Which is better, NCAA or Madden?

[MidnightPyro]

Did they ever get progression sorted out? If not, then I have to give it to Madden...

[Radioactiveman]

asking which is better is like asking a death row inmate if he would rather be hanged or put in the gas chamber...neither are paticularly appealing...

[Solidice]

Quote: Originally Posted by MidnightPyro

Did they ever get progression sorted out? If not, then I have to give it to Madden...

the progression was changed in the last patch. players don't progress as much now.

[lahoward]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

NCAA has terrible physic! For people to cry about wanting a SIM game to say NCAA is better its crazy. Madden has holes ,but is way more organic than NCAA where player cut of pennies(not dimes) and speed is still the key on both sides of the ball. Sport games at the end comes down to on the field play and Madden is lightyear ahead in that department.

I agree dathrone. This is the 1st madden i've purchased in years that i didn't feel the need to get on the ea site & vent a bit. I don't know what they did but the game has such a realistic feel to it this year. I wouldn't have even bothered purchasing it but my cousin (who is very critical of any EA Sports title) said i had to get it this year. Glad i did.

[Sausage]

Probably already mentioned, but they are on two different playing fields. Madden is head, shoulders, and knees above NCAA in every aspect.

I play Madden (360) daily-several games an evening-I am also in the 5th year of an excellent Franchise with the Browns.

I play NCAA (PS3) occasionally because I need a reason to turn on my poor PS3.

Take care fellas.

[JAYMO76]

The thing that brings me back to NCAA is the diversity of the teams and the uniqueness of each season. Madden is 100x better but it doesn't have that lasting appeal after five or so seasons.