becoming a free agent again at age 39. Becenti hoped to catch on somewhere in 2017, but was unsigned and later retired at age 40.
For his MLB career, Becenti ended with 2381 hits, 1196 runs, 379 doubles, 520 home runs, 1383 RBI, a .288/.335/.532 slash, 143 wRC+, and 87.7 WAR. As of 2037, he doesn’t crack the top 100 in any major statistic. However, Becenti does rank 14th in WAR, 5th in home runs, and 18th in RBI accrued at second base. For his era, supporters noted that he was the American Association’s best second baseman.
There were detractors who felt Becenti’s raw numbers weren’t strong enough. Others held his lack of team success as a mark against him. Becenti wasn’t an inner-circle level guy, but in the 2000s you would have been hard pressed to find a better second baseman in MLB. At 73.8%, Becenti got enough for the first ballot induction with MLB’s 2020 Hall of Fame class
|