To Date, Is NCAA 2007 The Best Football Game You've Played?

[2krules]

Quote: Originally Posted by srudoff

this poll should just be renamed "is this game better than 2k5" because everyone who votes no, can only be using 2k5 as their reason aside from 2k5, this game blows away every other football game ever by a mile. IMO it's better than 2k5 as well - others will disagree - but again, this poll is really just comparing two games

Actually, I disagree. I think 2k4 and 2k3 are also better than NCAA 07 for the 360.

[JayBee74]

Quote: Originally Posted by frago

Like I said its an improvement over last year but no way is it the best I ever played by a longshot.

Frago, which pigskin game is your favorite?

[ausar72]

Quote: Originally Posted by frago

XBOX 360 no. It is improved but far from the best imo. Players seem to be on top of the field.Shadows dont match on the players as the ground and it makes them not blend and look fake. Tacklers have Jet Packs and can zoom leap to catch someone. Too often the animations get in the way of the stick movement so that the player does not do what I want because he is in some animation. Change of direction seems flawed. No sharp cuts. Seems like too many plays are decided ahead of time. I get blown up on runs like I never had a chance sometimes and cant escape. The outside running game is bad. Counter runs are bad. Like I said its an improvement over last year but no way is it the best I ever played by a longshot.

So, in your opinion what's the best? Since you say it's not by a longshot. What game do you considered was THAT much better than this game?

You have to realize that this is based on all of the game that you have played to date, not some hypothetical game that is absolutely perfect (which will never happen by the way)

BTW, I chose Yes- for the 360 version. It simply combines the besy graphics and gameplay that I've played TO DATE.

[2krules]

I think how much you like a game depends on how much replay value you think the game has. The NFL 2K series from 2k3-2k5 had very high replay value for me. I was always wanting to play it for the entire first 2 months. It tapered off for me a little after that, but I actually still enjoy playing those games. NCAA 07 kept me very interested for the first 2 weeks, but now, I'm not that excited to be able to play it. For me, NCAA 07 is very frustrating, and that definitely kills a lot of the excitement. Also, the presentation is sorely lacking; I sure am getting tired of seeing the exact same cut scenes over and over and over again. The reason I am not selling the game on ebay is because of the minigames, expecially bowling. I love the minigames.

[The GIGGAS]

No - 360.

[CM1847]

Yes because it is the first sports game that I have ever played where I won the championship one year and went back with pretty much the same team and didn't even come close the following year. Every other sports game I get to the point where I am good enough and have a good enough team to win the championship and the game becomes boring.

There are gameplay issues of course, and recruiting could be better(xbox version), but the level of competition I am getting even with an A+ team makes it the best football game I have ever played. Probably the best sports game to come out in this generation.

[JayBee74]

I wasn't expecting such gaudy numbers in absolute favor of this game. Thanks for the input guys.

[Gmac1016]

360 version is dominant to the other versions.