Like I said, there are good people at some stores, but by and large their customer service is terrible. At least in my area.
While I agree with you that a customer should research a product to make sure it fits his needs before the purchase, this doesn't always work out. For example: a frequent situation involved someone coming into the store to buy a game for a nephew, cousin, etc. but didn't know what games the kid has already. Or maybe they only had a vague idea what the kid likes to play. Maybe the relative has no idea what version of that Naruto or Yu Gi Oh game the kiddo wants. In that case, as an employee all you can do is try to guess what the kid will like or try desperately to steer the customer towards a gift card so the kid can come get exactly what he wants. You do have to make sure that the customer knows about the return policy, but not all Gamestops do this.
This customer might buy a game the kid already has, or one the kid doesn't like or simply is too difficult for him to get the hang of.
The return policy should take things like this into account. Especially when it comes to the "new" games they sell that have had the cellophane removed to make a wall display. If a customer buys that copy and doesn't like it, as long as it's still in new condition, what's wrong with helping that customer out and making the return or an exchange?
It's good that you found a store or two that treats you well. By all means, shop there. But you are in the minority when it comes to finding decent service inside of a Gamestop\EB. They don't treat their DM's, Managers, or ASM's very well, so it only follows that their customer service would be suspect. I guess I've worked in retail too long so I expect more, and maybe I should relax a bit, but when I ask a clerk to perform a simple, logical function of her job and she flat refuses my request, there's a problem there.
Also, renting a game in my town costs around eight bucks. I pretty well know whether or not I'll like a game beforehand so I don't run into the situation, but games are expensive enough without adding to the cost for a trial run. Most people aren't willing to pony up for that.
This thread reminds me of an article I read recently written by a Gamestop manager who got tired of all the Gamestop bashing he was reading about. It addresses certain isses both employees and customers face all the time, and is well worth the read if you ever wondered about Gamestop policy.
It can be found here:
http://www.gamervision.com/gamer/coo...mestop_manager
If this guy ran the Gamestop by my house, I would likely not have any complaints, but my point of all this rambling is that he is the exception, not the rule.
So, I shop elsewhere. To each his own.