NCAA 10 isn't as bad as a lot of ppl here make it out to be..

[Buckeyes_Doc]

I rented NCAA 10 last September and just couldn't get into it. It's not that it was a terrible game, it was just Madden 10 was so much better. I thought NCAA 10 played way too fast for my taste, the football was a rocket. And with ZERO presentation I just felt like it was a washed down Madden.

I thought Madden 10 was great and I couldn't justify playing NCAA 10 over it. I'm so glad there is a speed slider for NCAA 11 as long with the presentation and dynasty improvements.

IMO Madden beat NCAA in gameplay particularly the speed of the game and in presentation by a long shot .

I enjoy playing the college game much more as I'm a bigger college fan then pro fan so I'm really excited to pick up NCAA 11 next month. The info I read is great and have faith NCAA 11 will be a great game as I'm itching for my college football video game fix.

Having a dynasty in NCAA and recruiting and building up a program is much more enjoyable then negotiating contracts.

[N51_rob]

I played a little of '10 this weekend as well. Wanted to practice with the 4-2-5 that TCU uses. The first thing that jumped out at me about playing NCAA 10 is the game speed. it was so much faster than Madden 10. I started to get the feel for it again. NCAA 10 is just a fun, game that does have flaws. But I had some good fun with it.

[Playmakers]

Quote: Originally Posted by N51_rob

I played a little of '10 this weekend as well. Wanted to practice with the 4-2-5 that TCU uses. The first thing that jumped out at me about playing NCAA 10 is the game speed. it was so much faster than Madden 10. I started to get the feel for it again. NCAA 10 is just a fun, game that does have flaws. But I had some good fun with it.

I actually had no problem between the two games......

I played Madden on fast speed option and it was basically a copy of NCAA game play speed.

It was the only way i could feel comfortable switching back and forth between the two games.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Playmakers

I actually had no problem between the two games...... I played Madden on fast speed option and it was basically a copy of NCAA game play speed. It was the only way i could feel comfortable switching back and forth between the two games.

So the complete lack of physics in NCAA isnt what set it apart from Madden?

[Teddy_Long]

odogg, i have no clue since i didn't buy ncaa 10 lol

[ODogg]

teddy - then ncaa 11 should be a huge upgrade for you from 09!

[rudyjuly2]

I don't think NCAA 10 was a terrible game but I don't think it was a good game either. I consider last year's football games to be the most disappointing set of games in five years. It was the first time in memory that I didn't have a new football game I enjoyed playing. I have high hopes for NCAA 11 though.

[ODogg]

wow, really? I thought NCAA 10 was pretty good and Madden 10 was great. In fact I think it's the best year ever for Madden in a long time. It was also the first time I actually liked Madden better than NCAA since they started both series.