Who should be the highest rated player by postion?

[dmhtfld]

Quote: Originally Posted by bosox15

Here's my attempt QB Jake Locker 96 Case Keenum 95 Ryan Mallett 94 Kellen Moore 94 Christian Ponder 93 Terrelle Pryor 92 Jacory Harris 92 Andy Dalton 91 Andrew Luck 91 Tyrod Taylor 90 Joshua Nesbitt 90 Greg McElroy 88 Ricky Stanzi 88 Colin Kapernick 88 Jerrod Johnson 88 Jordan Jefferson 87 Nick Foles 87 Tate Forcier 86 Nathan Enderle 86 Landry Jones 86 Robert Griffin 86 Zach Collaros 86 Matt Barkley 85 BJ Daniels 85 Russell Wilson 85 Garrett Gilbert 84 I only put Pryor and Harris so high because we all know they’re going to be overrated in the game.

even though i think pryor shoud be a 92 ovr i think EA will raise his rating higher than 2 points due to how well he did toward the end of last season

[CuseGirl]

Quote: Originally Posted by dmhtfld

even though i think pryor shoud be a 92 ovr i think EA will raise his rating higher than 2 points due to how well he did toward the end of last season

The fact that I see lists with Gilbert and Brantley, guys who haven't started yet, even NEAR the top 20, is ridiculous.

I'll admit it, I've been defending Pryor for the last 2 years and I'll keep doing it. I think 91 would be just right for him, he's a potential Heisman candidate and not because "he's popular", it's because he has game-changing talent, unlike Jake Locker, Jacory Harris, Ricky Stanzi (threw 5 picks against Indiana? please), Barkley (led the Pac-10 in picks). He's not perfect but tell that to the Oregon defense who couldn't tackle him when he converted key 3rd downs.

There really shouldnt be a QB rated over 93 anyway. The physical talent is there with some QBs (Mallet, Pryor, Locker), the leadership is there (McElroy, Taylor), some have the accuracy but none of them have the whole package, YET. We won't kno whose really at the top of the list until the bowl season starts.

[Tarheel]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bruce Wayne Jr

i'll throw out a few... qb: j. locker rb: m. ingram wr. j. jones or a. green de: r. quinn lb: ? db. p. peterson

Look out for Quinn!!!! He is ready to burst out in a big way this year.

[ndirish03]

rb: Deon Lewis, Mark Ingram, Ryan Williams

wr: Michael Floyd, Julio Jones

te: Kyle Rudolph

[ash00141]

Quote: Originally Posted by MWillard2

Taylor Potts might not be even starting for Texas Tech. Andrew Luck is better than 21 of those QB's. As a Michigan fan, Tate Forcier rating is laughable. He's will most likely be the 2nd Forcier to transfer out of Michigan. He played great against bad teams but against good teams was terrible and might not even start this year. Tyrod Taylor and Josh Nesbitt are terrible quarterbacks. Well Nesbitt is a terrible quarterback but in his system is a great quarterback. Colin Kapernick is a Top 7 Qb in College right now. I don't think any quarterback could run that system better than him. Jordan Jefferson is also a terrible quarterback. Spring game i think he only completed 4 passes of something like that. I watched it and wasn't impressed at all

Agree with the Kapernick, Luck, and Potts comments. Also, Garrett Gilbert could be better than half of these quarterbacks. He was a Gatorade Player of the Year i believe coming out of high school. He just hasn't played much yet, but watching him in the second half of the Alabama game you could see he had some serious tools to work with. Russell Wilson is also better than many of the quarterbacks ahead of him. Every time I watch him play, he is outstanding and excels in every facet of the game.

[RamblinWreck21]

Quote: Originally Posted by MWillard2

Taylor Potts might not be even starting for Texas Tech. Andrew Luck is better than 21 of those QB's. As a Michigan fan, Tate Forcier rating is laughable. He's will most likely be the 2nd Forcier to transfer out of Michigan. He played great against bad teams but against good teams was terrible and might not even start this year. Tyrod Taylor and Josh Nesbitt are terrible quarterbacks. Well Nesbitt is a terrible quarterback but in his system is a great quarterback. Colin Kapernick is a Top 7 Qb in College right now. I don't think any quarterback could run that system better than him. Jordan Jefferson is also a terrible quarterback. Spring game i think he only completed 4 passes of something like that. I watched it and wasn't impressed at all

Look I agree with you, as far as your normal drop back QB, Nesbitt is pretty bad, but he is fantastic at what he does, which is run the Triple Option. The real question is how do you rate this on this game? There's no doubt Nesbitt is one of the MVP for his team in the whole nation. Lose Nesbitt, GT goes from ACC Champs to like 5 wins. The kids got a good arm. He is very mobile, his awareness is very good for his offense, His accuracy sucks. All of that added in to this game still gives him a better rating then alot of pure QBs on the game. If Paul Johnson continues to succeed at the big time level, maybe NCAA should add a Triple Option QB template.

[mrMagic91]

QB: Kellen More (Pass efficiency was incredible)
RB: Mark Ingram
FB: Stanli Havili
WR: Julio/A.J/Michael Floyd
TE: D.J. Williams
DE: Von Miller (Texas A$M, 17 sacks in 2009, led nation)
DT: Adrian Clayborn
CB: Patrick Peterson
S: Rahim Moore (dont know much about him but 10 interceptions is good enough)

[MWillard2]

Here is my Top 5

QB
1. Ryan Mallett- Arkansas
2. Jake Locker- Washington
3. Case Keenum- Houston
4. Kellan Moore- Bosie State
5. Christian Ponder- Florida State

RB
1. Mark Ingram- Alabama
2. Ryan Williams- Virginia Tech
3. Kendall Hunter- Oklahoma State
4. Demarco Murray- Oklahoma
5. Jaquizz Rodgers- Oregon State

WR
1. A.J. Green- Georiga
2. Michael Floyd- Notre Dame
3. Jonathan Baldwin- Pittsburgh
4. Ryan Broyles- Oklahoma
5. Jeff Fuller- Texas A&M

TE
1. Kyle Rudolph- Notre Dame
2. D.J. Williams- Arkansas
3. Weslye Saunders- South Carolina
4. Jeffery Anderson- UAB
5. Lance Kendricks- Wisconsin

OT
1. Anthony Castonzo- Boston College
2. Gabe Carimi- Wisconsin
3. Jason Pinkston- Pittsburgh
4. Lee Ziembia- Auburn
5. Clint Bowling- Georgia

OG
1. Rodney Hudson- Florida State
2. Justin Boren- Ohio State
3. Stephen Schilling- Michgan
4. Stefen Wisniewski- Penn State
5. Ryan Miller- Colorado

C
1. Kristofer O'Dowd- USC
2. Tim Barnes- Missouri
3. Mike Pouncey- Florida
4. Colin Baxter- Arizona
5. Ben Lamaak- Iowa State

DE
1. Robet Quinn- North Carolina
2. Adrian Clayborn- Iowa
3. Allen Bailey- Miami(FL)
4. Cameron Heyward- Ohio State
5. Marcell Darues- Alabama

DT
1. Jared Crick- Nebraska
2. Jurrell Casey- USC
3. Marvin Austin- North Carolina
4. Stephen Pea- Oregon State
5. Jarvis Jenkins- Clemson

OLB
1. Von Miller- Texas A&M
2. Bruce Carter- North Carolina
3. Travis Lewis- Oklahoma
4. Nigel Bradham- Florida State
5. Akeem Ayers- UCLA

MLB
1. Quan Sturdivant- North Carolina
2. Greg Jones- Michigan State
3. Vontaze Burfict- Arizona State
4. Alex Wujciak- Maryland
5. Manti Te'O- Notre Dame

CB
1. Patrick Peterson- LSU
2. Kedric Burney- North Carolina
3. Aaron Williams- Texas
4. Ras-I Dowling- Virginia
5. Brandon Harris- Miami(FL)

FS
1. Rahim Moore- UCLA
2. Deunta Williams- North Carolina
3. Jermale Hines- Ohio State
4. Jaiquwan Jarrett- Temple
5. Blake Gideon- Texas

SS
1. DeAndre McDaniel- Clemson
2. Ahmad Black- Florida
3. Davonte Shannon- Buffalo
4. Mark Barnes- Alabama
5. Jeron Johnson- Bosie State