Some good ratings info off Grassy....

[OHguy00]

Quote: Originally Posted by common-sense

#42 rolb is not bobby carpenter because he is not an impact player for osu i dont think #21 fs is nate salley. he aint that good, is he?? i saw on a screenshot that tOSU's impact players are Ginn, Holmes, and Hawk

Salley is that good. He should go early on draft day.

Maybe Carpenter isn't an impact player, but he definitely should be ranked around a 93. Or, maybe big teams have more than 3 impact players.

[Nivek]

holly crap, #9 WR was Travis Wilson!

Btw, FSU is gonna be STACKED!!!! EA givin' em some groupie love!!!
Add to the list:
David Castillo- FSU (93 overall)
Pat Watkins- FSU (92 overall)

[Bill_Abner]

Quote: Originally Posted by OHguy00

Salley is that good. He should go early on draft day. Maybe Carpenter isn't an impact player, but he definitely should be ranked around a 93. Or, maybe big teams have more than 3 impact players.

OSU has some odd ratings IMO.

They have Whitner at CB, which is wrong; they have MLB Anthony Schlegal with more speed than Carpenter which is just so wrong that it's bizarre and they have FB Brandon Schittker as a tank, which I dont get either. They also have Zwick rated way too high IMO. I think Ginn is a hard player to rate. He should NOT be a 90 rated WR. He has not proven to be an elite WR yet but I dunno how you reflect how special he is in a game like this. It's kinda hard to do.

[Programmed2Kill]

Quote: Originally Posted by Nivek

holly crap, #9 WR was Travis Wilson! Btw, FSU is gonna be STACKED!!!! EA givin' em some groupie love!!! Add to the list: David Castillo- FSU (93 overall) Pat Watkins- FSU (92 overall)

Now if only they could beat Miami...


Hey, I would've thought Rocky McIntosh would be up there in the OLBs. Oh well.

[common-sense]

ginn isn't great reciever as far as route running and such but once he gets the ball in hands, he is one of the best players in college football. Thats why he gets that 90.



also is Zwick rated higher than Troy Smith??? cus he definitely shouldn't be. Smith should be rated higher with tha, thp, and the speed agility ratings of course.

[OHguy00]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bill_Abner

OSU has some odd ratings IMO. They have Whitner at CB, which is wrong; they have MLB Anthony Schlegal with more speed than Carpenter which is just so wrong that it's bizarre and they have FB Brandon Schittker as a tank, which I dont get either. They also have Zwick rated way too high IMO. I think Ginn is a hard player to rate. He should NOT be a 90 rated WR. He has not proven to be an elite WR yet but I dunno how you reflect how special he is in a game like this. It's kinda hard to do.

I didn't even notice that. Good thing we can change positions, so I can move Whitner back to SS. Having Schlegel faster than Carpenter is just wrong. I think Ginn is a little overrated as a WR. I guess they could just give him great speed, agility, and acceleration.

Do they have Jamario O'Neal as a FS or a CB?

[randyf]

Quote: Originally Posted by OHguy00

I don't think anyone posted this yet, but ROLB #42 (93 overall) is probably Bobby Carpenter for OSU.

Bobby Carpenter has done nothing to be a 93. I am guessing it is Ricardo Hurley from USC (South Carolina). It is a stretch but if Ko Simpson is the best FS then some one at EA has some love for the cocks

[Acid]

Quote: Originally Posted by randyf

Bobby Carpenter has done nothing to be a 93. I am guessing it is Ricardo Hurley from USC (South Carolina). It is a stretch but if Ko Simpson is the best FS then some one at EA has some love for the cocks

I can't help myself but laugh at that.