Who will be the top players at there position?

[Headtrip325]

Quote: Originally Posted by Swamp Swagger

Again true freshmen so how can you say Bridgewater bar none would smoke anything JM does when he gets to the NFL?

I don't know why this bugs me so much but does no one realize JM wasn't a true freshman he redshirted in 2011... to move on I still think he will be rated the as the highest QB.

[Swamp Swagger]

Quote: Originally Posted by Headtrip325

I don't know why this bugs me so much but does no one realize JM wasn't a true freshman he redshirted in 2011... to move on I still think he will be rated the as the highest QB.

Freshmen anything to do that was outstanding.

[BtothejizA]

Quote: Originally Posted by Swamp Swagger

Freshmen anything to do that was outstanding.

Very true. It is hard enough to be a first year starter. To be a first year starter as a Frosh or RS Fr is almost certain failure.

[Madwolf]

Quote: Originally Posted by Swamp Swagger

Freshmen anything to do that was outstanding.

It's impressive, but if you switch him and Teddy places last year Teddy gets the Heisman. JM is a really good college guy, and was great as a freshman, just like Teddy was.

I feel like Teddy is the better QB because the 95% of the time when he improvised with his feet, it's all to get in a better position to make a throw downfield, not run for a few yards. I've never seen a college QB keep his eyes down field while he scrambles around like Teddy, its just unreal to watch.

I didn't get to watch a lot of JM, but from what I saw Teddy is still the more polished passer, and I feel like that should make him the better QB at any level.

[RCopenhagen]

QB:
1) Johnny Manziel (Texas A&M)
2) AJ McCarron (Alabama)
3) Teddy Bridgewater (Louisville)
4) Tahj Boyd (Clemson)
5) Braxton Miller (Ohio State)

RB:
1) TJ Yeldon (Alabama)
2) Todd Gurley (Georgia)
3) De'Anthony Thomas (Oregon)
4) Silas Redd (USC)
5) Ka'Deem Carey (Arizona)

WR:
1) Sammy Watkins (Clemson)
2) Amari Cooper (Alabama)
3) Marqise Lee (USC)
4) Brandon Coleman (Rutgers)
5) Jordan Matthews (Vanderbilt)

TE:
1) Austin Seferian (Washington)
2) CJ Fiedorowicz (Iowa)
3) Jacob Pedersen (Wisconsin)
4) Colt Lyerla (Oregon)
5) Arthur Lynch (Georgia)

DE:
1) Jadeveon Clowney (South Carolina)
2) Stephon Tuitt (Notre Dame)
3) Aaron Lynch (South Florida)
4) Adrian Hubbard (Alabama)
5) Jackson Jeffcoat (Texas)

DT:
1) Louis Nix (Notre Dame)
2) Anthony Johnson (LSU)
3) Will Sutton (Arizona State)
4) Daniel McCullers (Tennessee)
5) Timmy Jernigan (Florida State)

OLB:
1) Ryan Shazier (Ohio State)
2) Anthony Barr (UCLA)
3) Kyle Van Noy (BYU)
4) Christian Jones (Florida State)
5) Denicos Allen (Michigan State)

MLB:
1) CJ Mosley (Alabama)
2) AJ Johnson (Tennessee)
3) Andrew Jackson (Western Kentucky)
4) Max Bullough (Michigan State)
5) Shayne Skov (Stanford)

CB:
1) Louchiez Purifoy (Florida)
2) Bradley Roby (Ohio State)
3) Aaron Colvin (Oklahoma)
4) Justin Gilbert (Oklahoma State)
5) Deshazor Everett (Texas A&M)

SS:
1) Ha'Sean Clinton-Dix (Alabama)
2) Craig Loston (LSU)
3) Ty Zimmerman (Kansas State)
4) Hakeem Smith (Louisville)
5) Ahmad Dixon (Baylor)

FS:
1) Lamarcus Joyner (Florida State)
2) CJ Barnett (Ohio State)
3) Nickoe Whitley (Mississippi State)
4) Corey Moore (Georgia)
5) Vinnie Sunseri (Alabama)

[USNAggie44]

I think johnny should be rated.higher, he does the scrambling and looks downfield like bridgewater but he is also a great runner. He also played Bama, LSU, and Florida. And why does him not translating to the NFL have anything to do with this, he's in college now and this is a college game

[cparrish]

Quote: Originally Posted by USNAggie44

he does the scrambling and looks downfield

How are you going to put that into ratings?

[Sundown2600]

Quote: Originally Posted by TreyDobbs

NCAA should be like Madden where only a few players in the entire game have over 90.

This should apply to all of the skills and attributes as well. It's why ppl spend countless hours tweaking ratings because that's the only way to get a bit of separation between good and great players.