I'm glad to know this is not just a problem with me and my ability, though I'm certainly not a great player. I've had far too many instances of being in a great position (sometimes as good as standing directly in front of a WR waiting for a long bomb that was throw a little short) when I've hit, and I've tried tapping and holding, the triangle button. A majority of the time my CB/S won't make a play on the ball at all - much less intercept it. He'll just stand there watching it sail overhead. However, I was able to complete the NIKE training easily, as I was curious if it was the game or me, but it doesn't seem to work well for me in regular games.
In full disclosure I've had a few times when I've been able to get USER INT's but they are few and far between it seems. Maybe it is a timing or distance thing, where you have to be a certain distance and/or hit the button at a certain point? Also my INT slider is on 30.
I don't want all interceptions but defenders certainly should not just stand there or run with the receiver and not put a hand up. It's got to be a bugged ball-hawking issue (really love that feature btw
). I don't catch for the WR very often but I have on occasion and usually don't have a problem with the button then - but that sample size is far smaller than the many times I've had to make a play defensively to make up for the AI.
On that note - have any of you tried using the swat button instead of going for the pick? I haven't consciously tried it as far as I remember. If you have is it better?