When Will We See Freshmen Ratings?

[jimcrow19]

Quote: Originally Posted by theaub

Yeah...Smith and Mustain not on this list is weird...not to mention that #35 on FSU's website is a senior fullback.

#35 is marcus sims....ernie sims brother

[Mprophetess]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

Anyone remember when they started popping up last year? I am definitely interested to see how Myron Rolle is in the game. I know historically EA has been favorable to players who entered school in January.

myron rolle ratings or
Myron Rolle
ovr:87
Sp:91
Str:70
Awr:65
AGI:95
ACC:94
Cth:70
Car:78
JMp:91
BTK:78
Tak:76

[sixthgradetyrant]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

Here are FSU's true frosh ratings: Myron Rolle - 87 ovr (highest freshman rating ever) Brandon Warren - 83 Caz Piurowski - 83 Marcus Sims - 82 Damon McDaniel - 80 Marcus Ball - 80 Anthony Leon - 81 Justin Mincey - 80

Not true.

In NCAA 02 (I think -- the one that only was available for PS2 w/Weinke on the cover) an OL on Tennessee was an 88 or 90, I believe. I think he was supposed to be Michael Munoz, but in 03 and 04 it was obvious that he was supposed to be Victor McClure, a do-nothing TE who ended his career as nothing more than a situational blocker.

Nivek, you got my back on this one? (And where the hell is that 02 soundtrack music?!)

[sixthgradetyrant]

Quote: Originally Posted by randyf

those ratings don't make much sense to me FSU got 1 RB and he was a 2 star according to scout.com why would he be the 19th best player in the nation. I don't know why Myron Rolle should get an 87 OVR that is too high for any freshman, according to rivals he wasn't even a top 10 player, Harvin was #1. Mustain was regarded by every recruiting service in the nation as the number 1 QB and he isnt in the top 25? These can't be right at all, I thought Whipsmart said that Tebow was an 85 and so was Mustain

Sims was rated at LB on most lists, but he was also a 4* RB. Just like his bro.

[sixthgradetyrant]

Quote: Originally Posted by GatorBait

EA has made some head scratching mistakes with freshman this year. Not having Juice in the game is a huge mistake. Also, EA rated Running Backs Demarco Murray and James Aldridge higher than Chris Wells (the #1 RB on both Scout and Rivals).

If you're an Insider at ESPN, check out their list from last year. It had Murray and Aldridge both rated higher the Wells. Maybe ESPN integration is alive and well in frosh ratings, eh...?

[theaub]

Quote: Originally Posted by jimcrow19

#35 is marcus sims....ernie sims brother

I see...

[Nivek]

Quote: Originally Posted by sixthgradetyrant

Not true. Nivek, you got my back on this one? (And where the hell is that 02 soundtrack music?!)

Oh yeah, I'll upload those when I get home tonite. I'll PM you...

[sixthgradetyrant]

Quote: Originally Posted by Nivek

Oh yeah, I'll upload those when I get home tonite. I'll PM you...

Many thanks, brother. A true man can only take so much marching band music...