Not meaning to be rude or disrespectful but I've seen you ask a simular question like this before and seen your thread moved, then I saw someone reply that a possible flame may come out of this inquiry and now here you are again.
You're pushing this bro and have been given several answers in kind to this and simular questions all answered and replied to at one time or another and still you continuie to ask these somewhat odd and akward questions.
heres a suggestion from one of the many people here who do rosters and edits for the video games you're inquiring about....play them and find out what works for you, your questions are not needed if you take the time to PLAY the game and DL the numerious rosters available.
There is no BEST all of them have their points and degrees of gameplay if only you take the time to actually play them for yourself and see what fits your playing style.
The guys here do an excellent job IMO of providing rosters to the members and non-members here and charge no fee for doing them so why don't you stop attempting to start up a competitive thing in a bad way here by asking which one is best. We are all very good at what we do present company included and respect one anothers work as a matter of respect.
You won't find bragging rights or self promotion as one of us being the best we don't get into that kind of thing here at Operation Sports thus avoiding a FLAME WAR or simular incidents sorry that kind of this does not happen here and we all get along just find so again see for yourself and stop asking these questions that have already been addressed to you and now by me personally because what you're attempting to do is not a good thing so stop and PLAY the game for yourself and stop asking guys to think and decide for you.
If I'm coming across as a hard baller its because you're asking us to think and decide for you and no one in their right mind is willing to do that judging from the responses you're getting.
You almost sound like you have no knowledge of Football what-so-ever so heres another suggestion...learn the game and what its about then watch and observer its many varations and styles of play then perhaps you'll realize that the best is just something thats not all that simple a thing to describe its Football American style and there are many guys here who have different ways of presenting the game in a video game format some better then others but as for the best it doesn't exist they're all the best depending on what YOU like or don't like about them so DL some rosters and spend more time playing and less asking what is this and what is that, again play the game bro and find out what works for you.
DL as in download and play them see what you like man up, and make a choice its that simple, these guys are all the best just pick one!
Holla Back ya'll
Rickster101 aka "Jack Bauer"
There is a fifth dimension beyond that which is known to man. It is a dimension as vast as space and as timeless as infinity. It is the middle ground between light and shadow, between science and superstition, and it lies between the pit of man's fears and the summit of his knowledge. This is the dimension of imagination. It is an area which we call … The Twilight Zone aka "OS...Da Spot".
— Rod Serling