NCAA or Madden

[ADTheBrute]

I buy 2 games every year no matter what

NCAA

Madden

While they both are usually flawed they are diffrent and I enjoy what each offers

[Skyboxer]

Quote: Originally Posted by Scur2D2

all the things you mentioned are such minor annoynces.. and not the huge game killers that you portray them to be. This year's Madden has done nothing in terms of making the gameplay better. Crowds leaving? Thats really your reason for buying a game?

No kidding.... Plus if NCAA11 has already gotten stale then I have no idea what FB game they've EVER played that kept their interest up long.

[hampshire2012]

Thanks for the feedback, definitely food for thought! Probably a stupid question, but can you increase your schools rating over time by getting good results etc?

[rudyjuly2]

Quote: Originally Posted by hampshire2012

Thanks for the feedback, definitely food for thought! Probably a stupid question, but can you increase your schools rating over time by getting good results etc?

Yes.

And I think most people will agree that NCAA dynasty mode is a lot better than Madden's franchise. If you like the NFL better you may stick with Madden but the dynasty mode in NCAA is simply the best mode of any sports game out there imo. It's far more addicting than Madden plus the season is quite a bit shorter (easier to go through each year quickly). Recruiting every week makes it fun.

[elliottcarbone]

No kidding.... Plus if NCAA11 has already gotten stale then I have no idea what FB game they've EVER played that kept their interest up long.

Madden 2010 held my attention pretty long considering the presentation is much better along with the gameplay. I am just a presentation/graphics guy and although the gameplay is just as important NCAA get annoying quick. Madden does not........Trust me Madden 11 will look and feel like a real football game. No more stale commentary and horrible fill ins that resemble something a college kid would design in a beginning animations class.

[elliottcarbone]

And yes these are all minor problems but sometimes minor problems take away from the overall beauty of the game...

[Segagendude]

Quote: Originally Posted by ODogg

elliottcarbone - NCAA does have crowds leaving early when there is a blowout. I should know, I'm Ohio State and just had two blowouts and probably a quarter of the seats were filled by the 4th quarter.

Was just gonna post this as well. I was Ohio State, and was winning 45-7 over Marshall. During the 4th qrtr, as the camera zoomed out over The Shoe, I saw many empty seats.

[ODogg]

I take it yours was in a dynasty Segagendude? I just wonder if it works ok there but for some reason doesn't work in exhibition...