I was just thinking of making a thread like this:
Troy Hensley, RB, MSU: (2003) I recruited him sometime in about 2006 or so with 95 speed, 80+ break tackle, and 90+ agility. His first run against some crappy school went for a 60+ yard TD run, and after that I knew he would be special. Had 2000+ yards as a Junior and 5000+ over his career. Sadly, I was tired of Madden so never got to play with him.
LeVon Vance, Lefty QB, Oregon State: (2004) Recruited LeVon in year 3 of my Oregon State dynasty. Came in with a 4.46 40, A+ arm strengh, B+ accuracy and good agility as well. Was an 86 speed in the game by the time he left as a Junior. In my first game with him, on the first throw, it was a completion, but he got injured for 6 weeks, so that kind of sucked. However, he came back and tore it up his Sophomore year both Passing and rushing with TDs up the wazoo and ended up in the Top 5 for Heisman. In his Junior year he won the Heisman and bolted for Madden without even listening to my pleas. Unfortunely, he was the biggest bust I have ever had in Madden. I took him in teh 1st round because my team needed a QB. Came in and threw picks left and right and never amounted to a thing in the NFL and I cut him after year 4.