Best Release of NCAA Football for PS3???

[canesfins]

All I know is NCAA 13 was terrible. NCAA 12 not that much better. 14 is the clear winner for me.

[buickbeast]

Would have been very interesting if last gen games were included in poll.

[TomSNC]

Eh 14 is clearly the best but the glitches like the infuriating rewind a play/game lag glitch makes it hard sometimes to enjoy but overall 14 is the best.

[mattynokes]

I haven't played NCAA '14 yet, but here's my thoughts on each game that I've played:

NCAA '10: Hard to really say how good it was since it was my first experience on this gen. I remember playing it a decent amount and using teambuilder schools almost elusively. Overall I don't remember it being that bad.

NCAA '11: I played a lot of this game and don't remember a lot of the glitches that have plagued recent versions.

NCAA '12: Initially I thought this game had a lot of bugs/glitches and didn't put up enough of a challenge, but a few house rules and SECElite's Heisman sliders and I wound up playing about 10 seasons of a dynasty.

NCAA '13: Terrible. DB Glitch. Option still broken. Sliders seemed broken. Just terrible. First time I've ever traded in NCAA early.

Personally, I still have '12, but if I decide to pass on NCAA '14 I think I'd go back to '11 first and see how it stacks up compared to '12.

[football200414]

Quote: Originally Posted by buickbeast

Would have been very interesting if last gen games were included in poll.

Previous gen games would have dominated the poll...I honestly can't remember which game it was on PS2 that I had last but it was far more enjoyable

[kingkilla56]

I liked 11 the best. 14 has a ton of issues for me.

[OReilly10]

I skipped 2013.

I would say 2014 easily. I play primarily in the Offline Dynasty mode. I feel they have improved that mode a great deal, especially with the point-system for recruits.
I also have to say the Option variety and execution is better than any previous version I remember.
Playing games on Heisman level out of the box, my games come out realistic and balanced (using 7 minute quarters).

I think the pregame and post game presentations have taken a step back... Also there are some bugs. Not game-breaking, but if they dont fix them, it could potentially knock this game down a peg.

[Earl1963]

NCAA14 is by far the best IMO.