No slider brings back ai defending.
If you don't mind how it plays and only stats are your major concern, you can probably put shot error at 100 and get players who can't shoot, so fewer goals. And if you put pass error at 100 you'll get players who can't figure out how to kick a football, so more attacks breaking down for no good reason, but you'll never get actual team defending which is what is missing.
In short, you can maybe make the players on the ball just as useless as the players defending and that's it.
You may also have to play the game yourself blindfolded or by pushing buttons with your feet to achieve the same with the player you're controlling. Some would say, just use "manual passing", serves the same purpose. So now you know why there's a 100% chance you'll get this suggestion.
Just generally miskick the ball on purpose as often as you can, as a substitute for the lack of defending and pretend it's soccer/football, even though it's basically basketball.