Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

[JayD]

As most of us know, the simulation in FIFA is broken and hasn't been fixed for a few years now. I assume it is the exact same in 19 as I've seen some odd results in videos from other game changers. This is why you see so many odd tables and results.

Below is a video as to why it is broken.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuiyZvV9D1I

Thoughts?

[TripleJay_X]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

oh damn, i'm playing fifa so long and i never was aware of this kind of mod lol

looks like a good mod. my league tables always end like this -> i'm (mostly) first, the team with the top-scorer, top-assists, most goals shot and lowest goals against.
if you play an own tournament like a super-league with all best teams, the top-players of the week are always from the same country your club is playing. pretty funny bug since fifa14 or 15 i believe lol

[Kumode]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

Do you have any actual proof (as in simsettings.ini file) that states that these things are untouched? I'm getting quite realistic results in my Serie A CM.

[TripleJay_X]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

FIFA 18? 100% unrealistic. Just go the calender and sim to the end of season and watch scores of other leagues and then compare them with the league tables of the real leagues.
I tried with the CareerMode Patch from soccergaming on fifa18...it's a lot better. Juve shoots 90 goals, PSG almost 100, Barca/Real about 80/90 goals. Without mod it's about 50% (!) less goals.

FIFA 19? Give it a try and post some screens

[TheAwesomeGem]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

Thanks for sharing the findings for the broken match simulation issue that I made early this year. When the modding tools becomes available, I will do the same on FIFA 19. Sadly it will only work in PC.

Also the patch I have released for FIFA 18 http://soccergaming.com/index.php?th...y-mod.6464124/ fixes the match simulation issue as well as a lot of other issues in the career mode.

[TripleJay_X]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

It's hard to play vanilla fifa-gameplay if you know how good fifa CAN be with all the mods by the community. I have more 'fun' aka interest to play FIFA with my modded FIFA18-CM than FIFA'19 could ever be@default.



i use Career-Mode Patch for realistic results (&more), Fidel's AGPE AI Simulation ULTRA SIM Aggressive and the Remove-AI-Scripting Mod from someone on soccergaming aswell. So, whoever is sick of this arcade-scripted-sh*t from EA....

[TripleJay_X]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

So, after all these patches, did something change in terms of 'Authentic League Tables' ?!


... or are Barca & Co. still shooting 50-60 Goals in a Season

[JayD]

Re: Explanation on why FIFA simulation is broken

So, after all these patches, did something change in terms of 'Authentic League Tables' ?!


... or are Barca & Co. still shooting 50-60 Goals in a Season

No. Tables still very unrealistic