2010/11 PG Discussion

[parker987]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

I think there should be a debate on if Rondo is a tier 1 pg

[PrettyT11]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

I think there should be a debate on if Rondo is a tier 1 pg

Why exactly?? Rondo has been by far the most discussed PG around here for the past 2 to 3 years. There isn't really anything that hasn't been said about Rondo and his game that hasn't already been said and discussed.

[TheMatrix31]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

There should be a debate on Nash still being a Tier 1 PG.

Because he is.

He's still averaging 17/11, and shooting 50/40/90. Despite having a significantly ****tier team, and a ton of turnover and instability. The guy still holds any Suns game in the palm of his hands.

[Jukeman]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

I still don't believe in the "tiers"

If anything, the likes of CP3, DWil, and etc are all "tier 1"

They are all game changers.

[parker987]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

There should be a debate on Nash still being a Tier 1 PG.

Because he is.

He's still averaging 17/11, and shooting 50/40/90. Despite having a significantly ****tier team, and a ton of turnover and instability. The guy still holds any Suns game in the palm of his hands.

Yeah, i agree, he is the best offensive PG of all leading a completely **** suns.

[Jasong7777]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

Is it wrong of me to say that I would take Rondo over CP3?

My Top Point Guards
1. D Williams
2. Rondo
3. CP3
4. Rose
5. Westbrook

Yeah. In that order.

[da ThRONe]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

Is it wrong of me to say that I would take Rondo over CP3?

My Top Point Guards
1. D Williams
2. Rondo
3. CP3
4. Rose
5. Westbrook

Yeah. In that order.

There is no wrong since it's all based on opinion ,but I would argue Paul is in a 3 way tie for 2nd best player in the league clearly putting him ahead of all other PG's.

This season alone CP3 is coming off major knee surgury and IMO still clearly looks like the top PG.

[Chrisksaint]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

CP3 lacks the Points he's normally put up and so far has 0 triple doubles, but it's really hard for me to argue against efficiency he has and the defense.

[parker987]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

My picks are

1. Deron WIlliams
2. CP3
3. Derrick Rose
4. Rajon Rondo
5. Steve Nash/Russell Westbrook

Steve Nash is still leading the team to a superior level despite having bad players. He is averaging 17/11 and is one of the best floor generals ever

[iAM-IncReDiBLe-]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

My picks are

1. Deron WIlliams
2. CP3
3. Derrick Rose
4. Rajon Rondo
5. Steve Nash/Russell Westbrook

Steve Nash is still leading the team to a superior level despite having bad players. He is averaging 17/11 and is one of the best floor generals ever

I'm good with Deron William. Has the whole package plus the size to do things in the post if need be. CP3/Rose a close 2nd for me.

[cubsball899]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

please enlighten me on what Deron Williams does that Rose doesn't do at least as good or better?

[Jasong7777]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

please enlighten me on what Deron Williams does that Rose doesn't do at least as good or better?

People will probably say pass and defend.

[AlexBrady]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

please enlighten me on what Deron Williams does that Rose doesn't do at least as good or better?

-Williams can post up on offense and is harder to post on defense
-Can run an offense better than Rose currently
-Better court awareness and screen/roll passer

[jeebs9]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

In my opinion Deron Williams and Derrick Rose just don't make as any steals like Paul and Rondo.

[AlexBrady]

Re: 2010/11 PG Discussion

In my opinion Deron Williams and Derrick Rose just don't make as any steals like Paul and Rondo.

Williams is a more fundamental defender while Rose is the sniping kind. Either way, point guard is easily the toughest position to guard. Gambling for steals at the point position is actually very counterintuitive since it leaves your teammates at risk.