espn nfl 2k4 or espn nfl 2k5

[NiKeKiD23]

Where's the roster file?

[NewAgeOutlaw716]

Quote: Originally Posted by max929

Brand new to this forum but really glad I found it...my take is that 2k4 is overall the better game. After playing 2k4 it is really hard to go back to 2k5..I'll break it down the strengths of each game as I see it: 2K4: Lightning fast game play Possible 80 yard deep pass opposing QB's escape rather than just standing in have to work harder at getting to the QB, really have to develop technique Can choose Team high's arm bands and vented helmets 2K5: More comprehensive salary strucure More uniform selections More adjustments available on defense, take a player out of his zone and assign him to a particular defender, putting a player into blitz Conclusion: 2K4 has better game play, is more intuitive and offers more uniform design options. I am splitting hairs here as 2K5 is an awesome game, just not as awesome as the year before

I agree 2K4 is overall a better game than 2K5

[NewAgeOutlaw716]

Quote: Originally Posted by Matt23134

Do you agree that 2K5 feels sluggish? This may be because it is trying to simulate momentum and locomotion, but it just feels sluggish to me. Does 2k4 feel like that?

No i have both and NFL 2K4 is smoother only thing 2K5 has 2K4 on is presentation and it's not by much tbh 2K4 is the overall better football game