How is the game play in NHL Legacy

[jack72]

After purchasing NHL 16 for xbox1, I am very disappointed in the way the game feels and plays.-m

- It is almost impossible to hit,
- The AI will take 70 shots a game at you ( and I have tried adjusting sliders and tried some on the forum),
- Skating between the AI and Human players are not even in the same world....cpu can turn on a dime while human momentum continues making it difficult to control.

Having said that, I was wondering if the Legacy game is any better.
I had NHL 15 Legacy, and felt that that was great.


So if you have the Legacy game, how is it playing for you...the same as the NHL 15 Legacy, or is it very different?

[tinpanalley]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Having said that, I was wondering if the Legacy game is any better.
I had NHL 15 Legacy, and felt that that was great.
So if you have the Legacy game, how is it playing for you...the same as the NHL 15 Legacy, or is it very different?

First of all NHL 15 was NHL 15. There was no 'legacy'. Second, this is a heavily personal opinion weighted question but I think NHL Legacy is fantastic. Would I like the 3-on-3 OT? Sure, but it's not going to ruin my game. I need the current schedule and a handful of newly made players. That matters to me. The game is as great as it was last year to me and perhaps plays a bit better but I have no quantifiable way of checking that because I haven't read anything that says they did anything to Legacy.

As far as the nextgen version goes, I've seen lots and played it and honestly, there is something in sports games when they go to new generations that never ceases to amaze me; the overdone graphical elements in place of finished games. Almost to remind you by beating you over the head that the game looks better because of a better GPU but almost as well to distract you from the fact that the game's launched unfinished. Look, if you like the latest in graphics (and even that is questionable) then next gen matters to you.

When I play hockey, baseball, soccer games, I'm watching the ball and my teammates. So if there's a guy walking up the aisle holding a realistic bag of popcorn or if the stadium mascot runs onto the ice at the end of the game couldn't possibly be less relevant to me. You know why I still play MVP NCAA Baseball? Because the physics and the gameplay are so tight it doesn't matter that it has PS2 graphics.

Anyway, just some thoughts.

[jack72]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

I agree with most of what you say, I don't stop to admire the crowd while rushing down the ice.


I like xbox360 version as I can put in my own BIP music which added to the atmosphere more than seeing the beads of water on the drink cups.


Seeing as the AI in xbox1 is virtually unplayable, I am going to get the legacy game instead and add the xbox 1 cd to my drink coaster collection.

[nhlhockeyguy]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

NHL legacy edition is a solid game. While legacy isn't as dramatic of a step up as NHL 15 old gen was from 14, there's still a lot of good tweaks and small additions and fixes to make it a great hockey game overall.

[Roscosuper]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Legacy is a cleaned up version of '15 as far as gameplay is concerned. The AI is a bit more challenging and has a few more plays.


It's definitely better than new gen (gameplay wise).


I'd have to go back and play some of the older hockey games, but it could be in the argument for best hockey game of all time.


IMO, if you took the Legacy gameplay/mechanics/etc. and combined it with current gen graphics, you'd have a clear winner.

[nhlhockeyguy]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Most people believe that it is "literally the same game as 14" since that is all they hear from people who haven't actually played 15 or legacy. The reason I've come to that conclusion is because the improvements between 14 and 15 are so glaringly obvious that it's impossible to miss if you have actually played both games. Previous games in the series have not gotten as many improvements as 15 old gen got. Legacy is a little more subtle with the improvements, but they fixed some of the things I personally had a problem with in 15 last gen, although the list is pretty small as I considered 15 old gen to be the best hockey game available. I think the problem is people see 15 new gen and expect ea to automagically port those graphics to old gen, otherwise "LITERALLY the same game".

[pezdaddy]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

sorry, i'm not going to pay full game price for Legacy when it just has some minor additions/fixes/jerseys that weren't in NHL15

I'm still playing '15, and with some great sliders (I definitely recommend AlTito's sliders in the Legacy/Sliders thread) makes the games very entertaining and close to realistic as you'll get

I used the "Generic EA DB Reader" app along with Horizon and the NHL DB Patcher, I was able to modify a season save from '15 to get this year's schedule implemented. Definitely a chore but my importing the schedule into a spreadsheet helped out a little bit


IMO, if you took the Legacy gameplay/mechanics/etc. and combined it with current gen graphics, you'd have a clear winner.

[Roscosuper]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

sorry, i'm not going to pay full game price for Legacy when it just has some minor additions/fixes/jerseys that weren't in NHL15

I'm still playing '15, and with some great sliders (I definitely recommend AlTito's sliders in the Legacy/Sliders thread) makes the games very entertaining and close to realistic as you'll get

I used the "Generic EA DB Reader" app along with Horizon and the NHL DB Patcher, I was able to modify a season save from '15 to get this year's schedule implemented. Definitely a chore but my importing the schedule into a spreadsheet helped out a little bit


IMO, if you took the Legacy gameplay/mechanics/etc. and combined it with current gen graphics, you'd have a clear winner.

I totally get not wanting to spend the money. EA really doesn't deserve it. But if we're analyzing the games without considering the wickedness of EA Sports' business practices, and just the game itself, than Legacy is the better game.


The price may drop. If it does; you should give more consideration.


What's more? There are more and better generic faces. If Artem updates his editor, this will give us so much/many better choices for assigning faces to players.


If new-gen continues down the same path, I may be keeping my beagm (when I start it, that is) going for a time with Legacy.

[EAKHL]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Hey folks,

[EAKHL]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Thought I might sign in and offer up some opinions on NHL Legacy. I've played them all from the beginning and this is the game you want. If you want a challenge from the AI follow this link and you will see our custom sliders and FULL game posted on you tube with comments from me about the improvements over last years game.

[EAKHL]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

You can download our custom slider settings in the description section. Print em off and try them out. Please feel free to return to my channel and post your findings. Enjoy!

[EAKHL]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unD_PahJJ1E

[EAKHL]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Sorry about the spam-like posts. I couldn't post a link as a new user so I just posted 5 times ~ Later.

[MrMars]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

I had NHL 15 and I am currently playing Legacy for the PS3. I must say the gameplay on Legacy is far better, in my opinion than 15. Also, it appears to be better now then when it first released, as they seem to have addressed the lack of penalty issue that has plagued the game for many years.

I played a game recently in my BeaGM where the Winnipeg Jets took 9 penalties including a 5 minute major with a game misconduct. Certainly adds another layer to the strategy when you're playing. And over the last 5 or 6 games there have been enough penalties within the flow of the game to make it much more fun.

Honestly, I was going to make the jump to the PS4 on this year's sports game crop. But, it appears that the dev's need one more cycle to get the gameplay on par with the graphics on the games i like to play with the new hardware (Well, new to me.) With that being said, this year's crop of games (NBA 2k16, NHL Legacy, Madden 16) are the best they have ever been on this platform which allows me to wait until Sep or Oct to make the jump.

Just my 2 cents

Peace,

MrMars

[EAKHL]

Re: How is the game play in NHL Legacy

Yup, don't bother. I got a PS4 and NHL 16 just for hockey and it was a HUGE mistake. NHL 16 is a POS when it comes to game play (which is really all that matters).

NHL legacy is best.... it's not even close.