First thing you have to do is create playbook for a specific team. Don’t go into manage substitutions to create your playbook because it will give you a default playbook for the league even if you select Create New Book From Team. The Create New Book From Team option in the Manage Substitution module is very deceiving because you think you are creating a playbook for a team when you are not. This is what you do
First go to Manage Playbook option and when Create Playbook from comes up select Team Book. Select the team you want to use. Then save it as whatever you want to call it. Next you will see the edit playbook screen just back out unless you want to edit your playbook.
Now you can go to Manage Substitutions. Select the playbook that you created. Select Edit Existing Book. You will notice that the team that you select for your playbook in Manage Playbook will is now showing. Now make you substitutions.
All you have to do now is when the TEAMSELECT screen comes up hit the Y button for the Xbox to go to options or if you have ps2 just look at the bottom right and it should tell you what button to push. Once in options you will see AWAY Playbook and HOME Playbook. Select whichever playbook your team will be using and scroll over until you see the playbook that you created earlier and you done.
I hope this works for you. Good luck.