I just want to chime in on this subject. I'm currently in school for Graphics & Game development, so you guys know where I stand on this issue.
But the reason I feel that way is because alot of gamers are not just game fans, but they are also sports fans (as I am). So it is unfair to say all that other stuff like Franchise and Owner is fluff. EA said it themselves "if its in the game.." you know the rest.
Therefore, if part of the NFL experience is the chance for a guy to join your team via free agency in real life and you have the capabilities to do it in the game, then I want to do it to. Does that make me a casual gamer? I don't think so, but others have their opinions.
Like it or not signing bonuses and holdouts are just as much a part of the NFL as flat passes and zone coverage.
In short all I'm saying is, if you are going to make a game based on reality......I WANT IT ALL!!!!!!