GOAT Contenders: Where is Kobe now?
By Helena Ramirez
The NBA’s offseason is chugging along as the draft has now passed and free agency is nearly upon us … but the conversation about the GOAT (Greatest of All-Time) continues to go on. No matter the time of year, no matter the status of the world, no matter what you thought before, the GOAT conversation can always be revisited, always be reignited.
Entering the 2010-11 season, it’s time to revisit the rankings, particularly on where one Kobe Bryant now ranks. Kobe has been the premier acolyte of Michael Jordan, almost since he entered the league — the comparisons between the two have been flying since 1996. They’ve engaged in some memorable games against one another, notably their memorable Finals contest in 2000 (where Jordan proved he still had a killer instinct). Since Jordan retired, the man has been largely been hailed as the GOAT.
There are arguments otherwise; Kareem has 6 titles to Jordan’s 5, but Kareem also played with Oscar Robertson or Magic Johnson for most of his career … and certainly, Kareem never held the imaginations of fellow players or fans like Jordan. Magic has the same amount of titles as Jordan, but had the benefit of Kareem most of his career … not to mention, during the 80s, the West wasn’t nearly as competitive as the East.
Then there’s Bill Russell — how can you argue with all those rings? Easy to do so, when you consider how weak the NBA was during Russell’s heyday. Russell accomplished much but did so in a smaller, weaker, and nearly unrecognizable era.
Jordan’s the GOAT for most, here in the USA and around the world. So if he’s number 1, which players still playing have the best chance to dethrone him? Who are the top contenders for GOAT status?
1. Kobe Bryant
He’s entering year 15 with more miles on his legs than Jordan had at this stage thanks to a combination of long postseason runs, a lack of lockouts and premature retirements, and a lot of Olympic play; but Kobe is still getting it done and now sports 5 rings after the last Finals, where he single-handedly buried Boston in a critical Game 7. It was the type of killer, legendary performance that MJ would have put on, the highest praise one could give a Jordan acolyte like Kobe.
In the rings department, he’s tied his mentor, and Kobe has a chance to add more — which would give him an advantage. But rings alone don’t make a GOAT (otherwise Russell would be the undisputed GOAT). It takes on-court pizazz, off-court savvy, consistency, and iconic moments to cement yourself in the minds of the population as a GOAT. Kobe has those in some degree and he’s still not done authoring his career. When it’s all said and done, he may be the best ever … but it’s still a long climb to the top of the mountain.
The case against him isn’t as long as some players, but still hurts. He left Miami, in the dead of night, after he and Riley couldn’t get along during the lockout shortened 1998-99 season. He only managed one ring playing with Shaq. He went through a stretch in the mid-2000s that saw his teams barely limp into the playoffs and become cannon fodder. He leveled the confidence of multiple players to the point they were never effective again (Smush Parker, Kwame Brown) … like Jordan, he became frustrated and took it out on his team.
Ultimately, the biggest case against Kobe may be he’s just too close to Jordan … the difference between an original work and a superb copy.
2. LeBron James
Year 8 of the LBJ experience will start somewhere new, though where is the question NBA insiders aren’t sure about. James has made it clear to his close-knit circle that Cleveland is not in his plans after their disastrous 35-47 season, where LeBron carried an injured, old, and broken down roster to just a few games within a playoff spot. Cleveland’s legion of fans have largely made peace with LBJ’s coming departure — few of them can blame him for the mess that last season was. Everyone knew Cleveland had to knock it out of the park this year to have a chance and they fell very short of that.
LeBron’s case for GOAT isn’t strong at this point — no rings, many individual awards, and a history of his team just not being good enough. Right now he’s in the “early Jordan” stage of his career, where he’s an excellent single player but struggles to get that kind of production from around him. His individual talent is astounding, however, so much so that the physical marvel he is gets him in this conversation before many.
If LeBron is going to make a case as the GOAT, he’s going to have to win a title at least — probably multiple — and do things that Jordan and Kobe haven’t done (which he absolutely can do thanks to his incredible play).
3. Dwyane Wade
Wade came into the league the same year as LeBron, but is a few years older and thusly expectations for his career are a bit higher. Now 29, Wade has one ring to his name, a number of individual awards, and a legion of Heat fans who hold him in high esteem. Much like LeBron and Cleveland, Wade is THE guy in Miami — perhaps more so than any other player in the Heat’s short history — but unlike LeBron, Wade is strongly considering staying with the team that drafted him.
The last few years haven’t been easy for him. Shaq and he managed two trips to the Finals, losing in 2005 and winning in 2006, then got swept in round 1 of the ECF in 2007 — and then Shaq was gone. In the years since, Miami’s front office has been doing enough to keep the team competitive while maintaining massive flexibility and Wade has been on board the whole way.
The case against him is a long one — he’s been largely absent the last few years, at least as far as contention. His individual greatness is good, but not on the same level as LeBron. He has a deeper list of historical predecessors that he struggles to measure against; it’s tough to put Wade in the top-10 of his position, so how can he be in the conversation for GOAT?
4. Carmelo Anthony
Melo has something neither Wade, LeBron, or Kobe has: an NCAA title. His run at Syracuse, brief as it was, resulted in a championship and him being picked by Denver in the 2003 draft. Since then, Melo’s career has been largely good but not great. He has never advanced past the WCF in the playoffs. He’s barely made it out of round 1 most years.
But his scoring brilliance is mesmerizing, and he certainly captures the imaginations of many people with his ability to seemingly hit from anywhere on the court. His lack of defense has been largely forgiven despite his lack of team success. He may be this generation’s most offensively gifted player.
Where Melo and Denver go this year is of huge importance to not only the Nuggets franchise, but Melo himself; he could demand a trade out, which some in his camp are pushing for. He could ride it out, like Wade, and wait for the front office to strike when massive cap space comes available next summer. It’s a crossroads for Melo, one that could determine just how much further he moves up this list … or how far he drops off it.
5. RJ Jordan
A rookie? A rookie. Jordan hasn’t even taken the court in the NBA yet, but already there is a massive push — and subsequent pushback — that he’s the “true heir” to Michael Jordan. It’s tough to argue that RJ doesn’t have a chance; son of Jordan, plays in many ways like him, has had a stellar college career for the one year he was at Duke.
His genetics are good enough that he could do it … but then again, RJ’s two older brothers also had those genetics and neither lasted in the NBA beyond a cup of coffee. RJ’s selection by the snake-bitten Wizards franchise — a place so far gone even Michael Jordan couldn’t get them into the playoffs (an older MJ but still) — has made people question if his early career will be marred by organizational failure mirrored by his own individual brilliance.
Ultimately, we’ll know more about RJ’s career trajectory after this upcoming season; if he wows the league like his father did in year 1 (MJ put up 28 PPG, 7 RPG, 6 APG on 52% from the field and an awful 17% from three — a different era), then he’ll have the bare beginnings of a case.