How does NCAA compare to Madden?

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Big FN Deal

Here is an IGN video I found discussing this exact topic. http://www.ign.com/videos/2012/04/13...-ncaa-football

Eh, I shut that video off half-way through. I remember from last year and last year I would agreed with him, but that was when he was ripping on Collingsworth and Johnson, much better with Simms and Nantz at the helm and a different take on the video for me. Plus, he showed the boxing match with Finnegan and we all know the NFL wouldn't allow that.

[Armor and Sword]

Still enjoy NCAA 13 a ton. I have not played in a few months but have a great Hurricane dynasty going.

I found it far better than any Madden this gen...by a wide margin.

[Black4track]

I was Pro Madden back in the PSX/PS2 Days. Then Back on PS2, a friend introduced me to NCAA. The rest was history. Havent bought a Madden game since.

The current Generation of Football games is mediocre at best. Why is that? I'l save that for another thread.

[jhc0011]

You guys are nuts thinking NCAA is better than Madden 13. Literally the only thing NCAA has on Madden is a better HUNH system. Every single other aspect is either inferior to Madden or a matter of preference.

I played NCAA for about a week before returning that trash to the retail store from whence it came. Still play Madden though.

[Armor and Sword]

Quote: Originally Posted by jhc0011

You guys are nuts thinking NCAA is better than Madden 13. Literally the only thing NCAA has on Madden is a better HUNH system. Every single other aspect is either inferior to Madden or a matter of preference. I played NCAA for about a week before returning that trash to the retail store from whence it came. Still play Madden though.

That's your opinion. A lot of us think Madden is a sloppy hot mess.

It's all subjective. Video games are like music. Different strokes for different folks.

[jello1717]

Quote: Originally Posted by jhc0011

You guys are nuts thinking NCAA is better than Madden 13. Literally the only thing NCAA has on Madden is a better HUNH system. Every single other aspect is either inferior to Madden or a matter of preference. I played NCAA for about a week before returning that trash to the retail store from whence it came. Still play Madden though.

this thread has been so strange. A bunch of guys on an NCAA board like that game best. Weird, right?

I'm sure this question wouldn't get the opposite response on the Madden boards either.