Which NCAA Football game is the best??

[Cardot]

I tended to get the game on even years....so I had '10 and '12. I know people talk highly of '11.....what was great in that edition that they screwed up in '12?

[Bjetw]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cardot

I tended to get the game on even years....so I had '10 and '12. I know people talk highly of '11.....what was great in that edition that they screwed up in '12?

11 seems so much more balanced. Penalties called !!! For one.not sure but something about Tim Tebow on the cover makes it all better. 11 has locomotion and 12 implements a modified engine to the system.

[Collegefbfan]

NCAA 12 was the first game I got on ps3. I liked it at first. I thought I sucked really bad at QB because the LBs were super human and could jump 6 feet up and snag all passes. I have 14. I ordered 11 to kind of preserve 14. I will say 11 is more balanced. You can't do the create and totally create conferences. You can switch teams but not just add them on. I know 11 doesn't have custom playbooks. But gameplay is better.

[DJ]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bjetw

11 seems so much more balanced. Penalties called !!! For one.not sure but something about Tim Tebow on the cover makes it all better. 11 has locomotion and 12 implements a modified engine to the system.

With some slider adjustments, the defense in 11 is tough (which I like!). DL are very active and you'll see a couple of passes batted down at the line of scrimmage.