NCAA 12 or Madden 12 for coach mode?

[DirtyJerz32]

Mods, I put this in the football other forum, but only got one reply. Hope you don't mind I put it here and the Madden forum. If so you can move it.

Just wanted to get everyone's opinion here. I'm looking to not get pissed off anymore, but still play.

Any thoughts?

What's the pros & cons of each?

[DirtyJerz32]

I find it hard to believe that nobody plays this game on coach mode. Come on guys, little help!

[w00dy Hayezz]

I LOVE coach mode!!! I am in 2 coach mode dynasties in NCAA and it's much better than Madden IMO. The ONLY thing i don't like is that you can't play user games on coach mode, maybe next year.

[DirtyJerz32]

Thanks for the help. I started a NCAA dynasty last night with my Teambuilder highschool teams and I agree, it's so much better than Madden.

[w00dy Hayezz]

It's hard to keep people involved in a coach mode dynasty but the ones that stick with it really seem to like it. It's a blast to build up smaller schools into good programs.

[DJ]

Yeah, Coach Mode in NCAA is superior to Madden. I'm waiting for Purple to finish his custom roster on the PS3 before I start my Dynasty.

[Gotmadskillzson]

Yeah......the fact the user QB don't scramble in Madden 12 coach mode just turned me off of Madden 12. Looks pretty but I couldn't stomach my QB getting sacked over and over again.

Where as with NCAA 12, I play coach mode all the time. More about the Xs and Os. It is like a game of chess.

Plus I just get a thrill and rush of knowing that I have 50/50 chance of succeeding or failing with the play I just called.

[w00dy Hayezz]

If anyone wants to do a coach mode OD let me know!