What is the difference between NFL 2k4 and NFL 2k5?

[steelerman59]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cardot

Kick off returns were too easy in 2k4 (common to get out past the 40)....and too hard in 2K5 (tough to get much past the 20) from what I recall.

I'd say running the ball in general was too easy in 2k4. Not only was there no momentum but it was a lot easier to break tackles on top of it.

[Idpmofo]

Less CPU controlled nonsense. Like when your RB stutter steps on your controlled player.
Overall much more control of the game in 2k4… which people may call arcade-style but it’s a video game. Being able to manipulate the game does not make it less sim. Easier to manually catch. Out routes are easier, less throwing out of bounds
2k4 is a better game as far as playability.