Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

[franch1se]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

hey Bard, I was reading your initial post and it gives great detail for positional players, but what about for Pitchers? Also, what about for guys who don't have 3 years of WAR built up?

[Bard]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

hey Bard, I was reading your initial post and it gives great detail for positional players, but what about for Pitchers? Also, what about for guys who don't have 3 years of WAR built up?

Pitchers would be the same! Just take their WAR.

Less than 3 years is so tough. I just try to do a modified version, so the most recent WAR times 6, if they have two years times by 6 then 3. No service time, try to find them on a top 100-200 list for prospects.

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

[boxers]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

What a trade for Cal Quantrill look like if I'm the Marlins? I'd be willing to take on the Wil Myers contract as well.

[Bard]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

What a trade for Cal Quantrill look like if I'm the Marlins? I'd be willing to take on the Wil Myers contract as well.

Tough call. Top 50 prospect in 2018, fell off that season and 2019 he was very meh in MLB.

Padres will want value for him, but I would say $15 million is his surplus. Not much, bottom end top 100 pitcher value at absolute highest.

Ryne Stanek comes in at around $13.2 million in surplus.

Marlins Receive:
Cal Quantrill

Padres Receive:
Ryne Stanek
Lotto ticket

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

[boxers]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Much appreciated. Stanek is great in-game, so that would be a tough deal but pretty fair. Any suggestions on trading Villar and acquiring Matthew Boyd from the Tigers?

Tough call. Top 50 prospect in 2018, fell off that season and 2019 he was very meh in MLB.

Padres will want value for him, but I would say $15 million is his surplus. Not much, bottom end top 100 pitcher value at absolute highest.

Ryne Stanek comes in at around $13.2 million in surplus.

Marlins Receive:
Cal Quantrill

Padres Receive:
Ryne Stanek
Lotto ticket

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

[Bard]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Much appreciated. Stanek is great in-game, so that would be a tough deal but pretty fair. Any suggestions on trading Villar and acquiring Matthew Boyd from the Tigers?

Jonathan Villar is worth around $21 million in surplus. Meaning he could nab one bottom end pitcher in the top 100. He is a pretty valuable guy to have around.

Boyd is worth around $65 million in surplus, as he is quite valuable.

Marlins Receive:
Matthew Boyd $65


Tigers Receive:
JJ Bleday $51
Edward Cabrera $13
Lotto ticket

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

[MFrigge2]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Any suggestions on what I could get for Keone Kela and Adam Frazier respectively? I’d be willing to throw in joe Musgrove into either deal as well.

I’m also thinking about trading Chris Archer but I’m hesitant cause I’m not sure if that would be too many trades on one deadline day.

[BoNity]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Hey guys. Forgive me, I don't post on here often but I'm making an effort this year with some free time.

My Tigers are in full sell mode right now of the current roster and I'm gauging interest around the league for our players. Vets and prospects. I'm very much as interested in flowndoring or unwanted, yet capable vets, as I am in prospects. We aren't rebuilding the farm system, we are assembling a competitor.

Also, Khris Davis and Franklin Barretto have been on my radar.

Thanks, Detroit.

[Bard]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Any suggestions on what I could get for Keone Kela and Adam Frazier respectively? I’d be willing to throw in joe Musgrove into either deal as well.

I’m also thinking about trading Chris Archer but I’m hesitant cause I’m not sure if that would be too many trades on one deadline day.

Keone Kela is worth $5.37 million in surplus. So, not much at all.

Adam Frazier is worth $47.1 million in surplus. He could land a prospect in the top 100 and a lotto ticket.

Joe Musgrove is worth $28.6 so he definitely has some value on the trade market.

Depends on teams contending and such that are looking for a cheap RP. Then to land a good utility option that is a starter and a pitcher that can start or relieve.

Hey guys. Forgive me, I don't post on here often but I'm making an effort this year with some free time.

My Tigers are in full sell mode right now of the current roster and I'm gauging interest around the league for our players. Vets and prospects. I'm very much as interested in flowndoring or unwanted, yet capable vets, as I am in prospects. We aren't rebuilding the farm system, we are assembling a competitor.

Also, Khris Davis and Franklin Barretto have been on my radar.

Thanks, Detroit.

Khris Davis is worth -$14.3 million at this point. He is not valuable whatsoever.

Franklin Barretto is difficult. He has had three years of attempts in the pros, but barely is over 200 at bats for his career. His negative career WAR and future earnings would put him at around -$30 million in surplus, which isn't correct. He isn't worth much anymore, but I would still give him a positive $10 million in surplus due to his cheapness, age, and service time.

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

[MrSerendipity]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

I've been thinking about making some moves in my Rangers franchise whenever the new rosters drop. Thoughts on these?

BAL Receives:
Willie Calhoun
Leodys Taveras
Chris Seise

TEX Receives:
Trey Mancini
__________________________________

SF Receives:
Jonathan Hernadez
Ariel Jurado

TEX Receives:
Dereck Rodriguez

[Bard]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

I've been thinking about making some moves in my Rangers franchise whenever the new rosters drop. Thoughts on these?

BAL Receives:
Willie Calhoun
Leodys Taveras
Chris Seise

TEX Receives:
Trey Mancini
__________________________________

SF Receives:
Jonathan Hernadez
Ariel Jurado

TEX Receives:
Dereck Rodriguez

I've been thinking about making some moves in my Rangers franchise whenever the new rosters drop. Thoughts on these?

BAL Receives:
Willie Calhoun $17
Leodys Taveras $15
Chris Seise $15

TEX Receives:
Trey Mancini $41.9
__________________________________

SF Receives:
Jonathan Hernadez $
Ariel Jurado $

TEX Receives:
Dereck Rodriguez$

Trade one. Taveras and Seise should probably be worth more, but they are just young. Neither are on the top 100 yet, but both have value. I think that deal works out fine.

Giants would likely not deal Dereck, yet. No reason to. You are buying low on him. His first year was solid, and his second year was...bad. Any different way I do his calculation it comes out negative, and he isn't a negative player. I'll go ahead and veto any D-Rod deals.

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

[MrSerendipity]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Trade one. Taveras and Seise should probably be worth more, but they are just young. Neither are on the top 100 yet, but both have value. I think that deal works out fine.

Giants would likely not deal Dereck, yet. No reason to. You are buying low on him. His first year was solid, and his second year was...bad. Any different way I do his calculation it comes out negative, and he isn't a negative player. I'll go ahead and veto any D-Rod deals.

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

As for the first trade, thank you bud. On the second, that is Pudge's son you're telling me I can't have! Lol. I thought about including Garcia instead of Hernandez. Younger, higher upside and from California. But I do agree that buying Rodriguez might be buying too low this year.

[joshrmlb]

Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Wow, I never knew that was his son! TIL


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[CesspoolofGreatness]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Speaking of Joey Gallo, is it at all possible to get Joey Gallo and Willie Calhoun to the white sox, preferably with either Encarnacion or Abreu as part of the package?

[Bard]

Re: Official MLB 20 the Show Trade Discussion Thread

Speaking of Joey Gallo, is it at all possible to get Joey Gallo and Willie Calhoun to the white sox, preferably with either Encarnacion or Abreu as part of the package?

1. Yes it is possible.

2. Rangers wouldn't want either of those guys in a return deal.

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk