Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

[berenjena]

After playing 400 games.

I just recently discovered the "Triple Play challenge"...wow.

I got a Goldy in my second try...awesome... but I don't need him and just sold him. I got Rizzo there...who happens to be a God at 1st base.

My outfield consist of Pederson LF (Probably my most consistent player), Adam Jones CF....and Chris Davis or Reddick RF.

With the stubs I got from Selling Goldy (along with some stubs I already had)...I have the unique option of Buying a Harper Straight Up or grabbing Pedroia/Ramirez and finally get my Teddy.

Any recommendations?

If I get Harper, he would go to RF. If I get Ted...he would go to LF, with Pederson moving to CF, and Adam Jones to RF.

[dta151]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Get them both. I did and you won't regret it.I had Harper from day 1 but recently got Trout and Now Williams to play left and it is just awesome to look at my lineup screen and see that outfield of LF Williams CF Trout RF Harper . I dont even have to play to enjoy it but Harper has been the best for me from the start but Rizzo is my 1B also and he is great too. I just got Williams so I cant say if he is better than Harper yet but why have to pick one. Keep playing the DP challenge or TP challenge and you will be able to get both

[berenjena]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Get them both. I did and you won't regret it.I had Harper from day 1 but recently got Trout and Now Williams to play left and it is just awesome to look at my lineup screen and see that outfield of LF Williams CF Trout RF Harper . I dont even have to play to enjoy it but Harper has been the best for me from the start but Rizzo is my 1B also and he is great too. I just got Williams so I cant say if he is better than Harper yet but why have to pick one. Keep playing the DP challenge or TP challenge and you will be able to get both

Thanks!

I'm honestly tired at this point of playing with Gold/Silver players.

I got to a 1950+ rating like this but fell into a slump and now my rating is 1850...I want to know how it feels to play with a stud at every position.

Also...is Brett the best 3rd baseman in the game?

Is Carew a big improvement over Kolten Wong?

[cnemergut]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Go with both. I have them as my number 3 and 4 hitters right now with Fred McGriff right after. It's a murders row for me since for some reason i'm unstoppable with McGriff (1.200 OPS). If you could only pick 1 though I would go with Harper. He's faster (73 spd to 56 spd) and his arm is much better 65 arm to 85 or something)

[BigDaddyRev]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Thanks!

I'm honestly tired at this point of playing with Gold/Silver players.

I got to a 1950+ rating like this but fell into a slump and now my rating is 1850...I want to know how it feels to play with a stud at every position.

Also...is Brett the best 3rd baseman in the game?

Is Carew a big improvement over Kolten Wong?

Some people will say Mike Scmitt (sp) is the best third baseman but Brett just hits for me most dependable player I have as for Wong anybody is a upgrade lol I cant play with Carew for whatever reason but Kipnis lights out

[BlessingSpore72]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Get them both. I did and you won't regret it.I had Harper from day 1 but recently got Trout and Now Williams to play left and it is just awesome to look at my lineup screen and see that outfield of LF Williams CF Trout RF Harper . I dont even have to play to enjoy it but Harper has been the best for me from the start but Rizzo is my 1B also and he is great too. I just got Williams so I cant say if he is better than Harper yet but why have to pick one. Keep playing the DP challenge or TP challenge and you will be able to get both

I have the same outfield. And yes it it does look awesome and they rake. I am convinced Ted Williams is the best batter in the game. I have him batting 4th. I have harper leading off. Trout was leading off but i switched him with Harper and is now second and for whatever reason he has started to rake for me batting second

[LewisCAVS]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

I didn't really like Harper for whatever reason, for me Dave Winfield is the best right fielder on the game

[johntait1]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

I'd recommend using your stubs to flip cards and get enough stubs to buy both.

[berenjena]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Okay. Williams in just OP in this game and by far the best hitter in the game.

I first went with Harper....after 30 AB's or so...realize that he's not as dominant as I imagined...my timing with him just wasn't there.

Sold him and completed the Williams collection.

All I've done is hit since then. Seriously...lefty or righty...it doesn't matter. Williams can hit any pitch for a hit.

.429 Average in 42 AB, 4 homeruns, 6 BB to 7 Strikeouts (Mostly looking) with a .1400 OPS. .419 Vs righties, .455 against lefties.

Truly a monster.

[Chiefpot]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Any recommendations on a stadium using teddy, cutch, harper?

[Cincyez]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Houstons stadium. Opposite field homers all day.

[TonyDanzaFan]

Re: Bryce Harper or Ted Williams?

Any recommendations on a stadium using teddy, cutch, harper?

Yankee stadium by far. Personally it took me a while to use Harper but he's incredible. I platoon him though. I've only had Ted for two weeks but I'm not crushing it with him. I make a lot of contact but the power isn't there. I hit four bombs in the first five games and none ever since. I think I'm trying to hard with him.