Why is NCAA better than Madden?

[ODogg]

I think a big part of it for me is what Senator Palmer said, the playbooks are just so much more deep and varied in NCAA 11 than Madden 11.

[Bucknut17]

For me its the college offensive variety, the NFL feels like the same team just different uniforms most the time, but ncaa u can use Oregon and spread option a team to death, or use ttu and throw the ball 50 times, or use Iowa or Wisconsin and punch ur opponent in the mouth with a power rushing attack...this is what makes ncaa great and why I prefer it

[dickey1331]

Quote: Originally Posted by reyes the roof

I prefer the NCAA Dynasty over Madden franchise, you get a completely new team every five seasons so it never gets stale for me

I agree. Plus I enjoy the college season more then the NFL

[Buffalo Gold]

NCAA has the ability to draw me in more so than Madden. The wins and losses feel more monumental in NCAA, because there of course is more of a gap in ratings from team to team and player to player.

IMO,the recruiting process is more rewarding than being able to "buy" your players.

OH and Upsets! upsets! upsets! In Madden not so much...

[bh446066]

I prefer to watch college football, therefore, I prefer to play NCAA. I think they are basically the same game. I do get frustrated that there are too many teams in NCAA that provide NO chellenge what-so-ever, beating the cr@p out of teams provides me zero entertainment.

[TheCreep]

Quote: Originally Posted by Carolus Rex

How is the gameplay better?

If you notice, most of the answers refer to things like more playbooks, more teams, with the occasional vague it plays more fluid/realistic, etc.

Dude, if you're thinking about getting one or the other as far as gameplay is concerned you cant go wrong with either. Its the same central gameplay team that works on both games man.

Its the same game period. You want more teams and playbooks get NCAA. Personally, I dont see why the two are compared. Its football. You're a fan of football you'll pretty much watch any game you can feast your eyes on feel me? That goes for football games too, you'll play em all pretty much.

On top of that, the games are meant to go together, hence the ability to draft players from NCAA to Madden. I know I know its broken right lol. Cant have one without the other, you're detracting from the whole experience.

[TheCreep]

Quote: Originally Posted by bh446066

I prefer to watch college football, therefore, I prefer to play NCAA. I think they are basically the same game. I do get frustrated that there are too many teams in NCAA that provide NO chellenge what-so-ever, beating the cr@p out of teams provides me zero entertainment.

Basically the same game? Exactly.

[Carolus Rex]

How is the pass rush in NCAA? That is the main/only problem that bothers me in Madden. I can get pressure on the QB but he allways gets the passa away in the last second. There seems to be no reason to blitz in Madden since that will leave a hole in the defence and the QB will still allways get a pass off. Is it possible to get a sack in NCAA?