On a scale of 1-10 rate the following....

[matt34652000]

Madden
--------------
EA Bios- 4
Franchise Mode- 8
Owner Mode- 8
Stat Tracking- 8
Player Models- 7
Presentation- 5
Lasting Appeal- 7
Polish- 7

ESPN 2k4
-------------------
The CRIB- 6
First Person Football- 9
Franchise Mode- 6
Presentation- 10
Lasting Appeal- 9
Player Models- 9
Stat tracking- 8
Polish- 10

[xxzone]

Quote:

---

texdirtbag said:
Madden
--------------
EA Bios - 8
Franchise Mode - 7
Owner Mode - 10
Stat Tracking - 8
Player Models - 6
Presentation - 5
Lasting Appeal - 6
Polish - 7

ESPN 2k4
-------------------
The CRIB - 7
First Person Football - 9
Franchise Mode - 8
Presentation - 10
Lasting Appeal - 10
Player Models - 9
Stat tracking - 6
Polish - 10

if ESPN had owner mode, it would be the PERFECT game.

---

I agree 100%. I played madded for 3 seasons, just for the owner mode, and I really got sick of playing the football games. If ESPN added that AHHWWWWWW DAMMMNNNN!

[Kanobi]

Madden
--------------
EA Bios 5
Franchise Mode 6
Owner Mode 8
Stat Tracking 9
Player Models 6
Presentation 4
Lasting Appeal 7
Polish 7

ESPN 2k4
-------------------
The CRIB 6
First Person Football 8
Franchise Mode 8
Presentation 10
Lasting Appeal 8
Player Models 8
Stat tracking 7
Polish 9

[Jistic]

Madden
--------------
EA Bios - 5
Franchise Mode - n/a
Owner Mode - 10
Stat Tracking - 9
Player Models - 7
Presentation - 5
Lasting Appeal - 8
Polish - 7

ESPN 2k4
-------------------
The CRIB - 1
First Person Football - 1
Franchise Mode - 6
Presentation - 10
Lasting Appeal - 8
Player Models - 8
Stat tracking - 4
Polish - 10

[sportsgeist]

Madden
--------------
EA Bios - 2
Franchise Mode - n/a
Owner Mode - 8
Stat Tracking - 7
Player Models - 5
Presentation - 1
Lasting Appeal - 5
Polish - 7

ESPN 2k4
-------------------
The CRIB - 7
First Person Football - 7
Franchise Mode - 8
Presentation - 10
Lasting Appeal - 9
Player Models - 10
Stat tracking - 8
Polish - 9

[MMan]

Madden
--------------
EA Bios- 6
Franchise Mode- 9
Owner Mode- 9
Stat Tracking- 8
Player Models- 5
Presentation- 4
Lasting Appeal- 6
Polish- 6

ESPN 2k4
-------------------
The CRIB- 7 (would be higher if unlockables at all levs)
First Person Football- 10 (people give up learning it)
Franchise Mode- 7
Presentation- 10
Lasting Appeal- 9
Player Models- 9
Stat tracking- 8
Polish- 7

---