A new feature ? A dark secret ?

[Azamien]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

I'm fairly certain I had a challenge at first on a double play call (while on offense).

As for HR challenges, they are definitely still present. I've seen a few already (twice in exhibition and once in RTTS...although with the RTTS one it gave me the points breakdown for a HR despite it being called foul initially. So the suspense of the challenge was non-existent).

Weird. I play mainly in franchise with quick counts. I wonder if either one of those is screwing with reviews.

[Greencollarbaseball]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

I was able to challenge a play while on defense. I have a video of it. The play was at first.

I've had a challenge on defense also, oddly enough it was the only one I've lost.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[COMMISSIONERHBK9]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

During last name game I got to do a challenge. I almost miss it cuz it only gives u 15 seconds to challenge or not. But good job for putting it in

[bellz666]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

I've played 14 games now and had one challenge at first base...and lost the challenge. It's frustrating as I've had quite a few close plays that I thought could be a challenge.

[trankins24]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

I've seen a few reviews on both fair/foul homeruns as well as plays at first. It's a random trigger. I'm in agreement with everyone else, would love to see more on plays at the plate. To make the game more realistic, we should have the catcher blocking the plate reviews.

[Bacong]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

replay feature is basically useless. every time it comes up for me it's plainly obvious one way or the other. it's never been close.

[Go Yankees]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

I would like to know why they implemented a challenge system that isnt even close to real life, I hate to say this but it reminds me alot of Madden and the same unreal challenge system they have had since EA implemented it, But NFL 2k5 had the best challenge system out of any game, Remember that NFL 2k5 came out in 2005, Ten years later........ How does this happen? So i hope in future The shows they will implement this correctly, I hope!

[Keirik]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

Yeah, I had seen them prior to this year, but none this year. Not a single time, despite foul balls being called home runs.

Well, im just pointing it out because I've for certain seen the HR review in this years game. Saw it a couple of weeks ago in Franchise and i didn't even have the game last year.

[Azamien]

Re: A new feature ? A dark secret ?

Well, im just pointing it out because I've for certain seen the HR review in this years game. Saw it a couple of weeks ago in Franchise and i didn't even have the game last year.

I believe you. I'm just more interested in why I'm not seeing any. My first thought was that it's because I turned check swing appeals off and that there's something haywire that makes it affect more than just check swings, but I had them off last year, too, and saw plenty of home run reviews.