College Football Magazines (Top QB's)

[sportzbro]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bootzilla

I always look forward to this time of year when the college and pro annuals start to hit newsstands. I always look at the college mags to see if their ratings and EA's ratings are similar. I also get familiar with programs I'm not that familiar with in anticipation of playing NCAA football. Lindy's has the following as their top 25 QB's. 1. Kellen Moore- Boise St. 2. Ryan Mallett- Arkansas 3. Jake Locker- Washington 4. Case Keenum- Houston 5. Terrelle Pryor- Ohio St 6. Andrew Luck- Stanford 7. Jerrod Johnson- Texas A&M 8. Greg McElroy- Alabama 9. Josh Nesbitt- Ga.Tech 10. Christian Ponder- Fla.St. 11. Blaine Gabbert- Missouri 12. Andy Dalton- TCU 13. Colin Kaepernick- Nevada 14. Tyrod Taylor- Va. Tech 15. Landry Jones- Oklahoma 16. Russell Wilson- NC State 17. Robert Griffin- Baylor 18. Jacory Harris- Miami 19. Ricky Dobbs- Navy 20. Scott Tolzien- Wisconsin 21. Matt Barkley- USC 22. Ricky Stanzi- Iowa 23. Nick Foles- Arizona 24. Tom Savage- Rutgers 25. Zach Collaros- Cincinnati What do you guys think? Who should be added or eliminated? Who will be rated highest in NCAA?

LOL at Stanzi being on that list... and Pryor at #5? ...please Dude is so overrated and will be in the game as well.

[yanks26ngoin]

Quote: Originally Posted by BORN4CORN

LOL at Stanzi being on that list... and Pryor at #5? ...please Dude is so overrated and will be in the game as well.

Haha. Couldnt have said it better my self. Im not just saying this because I am a Michigan fan. Pryor is far and away the most overrated QB in college football. He has speed. Thats it. His passing ability is just plain terrible. And he pretty much single handedly lost the Purdue game for O$U.

As for Ricky Stanzi, I have to agree with you, why in the world is he on that list?

[cowboy_kmoney]

Robert GRiffen will rise above all on that list and will be the next best thing in the sport. I feel like last year was our year to be bowl bound, But its this year with a healthy Griffen we will own the Big 12...

[yanks26ngoin]

Quote: Originally Posted by cowboy_kmoney

Robert GRiffen will rise above all on that list and will be the next best thing in the sport. I feel like last year was our year to be bowl bound, But its this year with a healthy Griffen we will own the Big 12...

Alright, lets be real here. Its highly doubtful Baylor will own the Big 12 this year. Yes, Robert Griffen is good and yes, he will win games for you. But, come on. Step away from the kool-aid.

[Barkley7]

Kellen Moore SUCKS. Yup, you heard it. His stats are padded against little WAC cupcakes. The only 2 decent teams Boise played, Moore had trouble ( but did win the game ). Put any average QB with Boise's schedule and hype is guaranteed.
On the flip side, Keenum should be #1. Yes, the C-USA sucks.. but at least Keenum, with a less talented team unlike Moore, performed well in upsets over Tech and Ok.ST. Let's just hope he dosen't have that 6 pick day against AFU next year..

[Potatoes002]

Didn't they say they were spreading out the ratings and you wont see as many top players? If so, I only see about 6 or 7 90overalls on this list.

[TripleCrown9]

Quote: Originally Posted by o 99 PROBL3MS o

Here is how I think these QB's will/should be rated in NCAA 11. 1. Kellen Moore- Boise St. 93OVR 67SPD 92AWR 89THP 95THA 2. Ryan Mallett- Arkansas 95OVR 65SPD 82AWR 98THP 90THA 3. Jake Locker- Washington 95OVR 87SPD 84AWR 91THP 88THA 4. Case Keenum- Houston 92OVR 75SPD 80AWR 87THP 94THA 5. Terrelle Pryor- Ohio St 92OVR 90SPD 74AWR 89THP 86THA 6. Andrew Luck- Stanford 91OVR 68SPD 80AWR 90THP 87THA 7. Jerrod Johnson- Texas A&M 90OVR 87SPD 72AWR 88THP 84THA 8. Greg McElroy- Alabama 90OVR 74SPD 78AWR 89THP 87THA 9. Josh Nesbitt- Ga.Tech 90OVR 86SPD 80AWR 87THP 84THA 10. Christian Ponder- Fla.St. 91OVR 82SPD 74AWR 89THP 89THA 11. Blaine Gabbert- Missouri 89OVR 74SPD 64AWR 94THP 87THA 12. Andy Dalton- TCU 88OVR 76SPD 80AWR 88THP 87THA 13. Colin Kaepernick- Nevada 92OVR 84SPD 74AWR 89THP 88THA 14. Tyrod Taylor- Va. Tech 91OVR 90SPD 74AWR 89THP 86THA 15. Landry Jones- Oklahoma 87OVR 70SPD 64AWR 92THP 87THA 16. Russell Wilson- NC State 90OVR 84SPD 76AWR 88THP 89THA 17. Robert Griffin- Baylor 90OVR 92SPD 61AWR 86THP 86THA 18. Jacory Harris- Miami 88OVR 82SPD 72AWR 88THP 87THA 19. Ricky Dobbs- Navy 84OVR 84SPD 59AWR 82THP 82THA 20. Scott Tolzien- Wisconsin 85OVR 74SPD 59AWR 87THP 87THA 21. Matt Barkley- USC 86OVR 77SPD 59AWR 90THP 86THA 22. Ricky Stanzi- Iowa 89OVR 83SPD 68AWR 88THP 88THA 23. Nick Foles- Arizona 87OVR 82SPD 61AWR 88THP 86THA 24. Tom Savage- Rutgers 85OVR 72SPD 68AWR 88THP 84THA 25. Zach Collaros- Cincinnati 87OVR 85SPD 74AWR 86THP 85THA

Lol, Pryor and Taylor are not faster than Nesbitt. Griffin is the only one I can see beating Nesbitt in a footrace. And ease up on Moore's awareness. Holy crap. You haveLandry Jones and Blaine Gabbert too high overall-wise. Bump up Ponder's speed. And I'd even go out on a limb and say you have Andrew Luck rated to high. I don't see him getting out of the 80s. But then again, you probably did these without realizing that potential is important this year. That being said, all of your ratings are probably too high. Thanks for playing.

[cowboy_kmoney]

Hey everybody Athlonsports college football mag is out to.. with so much more in detail.