Should I buy NCAA 08?

[jake44np]

Quote: Originally Posted by soce

LOL, nope, I graduated from there a while back.

Sorry to year that!

[jake44np]

I would pick it up if I was you!
The game is head and shoulders ahead of Madden IMO.
With playmakers slider set NCAA 08 plays a great game of college football.
When Madden first came out I quit playing NCAA 08 for about a week.
Now Madden gets no play at all from me, I cant express how much more I like NCAA over Madden this year!

[Mizzou23]

Get it. I love it. I even like the Campus Legend mode, and I don't normally even get into that stuff.

[VidGaminMachine476]

I agree.

This game is pretty fun. I haven't even ran into the INT / fumble issue.

Game plays so much better. It's worth $60 imho.

[Coach Bryant]

I enjoy it. I had to get it for the Bryant-Denny upgrade.

[dbshady]

Get it, Way better then Madden. Im just waiting for Alternate Uniforms. The game plays great, Running game is awsome, Madden was a disapointment for me... and I spent 100 bucks (360 and PC version). Thanks EA, Yeah, if Madden was like NCAA, I think I would have been awsome. Get NCAA, its worth it, Madden isn't. IMO.

[ODogg]

Quote: Originally Posted by dbshady

Get it, Way better then Madden. Im just waiting for Alternate Uniforms. The game plays great, Running game is awsome, Madden was a disapointment for me... and I spent 100 bucks (360 and PC version). Thanks EA, Yeah, if Madden was like NCAA, I think I would have been awsome. Get NCAA, its worth it, Madden isn't. IMO.

I have no idea why anyone would say NCAA is better than Madden unless you just love college football in general more than NFL. As most people on OS here know I've always loved NCAA better than Madden but this is the first year I think Madden is a better game overall, mostly because the touch passing works better in Madden and the frame stuttering (due to the game taking the pictures) is not in Madden.

[jake44np]

Quote: Originally Posted by ODogg

I have no idea why anyone would say NCAA is better than Madden unless you just love college football in general more than NFL. As most people on OS here know I've always loved NCAA better than Madden but this is the first year I think Madden is a better game overall, mostly because the touch passing works better in Madden and the frame stuttering (due to the game taking the pictures) is not in Madden.

To each his own I guess, but I really think Madden stinks compared to NCAA.
When I first got Madden after having NCAA for about a month I too thought Madden was better. But after playing Madden for a couple weeks now I cant get myself to play it anymore, NCAA 08 has been getting all of my playing time. Madden just doesnt play like a sim at all to me. The cpu throws way too many ints and the rbs fumble way too much. I have tried every set of sliders on the OS boards and none of them fix the turnover problems.
I have become very bored with Madden!