Who thinks that 2k5 is on par with 360 Madden?

[Mystery Ridah]

Quote: Originally Posted by 2krules

But I think 2K5 is the best football game ever.

I dont know why, but i think 2k4 is a tad bit better then 2k5. I also own 2k2 on dreamcast and 2k2 on xbox and 2k3 on xbox. I own the whole 2k collection expect for 2k and 2k1 on dreamcast.

Nevertheless, i think if you dont own 2k2 and 2k3 and 2k4 on xbox, you might need to pick it up and add it along with 2k5. Each 2k game on xbox is like a whole different game, trust me.

2K2(xbox) has the best replys ever in a football game, it has matrix style effects and all kinds of effects. 2K3 is best for the rain effects and running game. 2K4 is best for its overall gameplay, and the passing game is cool too. 2k5 is best for its graphics ( perfect , expect for a few faces ) and the passing game and options are the best.

[2krules]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mystery Ridah

I dont know why, but i think 2k4 is a tad bit better then 2k5. I also own 2k2 on dreamcast and 2k2 on xbox and 2k3 on xbox. I own the whole 2k collection expect for 2k and 2k1 on dreamcast. Nevertheless, i think if you dont own 2k2 and 2k3 and 2k4 on xbox, you might need to pick it up and add it along with 2k5. Each 2k game on xbox is like a whole different game, trust me.

I loved 2k4 - when I could actually play it. There were freezes galore for me. 2k5 never freezes. I've owned every 2k game, back to when it started on Dreamcast. What a shame to see 2K football go bye bye.

[Nza]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mystery Ridah

I dont know why, but i think 2k4 is a tad bit better then 2k5.

I do - the CPU AI actually know how to play football in 2K4.

[Nirvana]

This game is so much better than the Madden on 360. The controls aren't as good, IMO.