Warrick Dunn or Brian Westbrook?

[LoG05]

In my 2nd year of my dynasty, I can either re-sign Warrick Dunn or pick up Brian Westbrook from free agency. I am using the Falcons, I was thinking Dunn might be better since he fits what I run on offense very well, but Westbrook is younger. Who do you guys think I would be better off with?

[cbgatorade0202]

I'd say go with Brian Westbrook but thats really a choice you'd have to make, How good did you did with Warrick Dunn also would be the question, How many yards a carry and such? Do you use TJ Duckett a lot or not? Do u run with Vick and how much?

[NickChew]

My personal choice, I would re-sign Dunn. Using simulation style edits, of course (gamechewover.com...shameless plug, haha), Dunn would be more of an all around RB that can take it inside as well. Age and durability would come into question, so a long term deal would probably be out of the question. Tough call though, but ultimately Dunn's running expierence would win out for me and the offense I would run.

[LoG05]

Quote: Originally Posted by cbgatorade0202

I'd say go with Brian Westbrook but thats really a choice you'd have to make, How good did you did with Warrick Dunn also would be the question, How many yards a carry and such? Do you use TJ Duckett a lot or not? Do u run with Vick and how much?

well, to answer your question...Dunn had 5.8avg per carry. I don't use TJ a lot unless it's in a critical 3rd & short play. As for Vick I only run with him if I have to (4th quarter comeback)