The judging is still garbage

[MacGowan]

It's hard to read the stats and know how that fight really went down. If the W went to someone who had faaaar less significant strikes for all 5 rounds, then I could say something is broken. But I could also pull up numerous real life fights where decisions have been appalling.

I kinda like the way it is now (although I don't know the actual coding mechanics behind it.) You leave it up to the judges there's always a change you'll get screwed. I would like EA to still have that "random" aspect of it. A judge might be having a off night, or something.


And while I'm here. please, at least make a "Draws on/off" setting in advanced settings. I'm begging yeh.

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by MacGowan

It's hard to read the stats and know how that fight really went down. If the W went to someone who had faaaar less significant strikes for all 5 rounds, then I could say something is broken. But I could also pull up numerous real life fights where decisions have been appalling. I kinda like the way it is now (although I don't know the actual coding mechanics behind it.) You leave it up to the judges there's always a change you'll get screwed. I would like EA to still have that "random" aspect of it. A judge might be having a off night, or something. And while I'm here. please, at least make a "Draws on/off" setting in advanced settings. I'm begging yeh.

Thats not how judging works in UFC 3. Its based off of the new real life judging criteria which holds "impact/damage" as the highest criteria. So you could outs strike me by 40 Sig strikes in a round but if I knock you down twice and cut your face...im likely winning the round.

[MacGowan]

haha! Fair enough. I was actually saying that the stats can often lie, and even my counter example turned out to be false 😂.

Point being; I'm okay with the EA scoring system.

[Dankoz]

Judging is really carbage. Leg kicks > Everything else. Only issue i see in the game at the moment.

[LarsP]

How do you guys get fights to decisions in this game? Literally al but one of my fights ended with a finish. It's either me getting finished or my opponents getting reckless and counter KO'd.

[Trillz]

Quote: Originally Posted by LarsP

How do you guys get fights to decisions in this game? Literally al but one of my fights ended with a finish. It's either me getting finished or my opponents getting reckless and counter KO'd.

you get alot of decisions in high level fights.

[aholbert32]

Quote: Originally Posted by LarsP

How do you guys get fights to decisions in this game? Literally al but one of my fights ended with a finish. It's either me getting finished or my opponents getting reckless and counter KO'd.

I’ve had a few online. Offline, I have to drop the damage slider by 1.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[jcas007]

Quote: Originally Posted by MaccaC

Don't usually get annoyed by decisions but this one seems absurd. Clearly lost rounds 3-4 but VERY clearly won every aspect of the fight in 1-2-5

Have u seen some of the judges in the UFC the suck too , but I know what u mean I felt the same way about UFC 2

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk