MVP
|
1986 MLB Hall of Fame
Three players earned induction into the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame in 1986, each of them getting in on the first ballot. Outfielder Garland Mulholland was the star of the group with an impressive 97.3%. Joining him were reliever Thurman Lofink at 83.1% and starting pitcher Edward Delesdernier at 76.6%. Coming close on his ninth try but falling short of the 66% threshold was 1B Braylen Nelson at 60.9%. It is the third time he’s topped 60%. Also above 50% were catchers Russ Spratt at 53.6% on his debut and Gavin Geogham at 52.1% his fourth go.
Only one player was dropped after ten failed ballots in LF Leo Compian, who peaked at 35.1% on his fourth attempt and ended at 12.4%. He had a 21-year career and was a starter for San Diego’s 1950s dynasty run, posting 2465 hits, 1633 runs, 315 doubles, 449 home runs, 1328 RBI, a .271/.382/.472 slash, and 75.6 WAR. He also drew 1604 walks, one of only nine MLB players as of 2036 to have more than 1600. Compian was dismissed as a compiler though with only one Silver Slugger to his name. Pitcher Will Feliciano was also removed from the ballot after getting elected to Beisbol Sudamerica’s 1986 class. (Editor’s note: The way OOTP works, once a guy is elected to any HOF, they’re removed from the ballot of the other leagues. They show up on the HOF list for any of the leagues they played in).
Garland Mulholland – Outfielder – St. Louis Cardinals – 97.3% First Ballot
Garland Mulholland was a 6’4’’, 200 pound right-handed outfielder from Richmond Heights, Ohio; a Cleveland suburb with around 10,000 people. Mulholland was a very good contact hitter with a great eye and impeccable ability to avoid strikeouts. He retired with a 4.8% strikeout percentage and is one of a very select group of Hall of Famers to have played 2500+ games and struck out fewer than 600 times. Mulholland wasn’t just a guy who drew walks and got singles though as he averaged around 25 home runs and 25-30 doubles/triples per year. He also had solid speed and baserunning skills. Mulholland primarily played left field, although he did make starts in right and center. He was viewed as a pretty good defender in the corners and weak defender in center. On top of this, Mulholland was a team captain and clubhouse leader, viewed as a stand-up guy that was universally beloved.
He attended college at South Carolina and in 144 college games had 167 hits, 73 runs, 33 doubles, 13 home runs, a .293/.348/.430 slash, and 4.2 WAR. In the 1958 MLB Draft, Mulholland was picked 55th overall by St. Louis, the second pick of the supplemental first round. He spent all of 1959 in minor league Columbia and most of 1960 there, although he made 21 plate appearances in the bigs in 1960. Mulholland’s proper debut came in 1961 where he earned the full-time starter role, which he’d have for nearly the next two decades save time missed to injury.
In 1961, Mulholland posted a 5.8 WAR rookie season to earn the National Association Rookie of the Year. In 1962, he won the batting title (.351) and led with 202 wRC+, earning his first of seven Silver Sluggers. Mulholland also won the award in 1963, 64, 65, 67, 68, and 69. 1962 also saw a third place finish in MVP voting despite a historically bad 54-108 season for the Cardinals. This also marked the start of Mulholland playing for the United States in the World Baseball Championship. From 1962-76, he played 187 games and made 173 starts with 182 hits, 137 runs, 45 home runs, 118 RBI, a 302/.421/.568 slash, and 10.6 WAR. Mulholland was a part of eight world title teams and three times was a finalist for tournament MVP.
Mulholland played a huge role in turning around St. Louis’s fortunes as 1963 saw one of the greatest turnaround seasons in MLB history. The Cardinals went from 54 wins to 101, earning their first playoff appearance since 1930. Mulholland had a career best 10.2 WAR and bests in the triple slash (.358/.427/.603), OPS (1.030), and wRC+ (211). He took third in the MVP voting, but picked up 18 hits and 7 runs in the postseason as St. Louis won the World Series for the second time in history. That run alone cemented him as forever a Cardinals favorite, whose #34 would later be retired.
St. Louis made seven playoff appearances over the next nine years, although they never got out of the second round. Still, they were consistently in the mix with Mulholland after being bottom tier for a long time. He won two more batting titles and led in OBP twice and hits once. Mulholland’s lone MVP win came in 1965, but he was regularly a finalist (3rd in 1965, 2nd in 1967, 2nd in 1968, 2nd in 1969, and 3rd in 1970). In 1971, he won the All-Star Game MVP. Mulholland was as steady and reliable as you could be with his only missed time coming from a torn flexor tendon in 1966. Although the Cardinals struggled in later postseasons, Mulholland still had 51 hits, 29 runs, and a .321/.396/.434 slash in 43 playoff starts.
For his entire Cardinals career, Mulholland had 2125 hits, 1183 runs, 241 doubles, 87 triples, 312 home runs, 1038 RBI, 783 walks, 480 stolen bases, a .326/.402/.532 slash, 180 wRC+, and 90.4 WAR. This alone probably was enough to get into the Hall of Fame, but he would have another decade in front of him. At age 34, Mulholland opted out of the final year of the eight-year, $1,972,000 extension he had signed in 1965. He signed a four-year, $1,472,000 deal with Albuquerque.
Mulholland was never quite the same level player with the Isotopes and missed chunks of his first two seasons to injury. He had a solid 1975 full season and although his playoff stats weren’t anything great, Mulholland’s leadership helped Albuquerque win the 1975 World Series, their first title since 1934. In four seasons as an Isotope, Mulholland had 509 hits, 314 runs, a .278/.360/.463 slash and 12.0 WAR.
Now 38 years old, Mulholland’s contract expired and he signed a three-year deal with Columbus. He still provided respectable value in his first two seasons with the Chargers, but he struggled in the third season and was eventually relegated to a bench role. This effectively ended his MLB career, although Mulholland wasn’t ready to retire and wanted to get to 3000 hits. He was unsigned for most of 1980, making one start with Seattle that fall. Minor League Charleston (Charlotte’s affiliate) briefly employed him in 1981, but he didn’t see the field and eventually had to retire at age 43.
Mulholland’s final stats: 2978 hits, 1719 runs, 359 doubles, 115 triples, 435 home runs, 1422 RBI, 1191 walks to only 540 strikeouts, 658 stolen bases, a .306/.387/.501 slash, 161 wRC+, and 109.9 WAR. At induction, he had the tenth most WAR of any MLB batter. Mulholland was a beloved figure and an undisputed great of the 1960s and 70s, getting him the first ballot induction at 97.3%.
Thurman Lofink – Closer – New Orleans Mudcats – 83.1% First Ballot
Thurman Lofink was a 6’6’’, 195 pound left-handed closer from the west Texas city of El Paso. Lofink had electric stuff with very good movement and solid control. The lanky lefty had two pitches, a 97-99 mph sinker and an unhittable curveball. Lofink was also very good at holding runners, making him a great pitcher to get you out of a jam. His main downside was being a loudmouth jerk. His outspoken personality and spicy hot takes didn’t make him a lot of friends, although he would be popular among a certain type of fan.
Lofink attended West Virginia and was iffy as a starter in college, getting moved to the bullpen as a junior. He took third in 1964’s college Reliever of the Year voting, but true relievers didn’t tend to get a ton of attention in the draft. New Orleans picked Lofink with the first pick of the fourth round, 149th overall, in the 1964 MLB Draft. He immediately was thrown into the bullpen and saw regular use, often as a closer. Lofink was second in 1966’s Reliever of the Year voting and led the American Association in saves in 1968 with 35.
Lofink’s biggest claim to fame would come from 1970 to 1972, as New Orleans had their historic dynasty. After being a bottom rung franchsie for nearly 70 years, the Mudcats won three straight World Series rings. Lofink was a stud in the 1970 playoffs with six saves and 10 scoreless innings. In total, he had a 0.60 ERA over 45.1 playoff innings, 14 saves, 64 strikeouts, and 3.3 WAR. The playoff heroism earned him a spot in the hearts of New Orleans fans despite his outspoken nature and was a big reason his #5 uniform would be retired by the franchise. Lofink also took second in Reliever of the Year voting in both 1970 and 1972.
Lofink also earned Best Pitcher honors in both the 1971 and 1972 World Baseball Championship for the United States. In 1971, he had a 0.29 ERA and 72 strikeouts over 30.2 innings, then followed it up with a 0.83 ERA over 21.2 innings with 46 strikeouts. In total from 1967-80, Lofink tossed 169 innings with a 1.44 ERA, 21 saves, 327 strikeouts, and 9.3 WAR. After the 1972 season, Lofink (rightly) thought he was pretty big deal.
For his New Orleans run, he had 175 saves and 208 shutdowns, a 2.04 ERA, 513 innings, 640 strikeouts, and 25.9 WAR. Fresh off the three-peat and back-to-back Best Pitcher honors in the WBC, the 29-year old Lofink wanted to cash in. He left the Mudcats, but couldn’t find the massive money he was looking for. Lofink signed a one-year, $332,000 deal with Baltimore in April 1973. After a solid effort, he then signed a one-year, $414,000 deal with Montreal. Lofink delivered his usual production, then got a two-year, $834,000 deal with New York.
Although he liked the paycheck, the Yankees didn’t use Lofink as a closer. He wasn’t thrilled with his use and before the 1977 season, New York traded him to Houston for five prospects. Lofink reclaimed a closer role with the Hornets and spent four years there, helping them to three American Association Championship Series appearances. With Houston, he had 116 saves, a 2.19 ERA, 243 innings, 320 strikeouts, and 11.0 WAR. In his final season with the Hornets though, his production fell to middling levels and he wasn’t re-signed.
At age 37, Lofink still wanted to be a MLB closer, but many teams felt he was past his prime. The others that might have considered him didn’t think he was worth the big paycheck with his loud mouth. This marked the end of his MLB career, although he wasn’t ready to be done with baseball. A connection sent him to an unlikely place; Ghana. He signed with Kumasi of West African Baseball, although he only pitched 28 innings. Lofink was good in his limited use though and got a contract and a closer role again, this time in Liberia.
Lofink signed with Monrovia for 1982 and led with 41 saves. In 1983, he started with the Diplomats and was traded at the deadline to Nouakchott. Between the two though, he won his first-ever Reliever of the Year at age 39. In 1984, he signed with Port Harcourt and won Reliever of the Year for the second time. In total in WAB, he had 109 saves over 282 innings, 446 strikeouts, 1.56 ERA, and 15.4 WAR. However, late in the 1984 season, Lofink suffered a damaged elbow ligament that effectively ended his career. He was briefly signed in a comeback attempt in 1985 with Tampa, but never threw another pitch, retiring at age 41.
For his entire pro career, Lofink had 472 saves and a 1.92 ERA, 1288 innings, 1713 strikeouts, and 65.0 WAR. For just MLB, he had a 2.02 ERA, 363 saves and 431 shutdowns, 1006 innings, 1267 strikeouts, 260 walks, a FIP- of 46, and 49.5 WAR. At induction, he had the fifth most WAR of any MLB reliever. Although he never won the top award in MLB, Lofink was a great closer and a big part in the New Orleans dynasty. Even voters who thought he was a loudmouth goof couldn’t deny his resume, giving Lofink the first ballot induction with 83.1%.
Edward Delesdernier – Starting Pitcher – Nashville Knights – 76.6% First Ballot
Edward Delesdernier was a 6’0’’, 200 pound right-handed pitcher from Seven Oaks, South Carolina; a town of around 14,000 people in the center of the state. Delesdernier was a fireballer with 99-101 mph peak velocity and electric stuff, although he had solid movement and control as well. His fastball and curveball were his main two pitches, although he did also mix in a changeup. Delesdernier was also known for great stamina and going deep in games early in his career, although later injuries ruined that in the back end of his career. He was very intelligent, but considered a bit of a loner and mercenary type.
Delesdernier played collegiately at Virginia and had a great college career with a 22-5 record and 2.19 ERA over 303.2 college innings with 322 strikeouts and 12.7 WAR. He was one of the hottest prospects for the 1964 MLB Draft and was picked second overall by Nashville. Delesdernier was a part-time starter in his rookie year, but took over a full-time role from his second season onward. He posted five straight seasons worth 6+ WAR for the Knights and led the American Association with a 2.57 ERA in 1968. That earned Delesdernier a second place finish in Pitcher of the Year voting.
His first major setback came with a torn labrum in late 1970, putting him out nearly a full calendar year. In total with Nashville, Delesdernier had a 84-67 record, 2.98 ERA, 1483.2 innings, 1344 strikeouts, and 39.5 WAR. The Knights stunk during his run though and he made it clear to management that he wasn’t planning on sticking around. Plus, they weren’t sure what he’d look like coming off a major injury. Nashville traded him at the 1971 deadline to Philadelphia.
Delesdernier made 11 starts with the Phillies and looked dominant with a 1.55 ERA over 87 innings. This made him a hot commodity entering free agency in 1972 at age 28. His terms for a long-term contract proved too rich for other teams and Delesdernier wasn’t signed until the very start of the year. He ended up a with a one-year, $330,000 deal with Montreal. Delesdernier had a great year with the Maples, taking second in Pitcher of the Year voting and helping them to a World Series appearance. He entered free agency again though and finally got the bag he was looking for, a seven-year, $2,868,000 deal with Phoenix.
It proved a sound investment for the Firebirds in the first three seasons. Delesdernier’s second year in Phoenix saw only the fifth Triple Crown season for a MLB pitcher to that point with a 26-8 record, 2.16 ERA, and 313 strikeouts worth 10.2 WAR. He finally won Pitcher of the Year and even took second in MVP voting. Although he delivered early on, the Firebirds never became the high-level playoff contender they hoped to become, although they did get to the AACS in 1977.
By then though, Delesdernier’s value was diminishing, in part due to shoulder and hamstring issues. He had only partial 1976 and 1977 seasons with average at best results, then struggled in 1978. That summer, a damaged elbow ligament would put him on the shelf for 12 months. In total with Phoenix, Delesdernier had an 84-72 record, 3.28 ERA, 1374.1 innings, 210 strikeouts, and 35.1 WAR.
He tried to make a comeback in 1979 at age 35, but struggled in only two starts with Phoenix. On the last year of his big contract making $464,000, the Firebirds decided to trade him in June to Columbus. He did better with the Chargers, but was still subpar. Delesdernier signed with Minneapolis in 1980, but was cut midseason due to poor performance. He’d make one minor league appearance in Richmond before having to retire at age 36.
Delesdernier’s final stats: 197-160 record, 3.06 ERA, 3386 innings, 2990 strikeouts to 877 walks, 257/418 quality starts, 213 complete games, 77 FIP- and 87.4 WAR. He managed to build a solid resume despite a relatively short peak. His accumulations were lower than most other MLB Hall of Famers and he was one of a small list of starters to get in without 200 wins. Delesdernier’s Triple Crown season helped boost him and the pitcher-friendly voters gave him the bump needed for a first ballot induction at 76.6%.
|