My thoughts exactly.
Offline I can typically be competitive against the CPU and my win / loss ratio is about 50% on All Star. I play with the True Broadcast camera which adds to the difficulty (as shooting and stick handling is trickier) but I just like it more visually.
I dislike how EA have allowed seasoned online users to appropriate the puck with tricks and strategies which are neither realistic not physically possible. I can understand if I am pressured into a corner and my guys looses the puck, but how is it that the puck always (and I mean always) morphs with their stick, instead of it getting knocked loose so to give me a chance to fight for it. I know I've lost the battle as soon as I see the other guy charging towards me. I try to change direction, stick handle, protect the puck, move out of that area, but nothing helps.