I think we all have different opinions of how teams in general should be rated and what ratings mean. To me, a 99 Offense should mean literally "the greatest college offense of all time". But that's what I think, maybe someone else thinks 99 is just for the best offense in a given year. As far as Bama specifically goes, I'm a UGA fan so I can attest to their offense being very underrated because everyone thinks of the defense when they think of Bama. Bama's offense is one of, if not the most efficient in the NCAA. They run the ball at will on just about everyone. I do have a problem with the 97 rating for AJ McCarron, but I do think he's a good QB, just not that good. Overall, I feel like they usually give Bama players a +5 overall bump because of the jersey they put on.